HSC Study

Chemical Synthesis and Design

The factors weighed when designing a chemical synthesis (reagent availability, reaction conditions, yield and purity, industrial uses, and environmental, social and economic issues), with yield, purity and atom economy calculations and green chemistry.

90 min · Module 8: Applying Chemical Ideas

Assumes you have read Analysis of Organic Substances.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

  • Design starts from the product and works backwards (retrosynthesis) to available starting materials.
  • Reagents must be cheap, plentiful and reliably supplied. Plants are sited near raw materials, energy and markets.
  • Conditions (temperature, pressure, concentration, catalyst) are a compromise between yield, rate, cost and safety.
  • Percentage yield = actual mass ÷ theoretical mass × 100. In a multistep route, the step yields multiply, so fewer sequential steps is better.
  • Purity = mass of product in sample ÷ mass of sample × 100. It matters most for pharmaceuticals.
  • Atom economy = molar mass of desired product ÷ total molar mass of reactants × 100.
  • Issues: energy use and emissions, waste and spills; jobs, safety and useful products; cost, profit and location. Green chemistry tries to prevent waste in the first place.

Designing a synthesis

Retrosynthesis. Start with the target molecule and ask what could react to make it, then repeat until you reach cheap, available starting materials. There is often more than one route. The routes are then compared by reagent availability, conditions, yield and purity, and their environmental, social and economic costs.

Pathways. Most syntheses have several steps. The product of one step (an intermediate) becomes a reactant in the next.

  • In a linear route, each step follows the one before. The contact process is linear: S → SO₂ → SO₃ → H₂SO₄.
  • In a convergent route, separate branches make pieces that are joined at the end. Making an ester is convergent: the alcohol and the acid are made separately, then combined.

Since step yields multiply, a convergent route usually gives a higher overall yield than a linear route with the same number of steps.

Linear: 4 steps in sequenceABCDproduct80%80%80%80%overall 0.80 × 0.80 × 0.80 × 0.80 = 41%Convergent: 2 branches, then combineABXEFY80%80%80%80%product80%each branch 0.80 × 0.80 = 64%; overall 0.64 × 0.80 = 51%
Two routes, each with four steps at 80% yield. The linear route passes through all four steps in sequence, for 41% overall. The convergent route has only three steps in sequence, for 51%.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A chemist wants to make ethyl ethanoate using ethene as the only organic starting material. Which route works?

Select one answer

Hint 1Need both ethanol and ethanoic acid.

Hint 2Ethanol from hydration.

Hint 3Acid by oxidising ethanol.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A target molecule can be made by a linear route of four steps, or a convergent route where two 2-step branches are made separately and then combined in one final step. Every step has an 80% yield. Which statement is correct?

Select one answer

Hint 1Linear: 0.8⁴.

Hint 2Convergent: 0.8² × 0.8.

Hint 3Compare.

Availability of reagents

Reagents must be available in large, reliable quantities and at low cost. Otherwise the product is too expensive. The Haber process takes N₂ from air and H₂ mostly from natural gas, so ammonia plants are built near gas supplies. Transport costs push plants towards raw materials, cheap energy, water and markets. Non-renewable feedstocks such as crude oil will become scarcer, so renewable feedstocks such as biomass are being developed.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Which factor is least likely to decide where a new chemical plant is built?

Select one answer

Hint 1Raw materials, energy, markets.

Hint 2Transport and workforce.

Hint 3Safety distance.

Exam question

Standard · about 5 min

3 marks

Explain why the availability of reagents is important when designing an industrial synthesis, using an example.

Hint 1Cost and supply.

Hint 2Location near raw materials.

Hint 3Renewable vs non-renewable.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Only saying the reagents must be "available".

    Why it happens: Explain why: cost, supply, transport.

    Link to viability.

Written for this site.

Reaction conditions

Conditions are chosen using what you know about rates and equilibrium:

  • Temperature. Higher temperatures give a faster rate. For an exothermic reaction, though, they lower K and the equilibrium yield. A moderate temperature with a catalyst is the usual compromise.
  • Pressure. For gases, higher pressure favours the side with fewer moles of gas and raises the rate. But it costs more in equipment and energy, and it is less safe.
  • Concentration. Adding excess of a cheap reactant, or removing product, shifts the equilibrium right.
  • Catalyst. A catalyst gives a pathway with lower activation energy. It speeds up both directions equally, so it does not change the yield. It allows a lower temperature at an acceptable rate, which saves energy.
  • Recycling. Unreacted reactants are fed back in, so almost all of them are eventually converted.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Why is a catalyst used in an industrial equilibrium process such as the Haber process?

Select one answer

Hint 1Catalyst lowers activation energy.

Hint 2Equilibrium position unchanged.

Hint 3Lower temperature possible.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

In the Haber process, ammonia is liquefied and removed, and unreacted N₂ and H₂ are recycled. What is the main purpose?

Select one answer

Hint 1Le Chatelier.

Hint 2Remove product → shift right.

Hint 3Recycling uses reactants fully.

Exam question

Harder · about 7 min

4 marks

The Haber process is exothermic: N₂ + 3H₂ ⇌ 2NH₃, ΔH = −92 kJ mol⁻¹. Explain why a moderate temperature (about 400–500 °C) and high pressure (about 150–300 atm) are used.

Hint 1Temperature: yield vs rate.

Hint 2Pressure: 4 mol gas → 2 mol gas.

Hint 3Cost and safety.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Saying high temperature increases yield.

    Why it happens: For an exothermic reaction it lowers K.

    It is used for rate.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Harder · about 7 min

4 marks

Explain the reaction conditions used to prepare ethyl ethanoate in the laboratory, and how the product is purified.

Hint 1Reflux, catalyst, excess.

Hint 2Separating funnel with Na₂CO₃.

Hint 3Distillation.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Heating in an open beaker.

    Why it happens: Volatile reactants and product escape.

    Use reflux.

Written for this site.

Common mistake

A catalyst is used to increase the yield.

Why it happens: A catalyst speeds up the forward and reverse reactions equally.

The equilibrium position and K do not change. A catalyst increases the rate, which lets the process run at a lower temperature that favours the product.

Yield and purity

Theoretical yield is the mass of product if all of the limiting reagent reacted. Percentage yield compares the actual mass with the theoretical mass. Yields are lower than 100% because of equilibrium, side reactions, and losses during transfer and purification.

Worked example3 marks

Percentage yield of an ester

10.0 g of ethanoic acid (60.05 g mol) is refluxed with excess ethanol. 9.50 g of ethyl ethanoate (88.11 g mol) is obtained. Find the percentage yield.

Moles of limiting reagent

Ethanol is in excess.

mol.

Theoretical mass

The mole ratio is 1 : 1.

g.

Percentage yield

Actual over theoretical.

.

Answer

64.7%.

Is that answer sensible?

Esterification is an equilibrium, and some ester is lost in washing and distillation, so a yield well below 100% is expected.

Purity is the percentage of the sample that is the wanted product. You find it by titration, gravimetric analysis or instrumental analysis. Purification (washing, recrystallisation, distillation) raises purity, but it adds cost and lowers the yield. Checks for purity include:

  • a sharp melting point at the known value;
  • an IR fingerprint that matches the reference;
  • a single spot or peak in chromatography.

In pharmaceuticals, impurities or the wrong isomer can be harmful, so purity standards are very strict.

Atom economy measures how much of the reactants' mass ends up in the product:

Addition reactions have 100% atom economy. Substitution, condensation and elimination reactions always make a by-product.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Which type of reaction has a 100% atom economy?

Select one answer

Hint 1No by-products.

Hint 2All atoms end up in product.

Hint 3Alkene + water → alcohol.

Exam question

Standard · about 5 min

3 marks

10.0 g of ethanoic acid (60.05 g mol⁻¹) is refluxed with excess ethanol and a sulfuric acid catalyst. After purification, 9.50 g of ethyl ethanoate (88.11 g mol⁻¹) is obtained. Calculate the percentage yield.

Hint 1Ethanoic acid is limiting.

Hint 21 : 1 mole ratio.

Hint 3Actual ÷ theoretical.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Dividing the ester mass by the acid mass.

    Why it happens: Different substances; convert through moles.

    Find theoretical mass first.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Standard · about 5 min

3 marks

Aspirin (180.16 g mol⁻¹) is made from salicylic acid (138.12 g mol⁻¹) and excess ethanoic anhydride in a 1 : 1 mole ratio. 5.00 g of salicylic acid gives 4.89 g of dry aspirin. Calculate the percentage yield.

Hint 1Salicylic acid is limiting.

Hint 2Theoretical mass = n × M(aspirin).

Hint 3Divide.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Using 4.89/5.00.

    Why it happens: The masses belong to different compounds.

    Use moles.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Harder · about 7 min

4 marks

14.0 g of N₂ reacts with 4.0 g of H₂ in a Haber process reactor: N₂ + 3H₂ ⇌ 2NH₃. 3.40 g of NH₃ (17.03 g mol⁻¹) is collected. Calculate the percentage yield.

Hint 1Find the limiting reagent.

Hint 2n(N₂) = 0.500, n(H₂) = 1.98.

Hint 3H₂ needed = 3 × 0.500.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Using H₂ as the limiting reagent.

    Why it happens: Check the mole ratio 1 : 3.

    Compare required with available.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Standard · about 3 min

2 marks

A three-step linear synthesis has step yields of 80%, 70% and 90%. Calculate the overall percentage yield.

Hint 1Yields multiply.

Hint 2Convert to decimals.

Hint 30.80 × 0.70 × 0.90.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Averaging the yields.

    Why it happens: Each step works on what is left from the previous step.

    Multiply.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Standard · about 3 min

2 marks

A 2.00 g sample of synthesised aspirin is analysed by titration and found to contain 1.84 g of aspirin. Calculate its percentage purity.

Hint 1Purity = pure mass ÷ sample mass.

Hint 2× 100.

Hint 3Not a yield.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Confusing purity with yield.

    Why it happens: Yield compares with theoretical; purity compares with the sample mass.

    Divide by the sample.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Harder · about 4 min

2 marks

Ethene can be made by dehydrating ethanol: C₂H₅OH → C₂H₄ + H₂O. Calculate the atom economy for making ethene (C₂H₄ 28.05, C₂H₅OH 46.07 g mol⁻¹).

Hint 1Atom economy = M(desired)/M(all reactants).

Hint 2One reactant.

Hint 3× 100.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Including the water as a desired product.

    Why it happens: Only the wanted product counts.

    Desired over reactants.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Harder · about 5 min

3 marks

Explain why purity is critical in pharmaceutical synthesis, and describe two ways the purity of a synthesised product can be checked.

Hint 1Impurities may be toxic.

Hint 2Melting point.

Hint 3Spectra or chromatography.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Saying a high yield means high purity.

    Why it happens: Yield measures amount, not purity.

    Separate the ideas.

Written for this site.

Common mistake

Overall yield of steps at 80%, 70% and 90% is their average, 80%.

Why it happens: Each step only works on what the previous step produced.

Multiply the yields: 0.80 × 0.70 × 0.90 = 50.4%.

Industrial uses

  • Pharmaceuticals: aspirin from salicylic acid, and antibiotics. These need very high purity and often multistep routes.
  • Cosmetics: esters as fragrances, and emulsifiers.
  • Cleaning products: soaps by saponification of fats, and synthetic detergents from petrochemicals, which also work in hard water. Modern detergents use unbranched alkyl chains, so bacteria can break them down.
  • Fuels: biodiesel by transesterifying vegetable oils, and ethanol by fermentation or by hydrating ethene.

The use sets the priorities. A drug needs purity above all. A fuel or fertiliser needs a very large scale and a low cost.

Exam question

Standard · about 5 min

3 marks

Describe the industrial uses of chemical synthesis in two of the following: pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, cleaning products, fuels.

Hint 1Pharmaceuticals: aspirin, antibiotics.

Hint 2Cleaning: soaps and detergents.

Hint 3Fuels: biodiesel, ethanol.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Listing products without describing the synthesis.

    Why it happens: Name the reaction or feature.

    Give the process.

Written for this site.

Environmental, social and economic issues

  • Environmental:
    • energy use, often from fossil fuels, releases CO₂;
    • SO₂ and NOₓ emissions cause acid rain and photochemical smog;
    • waste and spills contaminate soil and water;
    • fertiliser run-off causes eutrophication.
    • Controls: scrubbers, recycling of unreacted gases, reuse of waste heat, and treating waste before it is released.
  • Social:
    • products that improve health, food supply and living standards;
    • jobs;
    • risks to workers and nearby communities. The Bhopal gas leak from a pesticide plant is the classic example.
    • Plants are sited away from housing, and they are regulated.
  • Economic:
    • the costs of reagents, energy, equipment and labour;
    • maximising output per unit time;
    • location near resources and markets;
    • the cost of meeting environmental laws.

Worked example5 marks

Evaluating two routes to ethanol

Ethanol can be made by fermenting glucose from crops, or by hydrating ethene from crude oil or natural gas. Evaluate the two processes for producing ethanol as a fuel.

Availability of reagents

Where does each feedstock come from?

Fermentation uses sugar or starch from crops such as sugarcane, which is renewable but competes with food production for land. Hydration uses ethene from fossil fuels, which is finite, though supplied reliably at large scale.

Reaction conditions

Link conditions to energy cost and rate.

Fermentation: yeast, about 35 °C, no oxygen, low energy but slow (days), run in batches. Hydration: over an H₃PO₄ catalyst at about 300 °C and high pressure. It is fast and continuous, but the heat and pressure cost energy and equipment.

Yield and purity

What must be done to the product?

Fermentation stops at about 15% ethanol, when the yeast dies, so energy-intensive distillation is needed. Hydration gives a low conversion on each pass, but unreacted ethene is recycled, so almost all of it is eventually converted, and the product is much purer.

Environmental, social and economic issues

Consider carbon, land and cost.

The CO₂ released when fermentation ethanol burns was recently absorbed by the crops, so it adds less to atmospheric CO₂. However, fertiliser, harvesting and distillation all use energy. Hydration adds fossil carbon but uses little land. Fermentation supports farming jobs; hydration depends on the oil price.

Answer

For a fuel, whose purpose is to reduce fossil carbon, fermentation is the better choice despite its slow rate and the energy needed to distil it, because its feedstock is renewable and it is closer to carbon neutral. Hydration is better where a large, continuous supply of pure ethanol matters most, such as an industrial solvent. The better route depends on what the ethanol is for.

Green chemistry aims to design processes that do less harm. The order of preference is to prevent waste, then recycle or reuse it, then treat it, and only then dispose of it safely. Its principles include:

  • high atom economy;
  • catalysts instead of reagents that are used up;
  • safer solvents (water or supercritical CO₂);
  • renewable feedstocks;
  • lower-energy conditions;
  • products that biodegrade.

Green polymers. Ethene can be made from cellulose instead of crude oil:

  1. Hydrolyse cellulose to glucose, using cellulase enzymes or dilute acid.
  2. Ferment the glucose to ethanol.
  3. Dehydrate the ethanol to ethene.

The feedstock is renewable and can come from plant waste. But breaking down cellulose is slow and costly, and it uses a lot of energy. The resulting polyethene is identical to the kind made from crude oil, so it is not biodegradable. Biodegradable plastics are made from biopolymers (such as starch or PHB made by bacteria), or by blending starch into synthetic polymers so that microbes break the material into fragments.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Why is polyethene made from bio-ethanol no more biodegradable than polyethene from crude oil?

Select one answer

Hint 1Same monomer.

Hint 2Same polymer structure.

Hint 3Source does not matter.

Exam question

Harder · about 5 min

3 marks

Outline three principles of green chemistry and explain how each reduces environmental impact.

Hint 1Prevent waste.

Hint 2Atom economy.

Hint 3Catalysts, safer solvents, renewable feedstocks.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Treating waste as the first priority.

    Why it happens: Prevention comes before treatment.

    Prevent first.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Harder · about 7 min

4 marks

Ethene for making polyethene can be produced from cellulose (plant waste) instead of crude oil. Outline the steps involved and evaluate this alternative.

Hint 1Cellulose → glucose → ethanol → ethene.

Hint 2Renewable, uses waste.

Hint 3Energy and cost.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Saying bio-based polyethene is biodegradable.

    Why it happens: The polymer is identical to polyethene from crude oil.

    Only the source changes.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 9 min

5 marks

Evaluate the environmental, social and economic issues associated with an industrial chemical synthesis such as the production of sulfuric acid or ammonia.

Hint 1Environmental: emissions, energy, spills.

Hint 2Social: jobs, safety, benefits of products.

Hint 3Economic: cost, profit, location.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Describing issues without a judgement.

    Why it happens: Evaluate means weigh up.

    End with a supported judgement.

Written for this site.

What lifts this to a Band 6

"Evaluate" needs a judgement. For a named process, give at least one specific point for each factor: reagents, conditions (with Le Chatelier and rate reasoning), yield and purity, use, and the environmental, social and economic issues. Then weigh them: state whether the benefits outweigh the costs, and under what controls.

Yield versus atom economy

A reaction can have a high percentage yield and still waste most of its atoms. Dehydrating ethanol to ethene can give nearly 100% yield, but its atom economy is only 61%, because water is always lost. Green chemistry cares about both: making product efficiently and not making by-products at all. This is why industry prefers addition reactions and catalytic routes wherever possible.

Why biodegradability depends on structure

Microbes break polymers down with enzymes that recognise particular bonds, such as ester and glycosidic links. Long chains of C–C bonds with no functional groups give enzymes nothing to attack, so polyethene lasts for a very long time. Polymers with hydrolysable links in their backbone, such as polyesters like PLA and PHB, can be broken down.