International Division of Labour and Migration
The least integrated of the five channels, why the work moved instead of the workers, and what flows back to the economies the workers left.
40 min · HSC Topic One - The Global Economy
Assumes you have read Technology, Transport and Communication.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
- The international division of labour is the allocation of stages of production between economies according to the cost and skill of their labour.
- Labour is the least integrated of the five channels, because moving a worker carries physical costs, social costs and an immigration barrier that capital never faces.
- So the division of labour went international mainly by moving the work: manufacturing to special economic zones in China and South East Asia, routine services to India, the Philippines and Malaysia.
- Where people do move, they move at both ends of the skill distribution, high skilled workers to higher pay and low skilled workers into jobs ageing economies struggle to fill.
- There were about 304 million international migrants in 2024, roughly 3.7 per cent of world population, up from about 220 million in 2010.
- Remittances to low and middle income economies reached about US$685 billion in 2024, several times the size of official development assistance and far more stable.
The judgement the exam wants: this channel transfers income reliably and productive capacity unreliably, because remittances finance consumption while the skills that generated them stay abroad.
The international division of labour
AnswersWhat is the international division of labour and how did it come about?
- International division of labour
The allocation of stages of production between economies according to the cost and skill of their labour. Transnationals place labour intensive manufacturing and routine services where wages are low, and keep design, research and high value services where skills are concentrated.
This is comparative advantage applied to labour rather than to finished goods, and it is the reason the previous two dot points matter. A firm can only separate design from assembly if communication is cheap enough to coordinate them, and it only bothers if the wage gap is large enough to pay for the separation.
Chain of reasoning
Why the work moved instead of the workers
Cost of moving a worker rises
Physical costs of travel and accommodation, social costs of leaving family and networks, and an immigration barrier that capital does not face. Only a small fraction of the world's workforce works outside its country of citizenship.
Cost of moving the work falls
Containerisation, broadband and the subsidiaries transnationals had already established made it cheap to send the task to the labour instead.
Offshoring and the fragmentation of production rises
Manufacturing relocated to special economic zones in China and the Asian newly industrialised economies; telecommunications, information technology, accounting and finance back office work relocated to India, the Philippines, Singapore and Malaysia.
Manufacturing employment in the advanced economies falls
Deindustrialisation and regional job displacement, concentrated in the towns built around a single industry, which is the origin of much of the political pressure against globalisation.
Where it breaks: The pattern holds for tradeable stages of production. A stage that must be performed where the customer is, such as construction or aged care, cannot be offshored, which is why those sectors rely on migration instead.
Common mistake
The international division of labour means workers moved to where wages were highest.
Why it happens: Division of labour sounds like it must involve labour moving.
Mostly the opposite happened. Because labour is the least mobile factor, firms moved the production stage to the workers rather than the workers to the production. Migration is a real part of this dot point, but it is the smaller part, and an answer that treats offshoring and migration as the same process misses the asymmetry that explains both.
What lifts this to a Band 6
The two halves of this dot point run in opposite directions, and saying so is a judgement. Offshoring moves low skilled work from rich economies to poor ones, which narrows the income gap between economies. Migration moves high skilled workers from poor economies to rich ones, which widens it. The net effect on any particular developing economy depends on which of the two it is more exposed to, and that is a far better sentence than listing benefits and costs.
Migration, and who actually moves
AnswersWhat are the patterns of international labour migration?
There were about 304 million international migrants in 2024, roughly 3.7 per cent of world population, against about 220 million in 2010. The share is rising slowly, which is itself the evidence that this channel is the least integrated: no other flow in this topic grew that slowly over the same period.
The direction is concentrated. Europe and Asia host the largest numbers, while the Gulf economies host the largest shares relative to their own populations, and the movement is mainly from emerging and developing economies towards the advanced economies, the newly industrialised Asian economies and the oil exporters of the Middle East.
Movement is concentrated at the two ends of the skill distribution, and the reasons differ:
| Who moves | Why they are pulled | Why they are pushed |
|---|---|---|
| High skilled workers, including graduates, health professionals and engineers | Higher pay and better opportunities in large high income economies, plus skilled migration programmes designed to attract them | Thin domestic labour markets for their skills, and lower returns to education at home |
| Low skilled workers in agriculture, care, construction and hospitality | Ageing populations in the advanced economies leave jobs local workers do not fill | Low wages and limited employment at home |
| Refugees and displaced people | Not an economic pull at all | Conflict and persecution, such as the roughly 8 million people who fled Ukraine after the invasion in 2022 |
The middle of the distribution largely stays put, which is why migration does not close the world wage gap the way trade in goods partially closes the world price gap.
Remittances, brain drain and what flows back
AnswersWhat are the effects of labour migration on the source economy?
- Workers' remittances
Payments sent home by workers employed abroad. They enter the source economy's balance of payments as secondary income on the current account, and for many developing economies they exceed both foreign aid and foreign direct investment.
- Remittances received
The numbers behind this graph
| Year | Remittances, US$ billion |
|---|---|
| 2019 | 548 |
| 2020 | 540 |
| 2021 | 605 |
| 2022 | 647 |
| 2023 | 656 |
| 2024 | 685 |
- Year
- 2024
- Remittances received
- US$685 billion
- Change across the series
- Up 25 per cent on 2019
- Left for health, education, housing and small business
- About US$171 billion, if 75 per cent goes on food, shelter and utilities
- The most recent figure
- A separate series published by the International Fund for Agricultural Development puts 2025 inflows at US$728.6 billion, up 94 per cent since 2016, sent by about 220 million migrants to about 1.1 billion relatives in transfers typically worth 300 to 400 dollars nine or ten times a year. It is on that publisher basis, so it is quoted beside the line rather than added to it.
- Against the other flows
- Remittances are several times official development assistance, which fell 23 per cent in real terms in 2025 to about US$174 billion, and they are far more stable than direct investment because they are sent by households rather than by firms responding to the cycle.
- Source
- World Bank and KNOMAD, Migration and Development Brief, 2024 figure is an estimate
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
Remittances to low and middle income economies reached about US$685 billion in 2024, having risen through the pandemic year of 2020 when almost every other flow in this topic fell. That stability is the analytically interesting property: a migrant worker keeps sending money home through a downturn, and often sends more, because the household at home needs it more. Direct investment does the opposite, and aid is set by donor budgets. In 2025 official development assistance fell about 23 per cent in real terms to roughly US$174 billion, which is about a quarter of the remittance total.
The transfers are also small and frequent rather than large and occasional. On the sending side, the remittance industry counts roughly 220 million migrant workers supporting about 1.1 billion relatives, typically sending 300 to 400 dollars nine or ten times a year, and estimates total flows of about US$728.6 billion in 2025 on a broader basis than the World Bank series in the figure. Quote whichever figure you use with its publisher, because the bases are not the same and the two totals should never be added.
Chain of reasoning
Migration: what flows back to the source economy
Workers' remittances rises
More stable than direct investment and larger than aid for many economies, and they reach households directly rather than through a government budget.
Networks and skills returning
Diaspora networks open trade and investment links, and returning workers bring methods learned abroad.
Brain drain falls
The same movement strips the source economy of the skilled workers it trained and paid to educate, widening the technology gap it was trying to close. Governments respond with incentives to retain skilled labour, which is a further cost.
Exploitation and irregular migration falls
Workers outside their own legal system are poorly protected by International Labour Organization standards on wages and conditions, and the gap is filled by people smuggling and illegal work, with enforcement costs for the destination economy and rising anti immigration sentiment.
Where it breaks: Remittances arrive as income for households. They finance consumption far more than investment, so they raise living standards more reliably than they raise productive capacity.
Common mistake
Remittances promote economic development in the source economy.
Why it happens: The money is large, it is stable, and it arrives in poor economies.
Remittances raise living standards, which is not the same as raising productive capacity. They arrive as household income and are spent mostly on consumption, housing and school fees rather than on capital formation, and the skills that earned them remain in the destination economy. The precise claim is that remittances reliably reduce poverty and unreliably raise growth, and a response that separates those two effects is doing the evaluation the question asked for.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Explain why labour is the least globalised of the drivers of globalisation, and assess the effects of labour migration on the economies workers leave. (4 marks)
Hint 1Two tasks, so structure the response in two parts and give each its own evidence.
Hint 2For the first part, compare the barriers facing a worker with the barriers facing a dollar or a container.
Hint 3For the second part, one flow runs back to the source economy and one resource leaves it. Name both.
Why this channel is the one policy can actually close
The chokepoint argument that runs through this topic reaches its limit here. A currency transaction cannot be inspected and a data flow cannot be stopped at a border, but a person can, and this is the only channel where the diplomatic barrier has always been the binding one.
That produces a result worth stating in an extended response: of the five channels, labour is simultaneously the one where the theoretical gains from integration are largest, because the wage gap between economies is far larger than the price gap for any traded good, and the one where integration is smallest. The gap between those two facts is entirely policy, and it is the reason estimates of the gains from freer migration dwarf the estimated gains from any remaining trade liberalisation.
Note the political economy, because an evaluate question rewards it. Trade liberalisation distributes its costs diffusely across an economy and its gains widely, which makes it politically survivable. Migration concentrates its perceived costs in specific communities and specific services, which makes it politically hard regardless of the aggregate gain. That is why this is the one channel with no equivalent of the World Trade Organisation.
Using Australia as the worked example
Australia is unusual enough to be a useful case, and the examiner will know the material from Topic 4.
Australia is a destination, not a source, and it runs a deliberately skill weighted permanent migration programme, so it captures the brain drain rather than suffering it: much of its skilled labour force was educated at another economy's expense. It is also exposed to the temporary end of the channel through international students and working holiday makers, which is why the closure of the border in 2020 produced immediate shortages in agriculture, hospitality and health care, and why net overseas migration rebounded sharply from 2022 once the border reopened.
Two uses follow. In a question about the effects of globalisation on Australia, this is evidence that the labour channel is integrated in one direction and barely at all in the other. In a question about the costs of globalisation for developing economies, Australia is the other side of somebody else's brain drain, and saying so shows you understand that the two effects are one movement described from two ends.
Exam question
Harder · about 8 min
5 marks
Analyse the effects of international labour migration on the economies that migrants leave.
Hint 1There are flows back to the source economy and there is something that does not come back.
Hint 2Remittances behave differently from every other flow in this topic during a downturn. Say how.
Hint 3A strong answer separates the effect on living standards from the effect on productive capacity.
Where students lose marks on this one
Concluding that remittances promote economic development in the source economy.
Why it happens: The sums are large, they are stable, and they arrive in poor economies.
Remittances raise living standards, which is not the same as raising productive capacity. They finance consumption far more than capital formation, and the skills that earned them stay abroad.
Writing only about the destination economy.
Why it happens: Most migration coverage is written from the destination's point of view.
The question names the source economy. Remittances, networks and brain drain are the three effects it asks for, and destination effects earn nothing here.
Written for this site.