Effects of Unemployment
The economic costs of unemployment (lost output, lower living standards, lost skills, the cost to the budget and slower wages growth) and its social costs (poverty, inequality, jobless families and personal and social problems), with an essay plan analysing the causes and effects of unemployment in Australia.
40 min · HSC Topic Three - Economic Issues
Assumes you have read Groups Affected by Unemployment and The NAIRU.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
Economic costs
- Opportunity cost. Output is lost for good: the economy operates inside its production possibility frontier. Each percentage point of unemployment is about 156,000 people.
- Lower living standards. The unemployed rely on welfare, and lower spending cuts sales, profits, investment and growth.
- Loss of human capital. Skills decay, especially in long-term unemployment. Hysteresis turns cyclical unemployment into structural unemployment.
- Costs to the budget. Welfare spending rises and tax revenue falls through the automatic stabilisers. Labour market programs cost more.
- Slower wages growth. Excess supply of labour holds wages down. Wages rarely fall, because they are sticky downwards.
Social costs
- Poverty and inequality, including jobless families (18.5 per cent of all families in June 2025) and disadvantage passed between generations.
- Personal and social problems: poorer physical and mental health, family breakdown, crime, homelessness and social isolation. These in turn create further economic costs.
The economic costs of unemployment
AnswersWhat are the economic costs of unemployment?
1. Opportunity cost: lost output. Unemployment means the economy's labour is not fully used, so it operates inside its production possibility frontier. Output is below what the economy could produce. The loss is permanent: an hour of work not done this year cannot be recovered later. Lower output means lower household incomes and spending, so sales and profits fall, which can lower investment, production and employment further through the multiplier.
Worked example3 marks
A rough estimate of the output lost to unemployment
In 2025-26 Australia's nominal GDP was about $2,927 billion, and in August 2026 about 14.84 million people were employed in a labour force of 15.56 million. Estimate the output lost if unemployment is one percentage point higher than it needs to be. Assume the extra unemployed would produce three quarters as much as the average worker.
Find the number of people in one percentage point
One per cent of the labour force is people.
Find output per worker
GDP of $2,927 billion divided by 14.84 million employed: dollars per worker a year.
Adjust for productivity
The unemployed are on average less experienced and skilled, so assume three quarters of the average: dollars.
Answer
billion dollars a year, or close to 1 per cent of GDP, for every percentage point of unnecessary unemployment.
Is that answer sensible?
The answer is of the same order as Okun's law suggests: each point of unemployment corresponds to roughly one to two per cent of output. It is an estimate of the order of magnitude, not a precise figure.
2. Lower living standards. Unemployed people rely on welfare payments, which are far below average earnings. Long spells can trap families in a cycle of welfare dependence and poverty. Taxpayers in work contribute more to fund payments. For the economy, lower production of capital goods as well as consumer goods reduces future growth and living standards, not just present ones.
3. Loss of human capital. Through hysteresis, unemployment today raises unemployment in the future. The unemployed, especially the long-term unemployed, lose skills, contacts and motivation. Rapid technological change can make their skills redundant, so the cyclically unemployed become structurally unemployed. When vacancies are scarce, school leavers struggle to gain their first experience. After the recession of the early 1990s, more than a third of the unemployed had been out of work for over a year. Unemployment did not return to its 1989 level until 2003.
4. Costs to the government. Higher unemployment worsens the budget through the automatic stabilisers:
- Spending rises on JobSeeker Payment and other income support.
- Revenue falls as income tax and GST collections fall.
- Discretionary spending is needed for training and labour market programs.
The larger deficits must be financed by borrowing, and later budgets may need fiscal consolidation, which crowds out spending on infrastructure, health and education. The COVID recession showed this on a large scale. Wage subsidies and higher income support to prevent mass unemployment produced the largest budget deficits since the Second World War.
5. Slower wages growth. Unemployment is an excess supply of labour, which puts downward pressure on wages. Wages are sticky downwards, for three reasons:
- Workers resist pay cuts.
- Enterprise agreements run for several years.
- Minimum and award wages set a floor.
So high unemployment slows wages growth rather than cutting wages. When unemployment rose to 7.4 per cent in 2020, growth in the Wage Price Index fell to 1.3 per cent, the lowest on record. Your notes add that wages growth was also weak through the late 2010s, even with unemployment near 5 per cent. They point to weaker productivity growth and the declining use of enterprise bargaining.
Exam question
Standard · about 7 min
4 marks
Explain TWO economic costs of unemployment. (4 marks)
Hint 1Opportunity cost and the PPF.
Hint 2The budget and automatic stabilisers.
Hint 3Skills and hysteresis; wages.
Where students lose marks on this one
Describing a social cost.
Why it happens: Both are costs.
The question asks for economic costs.
Written for this site.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
How does a rise in unemployment affect the federal budget, other things equal?
Hint 1What happens to welfare spending?
Hint 2What happens to tax revenue?
Hint 3Automatic or discretionary?
Investigating the problems created by unemployment
AnswersHow can you use evidence to investigate the problems created by unemployment?
To investigate means to gather evidence and draw conclusions. Two recent Australian episodes show the costs of unemployment in contrasting ways.
| The COVID recession, 2020 | The tight labour market, 2022 to 2023 | |
|---|---|---|
| Unemployment | Rose from 5.1 to 7.4 per cent; underutilisation reached 20.3 per cent in May 2020 | Fell to 3.4 per cent in October 2022, the lowest since 1974 |
| Output | GDP fell 6.8 per cent in the June quarter of 2020 | Output grew and firms reported labour shortages |
| Wages | Wages growth fell to a record low of 1.3 per cent | Wages growth rose to 4.3 per cent |
| Budget | Record deficits from income support and wage subsidies | The budget returned to surplus in 2022-23 and 2023-24 as tax revenue rose |
| Scarring | Long-term unemployment rose to 244,000 by April 2021 | Long-term unemployment fell to 88,000 by April 2023 as employers hired people they would once have passed over |
The contrast shows that most of the costs of unemployment reverse when the labour market tightens: the fiscal costs, lost output and weak wages growth. The long-term damage depends on how long unemployment lasts. Policies that kept workers attached to employers in 2020, and a fast recovery, limited the scarring that followed the 1990s recession. Unemployment can also fall too low: the tight labour market of 2022 and 2023 added to inflation, which is the NAIRU trade-off.
Exam question
Harder · about 7 min
4 marks
Using evidence from 2020 to 2023, assess whether the costs of unemployment in Australia were temporary or lasting. (4 marks)
Hint 1What happened to output, wages and the budget?
Hint 2What happened to long-term unemployment?
Hint 3Which costs are hardest to reverse?
Where students lose marks on this one
Describing without judging.
Why it happens: Assess needs a conclusion.
State whether the costs were mainly temporary or lasting and why.
Written for this site.
Exam question
Standard · about 5 min
3 marks
Explain why the costs of long-term unemployment are greater than the costs of short-term unemployment. (3 marks)
Hint 1Hysteresis.
Hint 2Income and family effects over time.
Hint 3Effects on the NAIRU.
Where students lose marks on this one
Saying long-term unemployment costs more only because it lasts longer.
Why it happens: Duration matters.
It also changes employability and the NAIRU.
Written for this site.
Essay plan: causes and effects of unemployment
AnswersHow would you plan an extended response on the causes and effects of unemployment?
Essay planpriority 16 of 16 · 20 marks
Analyse the causes and effects of a nominated economic issue in the Australian economy.
- Analyse
- Break the situation into its parts and show how they relate and affect each other.
- Thesis
- Australia's unemployment rate has moved with the business cycle: it was pushed to 7.4 per cent in 2020 by a collapse in demand, driven down to 3.4 per cent in 2022 by stimulus and recovery, and raised again to 4.6 per cent by 2026 by tighter monetary policy and a fast-growing labour force. Its costs are economic and social, and they fall hardest on the long-term unemployed and disadvantaged groups.
Cyclical unemployment rises and falls with aggregate demand, and this has driven the recent movements in Australia's unemployment rate.
Start with the cycle because it explains most of the recent movement, and use the COVID episode as the clearest evidence.
- Theory
- The demand for labour is derived from the demand for output; a fall in aggregate demand reduces production and employment, amplified by the multiplier.
- Diagram
- The labour market graph of unemployment since 1978, with recessions shaded, or an AD-AS diagram with AD shifting left.
- Evidence
- Unemployment rose from 5.1 per cent in February 2020 to 7.4 per cent in July 2020 as GDP fell 6.8 per cent in the June quarter, then returned to 5.1 per cent by May 2021 as demand recovered.
- Against
- Not all of the 2020 rise was measured: participation fell from 65.6 to 62.2 per cent, so hidden unemployment understated the damage.
The stance of macroeconomic policy, and constraints on growth, explain why unemployment fell to a 48-year low and then rose again.
This paragraph links unemployment to the inflation constraint, which lifts the analysis above a list of causes.
- Theory
- Expansionary policy raises aggregate demand; contractionary policy to contain inflation lowers it. The NAIRU limits how far policy can push unemployment down.
- Diagram
- Phillips curve with unemployment below the NAIRU and inflation accelerating.
- Evidence
- A cash rate of 0.10 per cent and fiscal stimulus took unemployment to 3.4 per cent in October 2022, below the NAIRU, as inflation peaked near 8 per cent. The Reserve Bank raised the cash rate to 4.35 per cent by November 2023, and again to 4.35 per cent in May 2026 after cuts in 2025; unemployment rose to 4.6 per cent by August 2026, with the NAIRU estimated between 4.5 and 5 per cent.
- Against
- Labour force growth also mattered: net overseas migration and record participation of 67.2 per cent in January 2025 meant employment kept growing even as unemployment rose.
Structural and technological change set the floor under unemployment and determine who is unemployed for longest.
Use this paragraph to connect causes to the groups most affected.
- Theory
- Structural unemployment arises from a mismatch between the skills and locations of workers and the jobs available; hysteresis converts cyclical into structural unemployment.
- Diagram
- The long-term unemployment ratio over time.
- Evidence
- The closure of car manufacturing in 2016 and 2017; long-term unemployment at 36 per cent of the unemployed in 1993 against 16.4 per cent in April 2023; median job search of 27 weeks for 55 to 64 year olds against 12 weeks for 15 to 24 year olds.
- Against
- Structural change also creates jobs in growing industries such as health care and professional services, so its net effect depends on retraining and mobility.
The economic costs of unemployment are lost output, lower living standards, lost skills, a weaker budget and slower wages growth.
Rank the costs: lost output is the largest and is permanent, while budget costs are partly transfers.
- Theory
- Unemployment places the economy inside its production possibility frontier; the automatic stabilisers widen the deficit; excess labour supply slows wages growth.
- Diagram
- A production possibility frontier with the economy at a point inside it.
- Evidence
- Each percentage point of unemployment is about 156,000 people and very roughly \$20 to 25 billion of output a year; Wage Price Index growth fell to 1.3 per cent in 2020 and rose to 4.3 per cent in late 2023 as unemployment fell; record deficits in 2020-21 turned into surpluses in 2022-23 and 2023-24.
- Against
- Most of these costs reversed quickly after 2020 because the recession was short and policy kept workers attached to employers.
The social costs of unemployment fall on the most disadvantaged and can persist across generations.
End by returning to the judgement: the costs are largest and least reversible when unemployment is long-term, so the speed and targeting of policy matter most.
- Theory
- Unemployment reduces incomes most for those with fewest skills, increasing poverty and inequality; long-term unemployment is associated with health, family and social problems.
- Diagram
- A Lorenz curve moving further from the line of equality.
- Evidence
- 1.4 million jobless families (18.5 per cent of families) in June 2025, 233,000 with dependants; youth unemployment of 10.8 per cent and First Nations unemployment of 12 per cent (2021 Census).
- Against
- Income support and the progressive tax system cushion the income loss, and the tight labour market after 2021 drew many disadvantaged jobseekers into work.
Judgement
Analyse asks how the causes work and which matter most, and how the effects follow from them. Rank the causes: aggregate demand and the stance of macroeconomic policy drove the recent cycle, while structural and technological change set the floor under unemployment (the NAIRU). On effects, argue that the costs of a short cyclical rise are largely reversible, but those of long-term unemployment are not, which is why speed of response matters.
The full response also needs: Policy responses from Topic 4, if the question also asks how governments have addressed unemployment.
Is some unemployment worth its cost?
The costs of unemployment are the reason for the full employment goal. But the NAIRU shows that pushing unemployment too low also has a cost: accelerating inflation, which the Reserve Bank then has to reverse by slowing the economy, often at the cost of higher unemployment later. So policymakers weigh the costs of unemployment against the costs of inflation. They also weigh the timing: a short, shallow rise in unemployment does far less lasting damage than a long one, because the costs of long-term unemployment compound. That is why Australia's response to COVID aimed to keep workers attached to their employers, and why the Reserve Bank's strategy after 2022 was described as trying to lower inflation "while preserving as many of the gains in the labour market as possible". Some economists argue that the evidence from 2022 and 2023, when very low unemployment drew many long-term unemployed people back into work, shows the benefits of running a tight labour market are larger than was once thought. Others point to the inflation that followed.
The social costs of unemployment
AnswersWhat are the social costs of unemployment?
1. Poverty and inequality. Unemployed people depend on welfare payments, and those most likely to be unemployed are already on low incomes with fewer skills. Unemployment therefore widens the gap between rich and poor, increases poverty and reduces social mobility.
2. Personal and social problems. Long-term unemployment in particular is associated with:
These social problems have economic costs of their own. More resources must go to health care, welfare services, policing and the justice system.
3. Social tension. High unemployment and inequality can erode social cohesion and trust in institutions. After the global financial crisis, many advanced economies saw a backlash against globalisation, trade and immigration, which your notes link to unemployment.
Chain of reasoning
How long-term unemployment compounds its own costs
Exam question
Standard · about 5 min
3 marks
Explain the social costs of unemployment in Australia. Use evidence. (3 marks)
Hint 1Poverty and inequality.
Hint 2Jobless families and intergenerational effects.
Hint 3Health and social problems.
Where students lose marks on this one
Listing problems without explaining them.
Why it happens: Social costs are familiar.
Explain how unemployment causes each.
Written for this site.
Common mistake
The main cost of unemployment is the cost of JobSeeker payments to the government.
Why it happens: Welfare spending is visible in the budget.
Welfare payments are a transfer: money moves from taxpayers to the unemployed, and no resources are used up. The real economic cost is the output that is never produced, together with lost skills and the social costs. Budget costs matter, but they are not the main cost to the economy as a whole.
Exam question
Standard · about 2 min
1 mark
A student writes: 'The biggest economic cost of unemployment is the money the government spends on JobSeeker Payment.' What is wrong with this?
Hint 1Is a welfare payment a use of resources?
Hint 2What is lost to the economy as a whole?
Hint 3Transfer versus output.
Where students lose marks on this one
Confusing budget cost with economic cost.
Why it happens: The budget cost is visible.
The economy loses output, not the transfer.
Written for this site.