HSC Study

Effects of Inflation

The positive and negative effects of inflation on households, firms, the government and the economy as a whole, including real incomes, the redistribution between borrowers and lenders, uncertainty, competitiveness, interest rates and bracket creep, with the costs of deflation and evidence from the post-COVID surge.

45 min · HSC Topic Three - Economic Issues

Assumes you have read Causes of Inflation.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

Negative effects (mainly of high or unexpected inflation):

  • Lower purchasing power and real wages when prices rise faster than incomes. Real wages fell about 4.6 per cent in 2022.
  • Redistribution: borrowers gain and lenders, savers and people on fixed incomes lose.
  • Uncertainty distorts spending and investment decisions and encourages speculation.
  • Lower international competitiveness, unless the dollar depreciates.
  • Higher interest rates to bring inflation down, which slow growth and raise unemployment.
  • Bracket creep: rising nominal incomes push taxpayers into higher tax brackets.

Positive effects (of low, stable inflation of about 2 to 3 per cent):

  • It avoids deflation, which leads people to delay spending.
  • It lets real wages and relative prices adjust without cuts to nominal wages.
  • It reduces the real burden of debt and gives the Reserve Bank room to cut interest rates.

The target of 2 to 3 per cent aims to capture the benefits of low inflation while avoiding the costs of both high inflation and deflation.

Real and nominal values

AnswersHow does inflation affect real incomes and real interest rates?

The effects of inflation all come back to the difference between nominal values (in dollars) and real values (in purchasing power).

  • Real wage growth nominal wage growth inflation.
  • Real interest rate nominal interest rate inflation.

Your notes put it simply: high inflation reduces the real value of money, so a dollar buys less. Whether a person is worse off depends on whether their income and assets rise as fast as prices.

Worked example4 marks

The effect of inflation on a worker, a saver and a borrower

In the year to the June quarter 2026, prices rose 3.9 per cent and wages rose 3.2 per cent. (a) A worker earned $80,000 a year. Calculate the change in their real wage. (b) A saver held $20,000 in a deposit paying 4.5 per cent interest, taxed at 30 per cent. Calculate the real after-tax return. (c) A household owes $500,000 on a mortgage. By how much did inflation reduce the real value of the debt over the year?

The worker's real wage

The new wage is dollars. In last year's prices this is dollars. The real wage fell by about $539, or per cent: approximately per cent.

The saver's real after-tax return

Interest is dollars. After 30 per cent tax the saver keeps $630, a nominal return of per cent. The real after-tax return is about per cent. The saver is losing purchasing power even though the account pays 4.5 per cent.

The borrower's real debt

The debt is still $500,000 in dollars, but in last year's prices it is worth dollars. Inflation reduced the real value of the debt by about $18,800.

Answer

The worker's real wage fell about 0.7 per cent (about $540 in purchasing power). The saver's real after-tax return was about −0.75 per cent. Inflation reduced the real value of the mortgage by about $18,800. Inflation redistributes purchasing power from savers and people whose incomes lag behind prices, towards borrowers.

Is that answer sensible?

The borrower's gain is not the whole story. Higher inflation led the Reserve Bank to raise the cash rate to 4.35 per cent, so mortgage interest costs rose. Borrowers gain from unexpected inflation only if their interest rate does not rise to match it. The saver example assumes a 4.5 per cent rate for illustration.

Common mistake

Inflation makes everyone worse off because prices go up.

Why it happens: Rising prices are what people notice.

Every price paid is also an income received. Inflation hurts people whose incomes and assets rise more slowly than prices, and helps those whose incomes rise faster, or whose debts shrink in real terms. The main effect is a redistribution, and the question is who gains and who loses. The losses to the economy as a whole come from uncertainty, distorted decisions and the cost of bringing inflation down.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Nominal wages rose 3.4 per cent and the CPI rose 2.1 per cent over the year to the June quarter 2025. Calculate the approximate change in real wages, in per cent. (2 marks)

Hint 1Real wage growth is approximately nominal wage growth minus inflation.

Hint 2Subtract 2.1 from 3.4.

Hint 3Is the answer positive or negative?

Negative effects of inflation

AnswersWhat are the negative effects of inflation?

Your notes list the consequences of a high level of inflation. Each can be analysed as a chain.

1. Lower purchasing power and living standards. When prices rise faster than incomes, real incomes fall. In December 2022 prices rose 7.9 per cent and wages 3.3 per cent, a real wage fall of about 4.6 per cent, one of the largest on record. Real net national disposable income per person fell 2.1 per cent in 2023-24. Households ran down savings to maintain consumption: the household saving ratio fell from 23.3 per cent in June 2020 to 1.8 per cent in September 2023. This was the cost-of-living squeeze.

2. Redistribution of income and wealth.

  • Losers: people on fixed incomes (some retirees, and welfare payments until they are indexed), savers whose interest rates lag inflation, and lenders, who are repaid in dollars worth less.
  • Winners: borrowers, whose debts shrink in real terms, and owners of assets such as property that tend to rise with inflation.
  • Low-income households spend more of their income on essentials such as food, rent and energy, which often rise fastest. So inflation tends to widen inequality.

3. Uncertainty and distorted decisions. Your notes explain that high inflation creates uncertainty about future costs. Firms find it harder to plan and price long-term projects, so investment falls. Households may buy early to beat price rises. Resources shift towards speculation in assets such as property, and away from productive investment. Firms must also update prices more often (menu costs), and people spend time and effort protecting the value of their money.

4. Lower international competitiveness. If Australia's inflation is higher than its trading partners', its exports become dearer and imports cheaper. This worsens the current account, unless the dollar depreciates, which in turn adds to imported inflation. In 2022 Australia's inflation was below that of the United States and Europe, so this effect was small.

5. Wage-price spiral and expectations. Your notes explain that workers seek larger wage rises to compensate for lost purchasing power. Firms pass on the higher costs, and inflation becomes entrenched, as in the 1970s.

6. Higher interest rates and unemployment. The largest cost of inflation is often the cost of bringing it down. The Reserve Bank raised the cash rate from 0.10 to 4.35 per cent between May 2022 and November 2023, and again to 4.35 per cent in 2026. Mortgage repayments rose sharply. Real GDP per person fell in both 2023-24 and 2024-25, and unemployment rose from 3.4 per cent to 4.6 per cent.

7. Bracket creep. Tax brackets are set in dollars. As nominal incomes rise with inflation, more income is taxed at higher marginal rates, even when real income has not risen. The average tax rate rises and disposable incomes fall. This raises government revenue until governments hand it back through tax cuts, as with the revised Stage 3 tax cuts from July 2024.

Chain of reasoning

How high inflation can slow the economy

  1. Inflation rises well above the target band.
  2. Real wages fall and uncertainty rises, so households cut discretionary spending and firms delay investment.
  3. The Reserve Bank raises interest rates to bring inflation back to target.
  4. Higher borrowing costs cut consumption, housing and investment. The dollar may appreciate, reducing net exports.
  5. Growth slows and unemployment rises until inflation returns to target.

Exam question

Standard · about 7 min

4 marks

Analyse TWO negative effects of inflation on the Australian economy. Use recent evidence. (4 marks)

Hint 1Real incomes and living standards.

Hint 2Interest rates and unemployment.

Hint 3Redistribution, uncertainty or competitiveness.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Describing effects without a chain.

    Why it happens: The effects are familiar.

    Explain how inflation leads to each effect.

Written for this site.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Which group is most likely to GAIN from an unexpected rise in inflation?

Select one answer

Hint 1What happens to the real value of a debt?

Hint 2Who is repaid in dollars worth less?

Hint 3Consider fixed incomes.

Positive effects of low inflation, and the costs of deflation

AnswersCan inflation have positive effects?

Low, stable inflation is good for an economy. That is why the target is 2 to 3 per cent, not zero. Your notes explain what goes wrong if inflation is too low:

  • Deflation discourages spending. If people expect prices to fall, they delay purchases. Lower spending reduces the demand for labour, so workers are laid off or wages cut. That pushes prices down further: a deflationary spiral. Japan's experience of falling prices and weak growth from the 1990s is the classic example.
  • Real wages can adjust. Firms rarely cut nominal wages. With some inflation, a firm in difficulty can let wages rise more slowly than prices, cutting real wages without laying workers off. At zero inflation, the firm may lay off workers instead.
  • Relative prices can adjust, allowing resources to move towards growing industries.
  • The real burden of debt falls for households, firms and the government. Deflation does the opposite: debts grow in real terms.
  • Room for monetary policy. With inflation of 2 to 3 per cent, nominal interest rates are higher, so the Reserve Bank has more room to cut them in a downturn. In 2020, with inflation low, the cash rate reached 0.10 per cent and the Bank had to use unconventional tools.

Mild inflation can also accompany strong growth. Rising prices signal strong demand, profits rise and firms expand. But this benefit disappears if inflation rises high enough to require tightening.

Common mistake

The best inflation rate is zero, because then prices are stable.

Why it happens: Price stability sounds like zero inflation.

Your notes are clear: price stability means keeping inflation at an acceptable level, not eliminating it. Zero measured inflation would risk deflation, prevent real wage adjustment and leave the Reserve Bank little room to cut rates. The CPI also slightly overstates true inflation, so a small positive rate is close to stable prices in practice.

Exam question

Standard · about 5 min

3 marks

Explain why a low positive rate of inflation is preferable to zero inflation or deflation. (3 marks)

Hint 1Delayed spending.

Hint 2Real wage adjustment.

Hint 3Room for monetary policy and real debt.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Saying inflation is good because prices rise.

    Why it happens: Positive effects are asked for.

    The benefits apply to low, stable inflation only.

Written for this site.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: 'The Reserve Bank should aim for zero inflation, because any inflation reduces living standards.' Which response is best?

Select one answer

Hint 1Do all incomes lag prices?

Hint 2What are the risks of zero?

Hint 3What does price stability mean?

Analysing the effects: what makes inflation costly

AnswersWhy are some episodes of inflation more costly than others?

The effects of inflation depend on four things:

FactorLess costlyMore costly
Level2 to 3 per centWell above the band, as in 1975 (17.5 per cent) or 2022 (7.8 per cent)
AnticipationExpected: wages, interest rates and pensions adjustUnexpected: redistributes from lenders and wage earners to borrowers
StabilitySteady and predictableVolatile, raising uncertainty
CauseA one-off supply shock that fadesExcess demand or rising expectations that make it persist

Indexation reduces the redistribution. Pensions and many welfare payments are indexed to the CPI and wages, the minimum wage is reviewed annually, and superannuation is invested in assets that tend to keep pace with inflation. But indexation lags prices, and it can also spread inflation.

So when analysing the effects of an episode, ask: how high was inflation, was it expected, who could protect themselves, and what did it cost to bring down? After 2022 inflation was unexpected, so real wages fell and borrowers with fixed-rate loans gained. Most of the cost came from the rise in interest rates needed to stop expectations rising.

Exam question

Harder · about 9 min

5 marks

Analyse the effects of the rise in inflation in Australia between 2021 and 2023. (5 marks)

Hint 1Real incomes and saving.

Hint 2Redistribution: who gained and lost?

Hint 3The cost of bringing inflation down.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Listing effects without linking them.

    Why it happens: Analyse sounds like describe.

    Show how each effect follows and which matters most.

Written for this site.

Essay planpriority 16 of 16 · 20 marks

Analyse the causes and effects of a nominated economic issue in the Australian economy.

Analyse
Break the situation into its parts and show how they relate and affect each other.
Thesis
Inflation surged to 7.8 per cent in 2022 because global supply shocks coincided with excess domestic demand, and it rose again in 2026 because of capacity pressures and weak productivity. Its effects were a sharp fall in real wages, a redistribution towards borrowers and asset owners, and the cost of the higher interest rates needed to contain it, which slowed growth and raised unemployment.
  1. Global supply shocks started the surge: imported and cost inflation.

    Open with supply because it explains why inflation rose everywhere at once.

    Theory
    A supply shock shifts aggregate supply left, raising prices and lowering output; higher world prices raise the price of imports and imported inputs.
    Diagram
    AD and AS with AS shifting left; the tradables and non-tradables table.
    Evidence
    Supply chain disruption, the war in Ukraine and the 2022 floods; tradables inflation reached 8.7 per cent in December 2022.
    Against
    Supply shocks raise the price level once. On their own they would have faded, as tradables inflation did, falling to 1.5 per cent by December 2023.
  2. Excess demand and the risk to expectations made inflation persist.

    This paragraph is where the ranking happens: persistence, not the initial shock, is what policy had to fix.

    Theory
    Demand inflation occurs when AD grows faster than capacity; unemployment below the NAIRU and rising expectations create second-round effects.
    Diagram
    AD shifting right near capacity, or the Phillips curve with unemployment below the NAIRU.
    Evidence
    Record stimulus and a 0.10 per cent cash rate; unemployment 3.4 per cent in October 2022; non-tradables inflation 5.4 per cent in December 2023 and 4.8 per cent in June 2026; the Reserve Bank's 'economy-wide capacity pressures' in 2026.
    Against
    Wages growth peaked at only 4.3 per cent and long-term expectations stayed near 2.5 per cent, so there was no 1970s-style spiral.
  3. Inflation reduced real incomes and living standards.

    Quantify the real income loss; it is the effect most students describe without numbers.

    Theory
    Real wage growth is nominal wage growth minus inflation; falling real incomes reduce consumption.
    Diagram
    The inflation graph, view 3, comparing inflation and wages growth.
    Evidence
    Real wages fell about 4.6 per cent in 2022; the saving ratio fell from 23.3 per cent to 1.8 per cent by September 2023; real net national disposable income per person fell 2.1 per cent in 2023-24.
    Against
    Real wages recovered through 2024 and 2025 as inflation fell faster than wages growth, before slipping again in 2026.
  4. Inflation redistributed income and wealth, and the response to it slowed the economy.

    End by weighing the cost of inflation against the cost of fighting it.

    Theory
    Unexpected inflation transfers from lenders and fixed-income earners to borrowers; contractionary monetary policy raises unemployment in the short run.
    Diagram
    Phillips curve: moving down the short-run curve as unemployment rises.
    Evidence
    The cash rate rose from 0.10 to 4.35 per cent by November 2023, and back to 4.35 per cent in 2026; real GDP per person fell in 2023-24 and 2024-25; unemployment rose from 3.4 to 4.6 per cent.
    Against
    The rise in unemployment was small by historical standards, suggesting that anchored expectations reduced the cost of disinflation.

Judgement

Analyse asks how the causes and effects work, and which matter most. Argue that supply shocks explain the timing of the surge but excess demand and the risk to expectations explain its persistence, and that the largest cost of the episode was the real income loss and the slowdown needed to reverse it, rather than inflation itself.

The full response also needs: Monetary policy from Topic 4, if the question asks how the government responded.

Who really paid for the post-COVID inflation?

The effects of the surge fell unevenly. Renters and young households with large new mortgages faced rising rents and repayments on top of higher prices. Outright home owners and retirees with savings faced higher prices but earned higher interest on deposits and saw property values rise. The government gained in the short term, as higher nominal incomes, profits and commodity prices lifted tax revenue and helped return the budget to surplus in 2022-23 and 2023-24, while indexed payments rose with a lag. Firms in sectors with pricing power held their margins, while those facing strong competition absorbed higher costs.

The ABS's Selected Living Cost Indexes showed that, while interest rates were rising, living costs for employee households, many with mortgages, rose faster than the CPI, and faster than for age pensioners. This is a reminder that a single inflation rate hides different experiences. It also explains why the policy debate focused on cost-of-living relief, such as energy rebates and rent assistance, alongside higher interest rates. Critics argued such relief worked against monetary policy by supporting demand; supporters pointed out that rebates lowered measured inflation directly and targeted the households hit hardest.