HSC Study

Taxation, Transfer Payments and Other Assistance

How the tax and transfer system redistributes income in Australia, progressive, proportional and regressive taxes, marginal and average tax rates, means-tested transfers and the social wage, how much they change each quintile's share, and the effect of recent policies from pandemic support and the Stage 3 tax cuts to the 2026 changes to super, negative gearing and capital gains tax.

40 min · HSC Topic Three - Economic Issues

Assumes you have read Sources of Household Income.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

  • A progressive tax takes a larger share of income as income rises. Australia's personal income tax is progressive, with marginal rates of 0, 15, 30, 37 and 45 per cent in 2026-27.
  • A regressive tax takes a larger share of income from low-income earners. The GST is regressive because low-income households spend a larger share of their income.
  • Transfer payments such as the age pension, JobSeeker and Family Tax Benefit are means tested, so they go mainly to low-income households. Other assistance (the social wage), such as Medicare, public schooling and the NDIS, is worth more to them as a share of income.
  • Together they lift the lowest fifth's share of income from 4.1 to 12.0 per cent and cut the highest fifth's from 47.8 to 34.9 per cent (ABS, 2021-22).
  • Recent policies: pandemic payments cut inequality in 2020. The redesigned Stage 3 tax cuts (2024) and the cuts to the lowest rate (2026 and 2027) favour low and middle incomes more than the original plan. From July 2026 earnings on super balances above $3 million pay extra tax. From July 2027 the government plans to limit negative gearing and replace the capital gains discount.

Progressive and regressive taxation

AnswersHow does the taxation system affect the distribution of income?

Marginal tax rate

The rate of tax paid on each extra dollar of income.

Average tax rate

Total tax paid as a percentage of total income.

As your notes explain, the three types of tax are defined by what happens to the average rate as income rises.

TypeAverage rate as income risesEffect on distributionExample
ProgressiveRisesReduces inequalityPersonal income tax
ProportionalConstantNeutralCompany tax (30 per cent, or 25 per cent for smaller companies)
RegressiveFallsIncreases inequalityGST, excise on tobacco and fuel

Personal income tax, 2026-27

Taxable incomeMarginal rate
$0 to $18,200Nil (the tax-free threshold)
$18,201 to $45,00015 per cent (16 per cent in 2024-25 and 2025-26; 14 per cent from 2027-28)
$45,001 to $135,00030 per cent
$135,001 to $190,00037 per cent
Over $190,00045 per cent

Plus the 2 per cent Medicare levy. Source: Australian Taxation Office.

Because each extra dollar is taxed at a higher marginal rate, the average rate rises with income. Higher-income earners lose a larger share of their income, which narrows the gap in disposable income. Income tax was 15.8 per cent of household gross income in 2025-26.

The GST is regressive. The 10 per cent GST is the same dollar amount on the same purchase for everyone. Low-income households spend almost all their income, and on necessities, while high-income households save part of theirs. The GST therefore takes a larger share of a low income. Fresh food, health and education are exempt, which reduces but does not remove this effect.

Worked example4 marks

Marginal and average tax rates, 2026-27

Using the 2026-27 tax scale, and ignoring the Medicare levy and tax offsets:

(a) Calculate the income tax and average tax rate for a person earning $40,000 and for a person earning $200,000. (b) Each spends $22,000 (including GST) on goods that attract the 10 per cent GST. Calculate the GST each pays as a percentage of income. (c) Use your answers to explain which tax is progressive and which is regressive.

Tax on $40,000

dollars. Average rate per cent. Marginal rate 15 per cent.

Tax on $200,000

dollars. Average rate per cent. Marginal rate 45 per cent.

GST

GST is one eleventh of a GST-inclusive price: dollars for each person. That is per cent of the lower income and per cent of the higher income.

Answer

Income tax: $3,270 (8.2 per cent) and $55,870 (27.9 per cent). GST: 5.0 per cent and 1.0 per cent of income.

Is that answer sensible?

Income tax is progressive because the average rate rises with income, from 8.2 to 27.9 per cent. The GST is regressive because the same $2,000 is a larger share of the lower income. Note that the marginal rate (45 per cent) is always above the average rate (27.9 per cent) in a progressive system: only income above $190,000 is taxed at 45 per cent.

Exam question

Standard · about 4 min

2 marks

Using the 2026-27 income tax scale (nil to $18,200; 15 per cent to $45,000; 30 per cent to $135,000; 37 per cent to $190,000; 45 per cent above), and ignoring the Medicare levy and offsets, calculate the average tax rate for a person with a taxable income of $100,000, to one decimal place. (2 marks)

Hint 1Tax each band separately.

Hint 226,800 × 0.15 and 55,000 × 0.30.

Hint 3Average rate = tax ÷ income × 100.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Applying 30 per cent to the whole income.

    Why it happens: The marginal rate is the one people quote.

    Each rate applies only to income within its band.

Written for this site.

Concessions weaken progressivity. Your notes point out that tax concessions change the distribution without changing tax rates. The main ones flow mostly to high-income and wealthy households:

  • Superannuation. Contributions and earnings are taxed at 15 per cent, a large saving for someone on a 45 per cent marginal rate and little or none for a low-income earner.
  • Capital gains. Only half of a capital gain on an asset held for over a year has been taxed.
  • Negative gearing. Investors can deduct losses on investment properties against their wage income, which is worth most to those on the highest marginal rates.

Common mistake

A person on a 45 per cent marginal tax rate pays 45 per cent of their income in tax.

Why it happens: The top rate is the most quoted number.

The 45 per cent rate applies only to income above $190,000. A person earning $200,000 pays an average rate of about 28 per cent. Progressivity is about average rates rising, not the top rate.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Which statement best explains why the GST is regarded as a regressive tax?

Select one answer

Hint 1Compare tax paid with income.

Hint 2Who spends a larger share of income?

Hint 3Regressive refers to the average rate.

Transfer payments and other assistance

AnswersHow do transfer payments and other assistance redistribute income?

Transfer payments

Payments from the government to individuals that are not in return for producing goods or services. They are funded from taxation and include pensions, allowances and family payments.

Transfer payments are means tested: they are reduced as the recipient's income and assets rise, so they are targeted at low-income households.

  • Pensions: the age pension, the disability support pension and the carer payment.
  • Allowances: JobSeeker for the unemployed, Youth Allowance and Austudy for students.
  • Family payments: Family Tax Benefit and Parenting Payment.
  • Rent assistance: Commonwealth Rent Assistance for low-income renters.

Social assistance benefits were $175 billion in 2025-26, 7.1 per cent of household gross income. For the 22 per cent of households who rely mainly on them, they are most of their income.

Other assistance: the social wage. Governments also provide services free or below cost. Medicare, the PBS, public schools, TAFE, public housing, the NDIS, the Child Care Subsidy and HECS-HELP loans are called the social wage because they raise living standards without appearing in cash income. They are used by everyone, but they are worth far more as a share of income to low-income households.

How much redistribution happens. The ABS measures each quintile's share of income before and after tax, cash transfers and services provided in kind.

Income quintileShare of gross income before redistribution (%)Share after tax, transfers and services (%)
Lowest4.112.0
Second9.215.2
Third15.717.4
Fourth23.220.5
Highest47.834.9

Source: ABS, Australian National Accounts: Distribution of Household Income, Consumption and Wealth, 2021-22. Households ranked by income.

The lowest fifth's share nearly triples; the highest fifth's falls by more than a quarter. The bottom three quintiles are net gainers and the top two net contributors. Because the survey measure in the Lorenz curve lesson counts only cash, its Gini of 0.324 for disposable income understates how much the whole system equalises living standards.

Chain of reasoning

How the tax and transfer system narrows the gap

  1. Progressive income tax rises

    takes a larger share of high incomes
  2. Government revenue rises

    funds means-tested transfers and the social wage
  3. Disposable income of low-income households rises

    rises relative to high-income households
  4. Gini coefficient falls

    falls, and the Lorenz curve moves towards the line of equality

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Using data, explain how transfer payments and other assistance change the distribution of income in Australia. (3 marks)

Hint 1Means testing.

Hint 2The social wage.

Hint 3Quintile shares before and after.

The impact of recent policies

AnswersHow have specific recent policies affected the distribution of income in Australia?

Your notes explain the general rule: cuts to top tax rates or to welfare spending tend to widen inequality, while increases in welfare, community services or progressivity tend to narrow it. The recent record tests this.

PolicyWhat changedEffect on the distribution
Pandemic support, 2020-21JobKeeper wage subsidy (about $101 billion, per your notes) kept 3.5 million workers attached to jobs; the Coronavirus Supplement of up to $550 a fortnight roughly doubled JobSeeker.Narrowed. HILDA's Gini fell from 0.304 to 0.291 in 2019-20. It rose again to 0.323 in 2021-22 after the supplement ended.
Stage 3 tax cuts, redesigned, from 1 July 202419 per cent rate cut to 16 and 32.5 to 30; 37 per cent rate kept for $135,001 to $190,000; top threshold raised to $190,000.Less regressive than planned. The original design removed the 37 per cent bracket and, as your notes record, gave about half its benefit to the top tenth. The redesign shifted the gains towards low and middle incomes, though high earners still receive the largest cuts in dollars.
Cuts to the lowest rate, 2026 and 202716 per cent to 15 per cent from 1 July 2026 and 14 per cent from 1 July 2027: at most $268, then $536, a year.Mildly equalising. The same maximum cut for everyone earning over $45,000 is a larger share of a low income.
Payment increases, 2023 and 2024JobSeeker raised by $40 a fortnight (September 2023); Commonwealth Rent Assistance raised 15 per cent in 2023 and 10 per cent in 2024; Parenting Payment Single extended until the youngest child turns 14.Narrowed, by lifting the lowest incomes, though JobSeeker remains well below the poverty line.
Minimum wage, 1 July 2026The Fair Work Commission raised the National Minimum Wage by 6 per cent to $1,004.90 a week, and award rates by 4.75 per cent.Narrowed at the bottom of the wage distribution, for about 2.8 million award-reliant workers.
Division 296 tax, from 1 July 2026Legislated March 2026: an extra 15 per cent tax on realised earnings on super balances above $3 million, and an extra 25 per cent above $10 million.Narrows wealth inequality by reducing the largest super concessions, which go to fewer than 1 per cent of members.
Negative gearing and CGT, from 1 July 2027 (announced)2026-27 Budget: negative gearing limited to newly built housing for properties bought after budget night; the 50 per cent CGT discount replaced by inflation indexing with a minimum 30 per cent tax on gains.Would narrow wealth inequality by reducing concessions that mostly benefit high-income property investors. Not yet legislated.

Bracket creep works the other way. When incomes rise with inflation but tax thresholds stay fixed, more income is taxed at higher marginal rates. Average tax rates rise most, as a share of income, for low and middle-income earners, which is why governments periodically return it through tax cuts.

Common mistake

Any income tax cut makes the distribution of income more equal because everyone keeps more of their income.

Why it happens: Everyone does gain.

What matters is who gains as a share of income. A cut to top rates gives the largest gains to high-income earners and makes the system less progressive, so inequality widens. A cut at the bottom, or a larger tax-free threshold, is more equalising.

Exam question

Harder · about 11 min

6 marks

Assess the impact of TWO recent government policies on the distribution of income and wealth in Australia. (6 marks)

Hint 1Choose one tax and one transfer or wealth policy.

Hint 2Who gains as a share of income?

Hint 3Use the Gini or quintile evidence.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Describing policies without their distributional effect.

    Why it happens: Policies are easier to describe than assess.

    Say who gains as a share of income and what happened to inequality.

Written for this site.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Explain why the original Stage 3 tax cuts were criticised for their effect on the distribution of income, and how the 2024 redesign changed this. (3 marks)

Hint 1What happened to the 37 per cent bracket?

Hint 2Who received most of the original benefit?

Hint 3What did the redesign keep?

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: 'Someone earning $200,000 pays 45 per cent of their income in tax.' Which response is best?

Select one answer

Hint 1Marginal against average.

Hint 2Which income is taxed at 45 per cent?

Hint 3Work out the average rate.

Equity against efficiency

Redistribution has costs as well as benefits, and a strong answer weighs them.

  • Work incentives. When a welfare recipient earns more, their payment is withdrawn and they may start paying tax. The combined effective marginal tax rate can exceed 50 per cent, for example for a second earner with children in child care, discouraging extra work. Higher top marginal rates can similarly discourage effort or encourage tax avoidance.
  • The tax mix. Australia relies heavily on personal income tax. Reviews have long proposed shifting towards broader bases such as land tax or a broader GST. That can raise efficiency, but a larger GST would be regressive unless paired with compensation through transfers.
  • Wealth, not just income. Most redistribution works on income. Housing and super concessions, and the absence of an inheritance tax, mean the system does far less to redistribute wealth, which is why the 2026 changes to super, negative gearing and capital gains are significant.

The Productivity Commission and Treasury both find that Australia's system is among the most targeted in the OECD: it spends less than most countries on transfers but concentrates them on low-income households, so it achieves substantial redistribution at relatively low cost.