HSC Study

Injections, Withdrawals and Equilibrium Income

How injections (I + G + X) add to the circular flow of income and withdrawals (S + T + M) take from it, why the economy settles where the two are equal, and how to calculate an equilibrium level of national income from propensities or from a schedule.

35 min · HSC Topic Three - Economic Issues

Assumes you have read Aggregate Demand and Its Components.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

  • Injections add spending to the circular flow that does not come from domestic households' current income: investment (I), government spending (G) and exports (X).
  • Withdrawals (leakages) are income that is not passed on as spending on domestic output: saving (S), taxation (T) and imports (M).
  • Equilibrium is where .
    • If injections exceed withdrawals, income rises.
    • If withdrawals exceed injections, income falls.
  • Withdrawals rise with income. The share of each extra dollar withdrawn is the marginal propensity to withdraw: .
  • To calculate equilibrium when all withdrawals are proportional to income: . Check that equals at that income.

Injections and withdrawals in the circular flow

AnswersWhat are injections and withdrawals?

In the simplest circular flow, households supply their labour and other resources to firms. They receive income, and spend all of it back on the firms' output, so income goes round unchanged. Real economies have three places where money leaves that loop and three where it enters. Your notes list them:

Withdrawals (leakages)Injections
Saving (S): income households do not spendInvestment (I): firms' spending on capital, financed from saving
Taxation (T): income paid to governmentGovernment spending (G): financed from taxation or borrowing
Imports (M): spending that goes to foreign producersExports (X): spending by foreigners on Australian output

The pairs are linked but made by different people. Households decide how much to save; firms decide how much to invest. Governments set tax rates, but spending depends on budget decisions. Australians decide what to import; foreigners decide what to buy from Australia. Nothing makes each pair equal at every level of income.

Marginal propensity to withdraw

The share of each extra dollar of income that is saved, taxed or spent on imports: . The rest, the marginal propensity to consume domestic output, is spent in the domestic economy.

Withdrawals rise with income, because people save, pay tax and import more as they earn more. The three main injections are treated as autonomous: they depend on business confidence, government policy and world demand, not on this year's national income.

Exam question

Straightforward · about 2 min

1 mark

Which of the following is an injection into Australia's circular flow of income?

Select one answer

Hint 1Injections add spending that does not come from households' current income.

Hint 2Which option is spending by foreigners or firms on capital?

Hint 3Saving, tax and imports are withdrawals.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Choosing superannuation contributions.

    Why it happens: Super funds invest the money.

    The contribution itself is saving, a withdrawal; investment happens only if firms decide to spend on capital.

Written for this site.

Why the economy settles where withdrawals equal injections

AnswersHow is equilibrium determined by injections and withdrawals?

Equilibrium income: aggregate demand and aggregate supplyWith an MPC of 0.75 and a change in injections of 0, equilibrium income is 400.Full employment output0200400600800100012001400160002004006008001000120014001600National income and output, Y ($b)Planned expenditure ($b)
  • AS: output = expenditure (45°)
  • AD = C + I + G + (X − M)
Equilibrium is where planned spending equals output, or equivalently where leakages equal injections. It need not be at full employment: at the default settings the economy settles at 400, well short of full employment output of 600. An increase in injections of 50 closes the gap, because each dollar of new spending is multiplied by 1/(1 − MPC) = 4 as it is re-spent. A higher MPC makes the aggregate demand line steeper and the multiplier larger.
1
0
0.75
Equilibrium income
400, where AD meets the 45 degree line
Multiplier, k = 1/(1 − MPC)
1/(1 − 0.75) = 4.00
Change in income
0 × 4.00 = 0
Full employment
Equilibrium is 200 below full employment: a deflationary gap with cyclical unemployment. Injections would need to rise by 50.0 to close it.
If AD is above AS
Firms sell more than they produce and run down their stocks, then raise output, income and employment until the two are equal.
If AD is below AS
Unsold stocks build up, so firms cut production and employment, and income falls until the two are equal.

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Set the view to 2 to see the leakages and injections diagram. Injections are a flat line, because they do not depend on income. Withdrawals slope upwards.

  • Below equilibrium, injections exceed withdrawals. More spending enters the flow than leaves it, so firms' sales exceed output. Stocks run down, firms produce more, and income rises. As income rises, withdrawals rise too, until they equal injections.
  • Above equilibrium, withdrawals exceed injections. More is leaving than entering, stocks pile up, and output and income fall until the two are equal again.

This is the same equilibrium as the one where AD crosses the 45 degree line in the previous lesson, seen from a different angle. It is a stable point: the economy returns to it after any disturbance, unless injections or propensities change.

A change in injections moves equilibrium. If the government spends more on infrastructure, the injections line shifts up. Income must rise until withdrawals have risen by the same amount. The rise in income is a multiple of the rise in G, because only part of each extra dollar of income leaks out. That is the multiplier, the next lesson.

A change in withdrawals moves it too. If households decide to save more at every income level, the withdrawals line shifts up and equilibrium income falls. In Australia's June quarter of 2020, the household saving ratio jumped to 23.3 per cent, and output fell 6.8 per cent in the quarter.

Chain of reasoning

What happens when injections exceed withdrawals

  1. Firms' sales exceed their output, so stocks fall.
  2. Firms raise output and hire more workers, so national income rises.
  3. Higher income raises saving, tax and imports, so withdrawals rise.
  4. Income stops rising when withdrawals have risen to equal injections: the new equilibrium.

Exam question

Standard · about 5 min

3 marks

Explain what happens to national income when withdrawals from the circular flow are greater than injections. (3 marks)

Hint 1Compare spending with output.

Hint 2How do firms respond?

Hint 3What happens to withdrawals as income changes?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Saying income falls forever.

    Why it happens: The process seems self-reinforcing.

    Withdrawals fall with income, so the fall stops at a new equilibrium.

Written for this site.

Calculating equilibrium national income

AnswersHow do you calculate equilibrium income using leakages and injections?

When each withdrawal is a fixed share of income, , and . Setting withdrawals equal to injections:

Worked example3 marks

Equilibrium income from propensities

In a hypothetical economy, investment is $100 billion, government spending is $150 billion and exports are $50 billion. Households save 10 cents, pay 20 cents in tax and spend 10 cents on imports out of every dollar of income. Calculate the equilibrium level of national income, and the new equilibrium if government spending rises by $20 billion.

Add the injections

Add the propensities to withdraw

Solve for Y

The change in government spending

Injections rise to 320, so . Income rises by 50, which is 2.5 times the 20 increase in G.

Answer

Equilibrium national income is $750 billion. After the rise in government spending it is $800 billion, an increase of $50 billion.

Is that answer sensible?

At $750 billion: , and , so withdrawals are 300, equal to injections. At $800 billion withdrawals are , equal to the new injections.

From a table. Some questions give a schedule of income, withdrawals and injections. Equilibrium is the row where the two totals are equal. Above it withdrawals exceed injections; below it injections exceed withdrawals.

National income ($b)STMTotal withdrawalsIGXTotal injections
400206040120608040180
500307550155608040180
600409060190608040180

Here withdrawals rise by 35 for each 100 of income, so . At 500, injections exceed withdrawals by 25, so income must rise by . Equilibrium is about $571 billion, between the rows.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

In a hypothetical economy, I = $80 billion, G = $120 billion and X = $60 billion. The marginal propensity to save is 0.15, to pay tax 0.25 and to import 0.1. Calculate equilibrium national income in $ billion.

Hint 1Add the injections.

Hint 2Add the propensities to withdraw.

Hint 3Divide injections by the MPW.

Exam question

Standard · about 5 min

3 marks

In an economy in equilibrium at $1,000 billion, the marginal propensity to save is 0.1, to pay tax 0.2 and to import 0.2. Exports fall by $25 billion. Calculate the new equilibrium level of national income and explain why income falls by more than the fall in exports. (3 marks)

Hint 1Find the MPW.

Hint 2How far must income fall for withdrawals to fall by 25?

Hint 3Why is the fall larger than 25?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Answering \$975 billion.

    Why it happens: Subtracting only the initial fall.

    Income falls until withdrawals have fallen by the full 25, which needs a 50 fall in income.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Harder · about 5 min

3 marks

The table shows withdrawals and injections for a hypothetical economy.

| Y ($b) | S + T + M ($b) | I + G + X ($b) | | --- | --- | --- | | 200 | 50 | 110 | | 300 | 90 | 110 | | 400 | 130 | 110 |

(a) Calculate the marginal propensity to withdraw. (b) Calculate equilibrium national income. (c) State what is happening to stocks when income is $400 billion. (3 marks)

Hint 1How much do withdrawals rise for each 100 of income?

Hint 2At 300, how large is the gap between injections and withdrawals?

Hint 3Withdrawals exceed injections at 400.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Choosing \$300 billion as the closest row.

    Why it happens: Looking only at the table rows.

    Equilibrium can lie between rows; use the MPW to find it.

Written for this site.

Common mistake

In equilibrium, saving equals investment, taxation equals government spending and imports equal exports.

Why it happens: The pairs line up in the equation.

Only the totals must be equal. Australia usually has imports above exports and, in most years, government spending above tax revenue, offset by private saving above investment or the reverse. What matters for equilibrium is , not each pair.

Exam question

Harder · about 2 min

1 mark

A student writes: 'Because saving is a withdrawal from the circular flow, a rise in household saving is always bad for the Australian economy.' What is wrong with this?

Select one answer

Hint 1What does saving finance?

Hint 2When is lower spending helpful?

Hint 3What about the long run?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Treating a withdrawal as a loss.

    Why it happens: Withdrawal sounds like money disappearing.

    Saving is income not spent now; it funds investment and future spending.

Written for this site.

From the circular flow to the current account

Rearrange the equilibrium condition :

Private saving less investment, plus the budget balance, equals net exports. Read it the other way round: an economy that invests more than it saves, or whose government runs a deficit, must import more than it exports and borrow the difference from abroad. This is the savings and investment explanation of Australia's current account deficit from Topic 2. In the full national accounts X − M becomes the current account balance, including income payments. It also explains a result from 2019-20 to 2022-23. When households saved heavily during COVID and commodity export income soared, Australia's saving exceeded its investment, and the current account moved into surplus even though the government ran record deficits.