Centralised, Decentralised and Individual Wage Determination
The shift from centralised wage fixing to enterprise bargaining, the arguments for and against centralised, decentralised and individual methods of setting pay, the evidence on productivity, inflation, unemployment and inequality, the partial return to centralised elements since 2022, and an essay plan on the impacts of labour market reform.
40 min · HSC Topic Four - Economic Policies and Management
Assumes you have read Enterprise Agreements and Individual Contracts and High Income Earners.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
- Centralised: a tribunal sets wages and conditions for whole industries or the whole economy. Decentralised: wages are negotiated at each enterprise. Individualised: each employee negotiates with the employer.
- The shift. Until the 1980s wages were set centrally. The Accord (from 1983), enterprise bargaining (from 1991), the Workplace Relations Act 1996, Work Choices 2005 and the Fair Work Act 2009 moved Australia to a hybrid system: a centralised safety net with bargaining above it.
- For centralisation: fairness and comparative wage justice, protection of workers with little bargaining power, and a tool to restrain wages.
- Against centralisation: uniform increases ignored productivity, fuelled wage-price spirals, slowed structural change and brought more disputes. Inflation averaged about 9.4 per cent from 1970 to 1985.
- For decentralisation: pay linked to productivity, better allocation of labour, flexibility in downturns and a lower NAIRU. Productivity growth averaged about 2.2 per cent from 1991 to 2004.
- Against decentralisation: wider inequality, pay that reflects bargaining power rather than productivity, harder enforcement, and weak wages growth in the 2010s.
- Since 2022, reforms have moved partly back towards centralised elements: multi-employer bargaining, arbitration of intractable disputes, and larger minimum wage and award increases.
From centralised to decentralised
AnswersHow did Australia move from centralised to decentralised wage determination?
- Centralised wage determination
A system in which wages and conditions are set mainly by a government or industrial tribunal for whole industries or the whole economy, often through uniform increases.
- Decentralised wage determination
A system in which wages and conditions are set mainly through negotiations between employers and employees at the level of each enterprise or workplace, with a limited role for tribunals.
- Individualised wage determination
A system in which wages and conditions are negotiated between an employer and each employee, through individual contracts.
As your notes explain, Australia had a centralised system until the 1980s, reflecting strong unions and a culture of fairness: the same pay for the same work. The Australian Industrial Relations Commission set wages after hearing unions and employers. Because increases were not linked to productivity, the system contributed to cost-push inflation.
Key steps towards decentralisation
| Reform | What changed |
|---|---|
| Prices and Incomes Accord (1983 to 1996) | Unions agreed to wage restraint in return for the social wage, including Medicare and superannuation. From 1991 it encouraged enterprise bargaining linked to productivity |
| Workplace Relations Act 1996 | Expanded enterprise bargaining, introduced Australian Workplace Agreements and reduced the scope of awards |
| Work Choices 2005 | Removed the no-disadvantage test for AWAs, promoting individual contracts |
| Fair Work Act 2009 | Abolished AWAs, created modern awards and the NES, and made enterprise bargaining the centre of the system |
| Secure Jobs, Better Pay 2022 and Closing Loopholes 2023 and 2024 | Multi-employer bargaining, arbitration of intractable disputes, Same Job Same Pay and criminal wage theft penalties |
Today the system is a hybrid: a centralised safety net of the NES, minimum wage and awards set by the Fair Work Commission, with decentralised enterprise bargaining and individual contracts above it.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Which reform abolished Australian Workplace Agreements and made enterprise bargaining the centre of the wage determination system?
Hint 12009.
Hint 2Modern awards and NES.
Hint 3Replaced Work Choices.
Arguments for and against each method
AnswersWhat are the arguments for and against centralised, decentralised and individual wage determination?
Centralised wage determination
| For | Against |
|---|---|
| Comparative wage justice: similar pay for similar work, protecting the living standards of low-paid workers | Institutionalised inflation: uniform increases unrelated to productivity are passed on as higher prices, creating a real wage overhang |
| Protects workers with little bargaining power | Wage-price spirals: a successful claim by one union triggers claims by others |
| Allows government to restrain wages through an incomes policy, as under the Accord | Slows structural change: expanding industries cannot pay more to attract labour from declining ones |
| Fewer workplace-level negotiations | Associated with high levels of disputes |
Decentralised wage determination
| For | Against |
|---|---|
| Productivity: wage rises can be traded for better work practices, improving technical efficiency | Inequality: wage dispersion widens between workers with and without bargaining power |
| Allocative efficiency: growing firms can pay more to attract labour, speeding structural change, as in mining during the boom | Bargaining power, not productivity, often decides outcomes, so low-paid workers fall behind |
| Flexibility: hours and pay can adjust in downturns, protecting jobs | Enforcement is harder, with widespread underpayment |
| Lower NAIRU: wages linked to productivity reduce inflationary pressure at low unemployment | Wage-push inflation in tight labour markets, when workers' bargaining power rises |
Individual contracts
| For | Against |
|---|---|
| Maximum flexibility to reward skills and performance | Low-skilled workers have little power, as the AWA experience showed |
| Lets highly skilled workers earn more | Relies on a strong, enforced safety net; underpayment at franchises such as 7-Eleven |
Exam question
Harder · about 11 min
6 marks
Explain the arguments for and against a decentralised system of wage determination. (6 marks)
Hint 1Productivity and allocation.
Hint 2Flexibility.
Hint 3Inequality and power.
Where students lose marks on this one
Only arguing one side.
Why it happens: The question says for and against.
Balance the two.
Written for this site.
The evidence on decentralisation
AnswersWhat has decentralisation achieved?
Productivity. As your notes explain, labour productivity growth averaged about 2.2 per cent a year from 1991 to 2004, as enterprise bargaining removed outdated work practices. But these were largely one-off gains: productivity growth slowed to about 0.3 per cent a year in the decade to 2024-25, and recent agreements have focused on pay rather than productivity.
Inflation. Inflation averaged about 9.4 per cent from 1970 to 1985 under centralised wage setting, but has averaged close to the 2 to 3 per cent target since the early 1990s. In the 2022 inflation surge, wages growth peaked at only 4.3 per cent (December 2023) while CPI inflation peaked at 7.8 per cent: there was no wage-price spiral, partly because multi-year agreements and annual award reviews adjust slowly.
Unemployment and flexibility. Flexibility helped keep unemployment low. During COVID-19, many firms cut hours instead of jobs, with JobKeeper support. Unemployment fell to about 3.5 per cent in 2022 and 2023, the lowest in almost 50 years. It was 4.6 per cent in August 2026.
- Long-run Phillips curve (at the NAIRU)
- Short-run Phillips curve, expected inflation 2.5%
- Inflation
- 2.5 per cent, with unemployment at 4.75 per cent and the NAIRU at 4.75 per cent
- What happens
- Unemployment is at the NAIRU: inflation equals expected inflation and is stable. There is no cyclical unemployment.
- Lowering the NAIRU
- Move the NAIRU slider left: microeconomic and labour market policies that cut structural, frictional and long-term unemployment shift the long-run curve left, so unemployment can be lower without accelerating inflation.
- About the model
- Illustrative numbers. The short-run curve passes through expected inflation at the NAIRU; the long-run curve is vertical because, once expectations adjust, unemployment settles at the NAIRU whatever the inflation rate.
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
Wages and equity. Decentralisation delivered weak real wages growth in the 2010s, as bargaining declined and many workers fell back on awards. Individual arrangements responded fastest when the labour market tightened after the pandemic. Real wages fell sharply in 2022 and 2023, recovered in 2024 and 2025, and fell again in 2026 as inflation rose above wages growth of 3.2 per cent.
Chain of reasoning
Decentralised bargaining rises
Pay set at the workplaceWage-productivity link rises
Rises traded for better work practicesUnit labour costs falls
Wages funded by productivityNAIRU falls
Lower unemployment without accelerating inflation
Exam question
Hardest asked · about 9 min
5 marks
Using evidence, assess the impact of decentralised wage determination on inflation and unemployment in Australia. (5 marks)
Hint 11970-85 versus since 1993.
Hint 22022 no spiral.
Hint 3Unemployment.
Where students lose marks on this one
Attributing all outcomes to wage determination.
Why it happens: Correlation looks strong.
Monetary policy and other factors also matter.
Written for this site.
A partial return to centralised elements
AnswersWhy has policy moved partly back towards centralised wage setting since 2022?
After a decade of weak wages growth, falling bargaining coverage and widespread underpayment, the government concluded that decentralised bargaining was not working for many low-paid workers. Since 2022:
- multi-employer bargaining lets whole low-paid sectors, such as early childhood education, bargain together;
- the Fair Work Commission can arbitrate intractable bargaining disputes;
- the Annual Wage Review has given larger increases to the lowest paid, including 6 per cent to the minimum wage from July 2026, and work value cases raised aged care pay;
- gender equity is now an object of the Fair Work Act, and pay secrecy clauses are banned;
- deliberate underpayment became a criminal offence from 2025.
The debate. Supporters argue these reforms correct an imbalance in bargaining power and help close the gender pay gap, which fell from 18.5 per cent in 2014 to 11.5 per cent in November 2025. Critics, including employer groups, argue they reduce flexibility, raise labour costs in sectors with low productivity growth, and risk industry-wide disputes, at a time when productivity growth is weak. It is too early to judge their overall effect.
Common mistake
Australia now has a fully decentralised labour market.
Why it happens: Enterprise bargaining and individual contracts dominate pay setting.
Australia has a hybrid system. The Fair Work Commission still sets the minimum wage, about 120 modern awards and work value increases, which directly set pay for about one in five employees, and the NES apply to everyone. Since 2022 the centralised elements have been strengthened.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student writes: 'Australia now has a fully decentralised labour market.' Which response is best?
Hint 1Safety net.
Hint 2One in five.
Hint 3Since 2022.
Essay planpriority 7 of 16 · 20 marks
Analyse the impacts of labour market reform on the Australian economy.
- Analyse
- Break the situation into its parts and show how they relate and affect each other.
- Thesis
- Labour market reform since the 1980s, by decentralising wage determination, has improved flexibility, supported productivity growth and helped Australia combine low inflation with low unemployment. These gains came with weaker real wages growth and wider inequality for workers with little bargaining power, which has led to a partial return to centralised elements since 2022.
Decentralisation improved productivity by linking wages to changes in work practices, though the gains were largely one-off.
Establish productivity as the main channel through which reform affects the rest of the economy.
- Theory
- Enterprise bargaining trades wage rises for productivity; technical and allocative efficiency; AS shifts right.
- Diagram
- AD-AS with AS shifting right.
- Evidence
- Labour productivity growth of about 2.2 per cent a year from 1991 to 2004; about 0.3 per cent a year in the decade to 2024-25; collective agreement coverage down to 34.6 per cent in May 2025.
- Against
- The 1990s gains also reflected technology and product market reform, and recent agreements focus on pay rather than productivity.
Decentralised wage setting has helped keep inflation low by preventing economy-wide wage-price spirals.
Show that the absence of a wage-price spiral in 2022 is recent evidence for the argument.
- Theory
- Cost-push inflation; wage-price spiral; wages linked to productivity keep unit labour costs stable.
- Diagram
- AD-AS with a smaller leftward AS shift from wage costs.
- Evidence
- Inflation averaged about 9.4 per cent from 1970 to 1985 under centralised wage fixing; in the 2022 surge, wages growth peaked at 4.3 per cent in December 2023 while CPI inflation peaked at 7.8 per cent, so there was no wage-price spiral.
- Against
- Slow adjustment through multi-year agreements also meant real wages fell sharply in 2022 and 2023, which reduced household consumption.
Greater flexibility has helped lower unemployment and the NAIRU.
Link flexibility to the full employment objective and to the NAIRU.
- Theory
- Flexible hours and wages absorb shocks; a lower NAIRU shifts the long-run Phillips curve left.
- Diagram
- Phillips curve with the long-run curve shifting left.
- Evidence
- Firms cut hours rather than jobs during COVID-19 with JobKeeper support; unemployment fell to about 3.5 per cent in 2022 and 2023, the lowest in almost 50 years; 4.6 per cent in August 2026 with underemployment of 6.2 per cent.
- Against
- Low unemployment after 2022 owed much to fiscal and monetary stimulus and closed borders, not only to labour market flexibility.
Decentralisation widened inequality and weakened the bargaining power of low-paid workers.
This is the main cost of reform and explains the policy response in the next paragraph.
- Theory
- Bargaining power; wage dispersion; labour market segmentation.
- Diagram
- None needed.
- Evidence
- Weak real wages growth through the 2010s as bargaining declined; widespread underpayment; the gender pay gap of 11.5 per cent in November 2025; about one in five employees reliant on award rates.
- Against
- Award and minimum wage increases, the tax-transfer system and the NES limit the rise in inequality.
Since 2022 policy has partly re-centralised wage determination to address equity, with uncertain effects on productivity.
Conclude by weighing efficiency gains against equity costs, and noting the direction of recent policy.
- Theory
- Bargaining power and equity versus flexibility and labour costs.
- Diagram
- None needed.
- Evidence
- Multi-employer bargaining and the 15 per cent early childhood pay rise from December 2024; the 6 per cent minimum wage increase from July 2026; aged care work value increases; wage theft criminalised from 2025; industrial disputes of about 167,000 working days lost in 2025, far below the 1980s.
- Against
- Employer groups argue these reforms reduce flexibility and add costs when productivity growth is weak; it is too early to judge their effect.
Judgement
Analyse means identify the components and the relationships between them, and draw out their implications. Organise the response by the impact on each objective, and link each impact to the mechanism of decentralisation or re-regulation. Conclude that the impacts have been positive for efficiency and macroeconomic stability but mixed for equity.
The full response also needs: The unemployment, inflation and distribution lessons in Topic 3 for the objectives, the awards, enterprise agreements and minimum wages lessons, and the education and training lesson for supply-side labour market policy.
Why the pendulum swings
Wage determination in Australia has swung between centralised and decentralised systems as the main economic problem has changed. In the 1970s and 1980s, the main problem was inflation and inefficiency, so policy moved towards bargaining linked to productivity. By the late 2010s, the main problem was weak wages growth and inequality, so policy moved back towards collective and tribunal-set outcomes.
Neither extreme is stable. A fully centralised system cannot respond to differences between industries and firms, and risks inflation. A fully decentralised system leaves low-paid workers exposed and relies on enforcement that is costly and incomplete. The hybrid model tries to keep the benefits of both: a floor set centrally for equity, and bargaining above it for efficiency. The recent debate is less about which system to choose than about where to set the balance.