HSC Study

Effects of Budgetary Changes

How changes in the budget affect economic activity and unemployment through the multiplier, resource use through direct spending and incentives, the distribution of income through tax and transfers, and national saving and the current account in the long run, with multiplier calculations and examples from COVID to the 2026-27 Budget.

40 min · HSC Topic Four - Economic Policies and Management

Assumes you have read Federal Government Budgets and Budget Outcomes and The Multiplier.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

  • Economic activity. An expansionary budget adds to aggregate demand, and the multiplier spreads it: , with . A contractionary budget does the reverse. This is the most important short-run effect.
  • Unemployment. Stronger activity raises demand for labour. Treasury estimated JobKeeper kept the unemployment rate about 5 percentage points lower than it would otherwise have been in 2020.
  • Resource use. Directly, the government provides public goods and services (defence, health, infrastructure). Indirectly, taxes and subsidies shift resources: tobacco excise, the permanent $20,000 instant asset write-off, clean energy funding.
  • Income distribution. Progressive taxes and targeted transfers reduce inequality. Flattening tax scales or cutting welfare increase it.
  • Saving and the current account. In the long run a deficit reduces national saving, which can raise interest rates (crowding out) or, in an open economy, increase foreign borrowing and the current account deficit.
  • Leakages matter. Australia's multiplier is small because saving, tax and imports all leak, and a tax cut has a smaller multiplier than an equal rise in spending because part of it is saved.

Economic activity and unemployment

AnswersHow do budgetary changes affect economic activity and unemployment?

As your notes explain, the budget stance is the most significant short-term effect of fiscal policy.

  • An expansionary stance (a larger deficit or smaller surplus) raises government spending or lowers taxes. This adds directly to aggregate demand, or raises disposable income and so consumption and investment. It closes a deflationary gap.
  • A contractionary stance does the reverse and closes an inflationary gap.

Through the multiplier, the change in national income is larger than the initial change in the budget, because one person's spending becomes another's income. Stronger activity raises demand for labour, so expansionary policy reduces cyclical unemployment, or slows its rise in a downturn.

Examples.

  • COVID, 2020 and 2021. The largest fiscal expansion in Australia's history: JobKeeper wage subsidies (about $89 billion, supporting about 3.8 million workers at their peak), the Coronavirus Supplement of $550 a fortnight for people on income support, cash payments and investment incentives. Treasury estimated JobKeeper kept the unemployment rate about 5 percentage points lower, and unemployment peaked at 7.4 per cent rather than the 10 per cent or more first feared.
  • Temporary full expensing (2020 to 2023) let firms deduct the full cost of new assets immediately, bringing forward business investment. The $20,000 instant asset write-off for small business was made permanent in the 2026-27 Budget.
  • 2026-27. The Budget cut fuel excise by 32 cents a litre for three months and cut the lowest income tax rate, supporting household spending while inflation was above target, which conflicts with the Reserve Bank's tightening (see the conflicts lesson).

As your notes explain, in the long run the effectiveness of fiscal policy may diminish if past deficits have created high public debt, because rising interest costs limit the room for future stimulus.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Which budgetary change is most likely to close a deflationary gap?

Select one answer

Hint 1Deflationary means AD is too low.

Hint 2Expansionary stance.

Hint 3Larger deficit.

Multiplier analysis

AnswersHow can the multiplier be used to explain how governments solve economic problems?

In an open economy with a government, each round of spending leaks into saving, tax and imports. The multiplier is:

where MPW is the marginal propensity to withdraw. A change in government spending of changes equilibrium income by:

Using it to solve a problem. To close an output gap of , the government only needs to change spending by , the expenditure gap.

Tax changes have a smaller effect. A tax cut raises disposable income, but households save part of it (and part is spent on imports) before any spending enters the circular flow, so only the first-round spending is multiplied. Changing government spending on goods and services directly by the same amount has a larger effect.

Worked example4 marks

Closing a deflationary gap with fiscal policy

An economy's equilibrium level of income is $60 billion below the full employment level. The marginal propensity to save is 0.2, the marginal propensity to tax is 0.2 and the marginal propensity to import is 0.1. Households spend 60 per cent of any tax cut in the first round.

(a) Calculate the multiplier. (b) Calculate the increase in government spending needed to close the gap. (c) Calculate the tax cut that would close the gap instead, and explain why it is larger.

Calculate the multiplier

The marginal propensity to withdraw is 0.2 + 0.2 + 0.1 = 0.5.

Find the spending increase

The output gap is $60 billion, so the government needs to raise spending by

which is $30 billion. The first $30 billion adds to income, a further $15 billion is spent in the next round, and so on, until income rises by $60 billion.

Find the tax cut

A tax cut adds only 60 per cent of its value to spending in the first round, so the first-round spending needed is still $30 billion:

The government must cut taxes by $50 billion.

Answer

(a) The multiplier is 2. (b) Government spending must rise by $30 billion. (c) Taxes must be cut by $50 billion, because 40 per cent of the tax cut is saved or spent on imports before it enters the circular flow, so it raises the budget deficit by more for the same effect on income.

Is that answer sensible?

Check the answer by working forward: $30 billion of new spending times a multiplier of 2 gives $60 billion, the size of the gap. In practice, the multiplier is uncertain and may be smaller if the stimulus raises interest rates (crowding out), is saved because households expect future tax rises, or is spent when the economy is near capacity, where it raises prices rather than output.

Exam question

Standard · about 5 min

3 marks

An economy's equilibrium income is $24 billion below the full employment level. The marginal propensity to save is 0.25, the marginal propensity to tax is 0.25 and the marginal propensity to import is 0.1. Calculate the increase in government spending, in billions of dollars, needed to close the gap.

Hint 1Add the leakages.

Hint 2k = 1 / MPW.

Hint 3Divide the output gap by k.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Using only the MPS.

    Why it happens: The closed-economy formula is familiar.

    In an open economy with government, tax and imports also leak.

Written for this site.

Resource use

AnswersHow do budgetary changes affect the allocation of resources?

As your notes explain, fiscal policy influences resource use in two ways.

ChannelHow it worksRecent examples
DirectGovernment spending provides goods and services markets will not provide, or not quickly enough, including public goods (non-rival and non-excludable, so free riders make them unprofitable)Defence ($52 billion in 2026-27), rising for strategic reasons; the NDIS and aged care; disaster relief
IndirectTaxes and subsidies change the incentive to use resources in particular waysTobacco excise discourages smoking and its health costs; clean energy funding and the Future Made in Australia production tax credits for green hydrogen and critical minerals; the permanent $20,000 instant asset write-off; 2026-27 changes to negative gearing and capital gains concessions to direct housing investment towards new dwellings

Your notes also explain that governments rely on market forces for most resource allocation, intervening mainly to correct market failures. Direct subsidies to industry are now small by historical standards, and governments allowed car manufacturing to close in 2017.

Common mistake

Fiscal policy only affects the level of economic activity.

Why it happens: The budget stance gets most of the attention.

The composition of the budget matters as much as the balance. Two budgets with the same deficit can have very different effects on resource use and income distribution, depending on what is taxed and what is funded.

Exam question

Standard · about 7 min

4 marks

Distinguish between the direct and indirect effects of fiscal policy on resource use. Use examples from recent budgets. (4 marks)

Hint 1Direct: government provides.

Hint 2Indirect: incentives.

Hint 3Examples.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Describing only the budget balance.

    Why it happens: Stance is the best-known effect.

    Resource use depends on the composition of the budget.

Written for this site.

Income distribution

AnswersHow do budgetary changes affect the distribution of income?

As your notes explain, Australia's progressive income tax system means people on higher incomes pay higher marginal and average rates, and the revenue funds transfer payments and services that benefit lower-income households most.

ChangeEffect on inequalityReason
Higher top tax rates or fewer concessionsReducesMore progressive
Flatter tax scale, cuts at the topIncreasesLess progressive
Higher GSTIncreasesRegressive: a larger share of low incomes is spent
Higher welfare payments, servicesReducesLarger proportional benefit for low-income households
Spending cuts to welfare and servicesIncreasesLow-income households rely more on them

Examples.

  • The stage 3 tax cuts as legislated in 2019 would have flattened the scale, with a large share of the benefit going to high-income earners. They were redesigned from 1 July 2024 to cut the lowest rate from 19 to 16 per cent and spread the gains more evenly. The 2026-27 Budget cuts the 16 per cent rate to 15 per cent in 2026 and 14 per cent in 2027.
  • The Coronavirus Supplement temporarily almost doubled JobSeeker in 2020, and poverty fell sharply before rising again when it ended.
  • Cost-of-living measures since 2023: energy bill relief for all households, a tripled bulk billing incentive, cheaper medicines and higher rent assistance, all of which benefit low-income households proportionally more.

The ABS estimates that taxes, transfers and services raise the lowest quintile's share of income from about 4 per cent before tax to about 12 per cent after (see the distribution of income lesson).

Exam question

Harder · about 9 min

5 marks

Explain how changes in taxation and government spending can affect the distribution of income. Refer to budget measures since 2020. (5 marks)

Hint 1Progressive tax.

Hint 2Transfers and services.

Hint 3Stage 3 and COVID examples.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Treating any tax cut as reducing inequality.

    Why it happens: Tax cuts raise disposable income.

    Who receives the cut matters; cuts at the top widen inequality.

Written for this site.

National saving, crowding out and the current account

AnswersWhat are the long-run effects of budget deficits on national saving and external stability?

As your notes explain, there is a long-run link between the budget outcome, the current account deficit and foreign debt.

Chain of reasoning

From a budget deficit to the current account

  1. Budget deficit rises

    the government borrows to cover it
  2. National saving falls

    public dissaving reduces the pool of saving
  3. Interest rates rises

    competition for funds raises the cost of borrowing: crowding out
  4. Foreign borrowing rises

    in an open economy, borrowers turn overseas instead
  5. Current account deficit rises

    higher foreign liabilities mean more income paid abroad
  • In a closed economy, higher interest rates reduce private investment (crowding out).
  • In an open economy like Australia, crowding out is weaker because borrowers can access foreign saving, but foreign liabilities and primary income payments rise.
  • Crowding out is weaker in a recession, when private demand for funds is low, and stronger in a boom.

This is why fiscal consolidation is a medium-term aim. The surpluses of 2022-23 and 2023-24 helped reduce gross debt below earlier forecasts, and the current strategy aims to reduce gross debt as a share of GDP from a peak of 35.8 per cent in 2028-29. Net interest payments are forecast to more than double from $13.7 billion in 2024-25 to $31.7 billion in 2029-30, a growing cost that crowds out other spending within the budget.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: 'A $10 billion tax cut and a $10 billion increase in government spending on infrastructure have exactly the same effect on national income.' Which response is best?

Select one answer

Hint 1First round.

Hint 2Saving and imports.

Hint 3Multiplier.

How big is the fiscal multiplier really?

Textbook multipliers use fixed propensities, but real multipliers depend on conditions. Research across advanced economies finds multipliers of roughly 0.5 to 1 in normal times and larger, possibly above 1.5, in deep recessions when interest rates are at their lower bound, because the central bank does not offset the stimulus and idle resources mean little crowding out.

Three things make Australia's multiplier small. It is a very open economy, so much stimulus leaks into imports. The Reserve Bank targets inflation, so if fiscal expansion pushes inflation up when the economy is near capacity, the Bank raises interest rates and offsets part of it. And under Ricardian equivalence, households that expect deficits to mean higher future taxes may save a tax cut rather than spend it, although the evidence suggests only partial effects of this kind.

This explains the pattern of the last six years. The 2020 stimulus was highly effective because the economy had large spare capacity and interest rates were near zero. By 2022 the same kind of stimulus added more to inflation than to output, which is why economists now emphasise that fiscal support should be timely, temporary and targeted.