Use of a Budget Surplus
The choices a government has when revenue exceeds spending (retiring public debt, repaying foreign debt, building funds for future spending, or cutting taxes and raising spending), their effects on interest costs, national saving and the current account, and how the surpluses of 2022-23 and 2023-24 were used.
20 min · HSC Topic Four - Economic Policies and Management
Assumes you have read Methods of Financing Deficits.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
A budget surplus occurs when revenue exceeds spending. Your notes identify three main uses.
| Use | How | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Retire public debt | Buy back government bonds from the private sector, or issue fewer | Lower future interest payments; frees savings for private investment |
| Repay foreign debt | Use the surplus to repay bonds held overseas | Lower foreign liabilities and primary income debits, improving the current account |
| Save for the future, or fund tax cuts and spending | Invest in funds such as the Future Fund, or cut taxes and increase spending | Provides for future costs; tax cuts and spending add to demand |
- A surplus adds to national saving, which reduces reliance on foreign saving and eases pressure on interest rates: the reverse of crowding out.
- Recent surpluses: $22.1 billion in 2022-23 and $15.8 billion in 2023-24, the first since 2007-08. They were used mainly to borrow less, keeping gross debt well below earlier forecasts.
The options for a surplus
AnswersWhat can a government do with a budget surplus?
- Budget surplus
The outcome when government revenue exceeds government spending over a financial year, so the government has funds left over after meeting its spending commitments.
1. Retiring public debt. As your notes explain, the government buys back bonds it has previously sold to the private sector, or issues fewer new bonds as old ones mature. This is usually the preferred option:
- it reduces future interest payments, one of the fastest-growing parts of the budget;
- it adds to national saving and returns funds to the private sector, lowering interest rates and encouraging private investment;
- it rebuilds fiscal space to respond to future downturns.
2. Repaying debt accumulated overseas. The surplus can repay bonds held by foreign investors, with the Reserve Bank converting Australian dollars into foreign currency where needed. This reduces public foreign debt and future interest payments abroad, which reduces primary income debits and improves the current account.
3. Financing future spending, tax cuts or current spending. The government can invest the surplus in funds for future costs, or return it through tax cuts or new spending.
- The Future Fund was created in 2006 from surpluses and asset sales to meet the Commonwealth's unfunded public service superannuation liabilities, and other funds followed, including the Medical Research Future Fund and the Housing Australia Future Fund.
- Tax cuts or new spending return the surplus to the economy and add to aggregate demand, which can be inflationary if the economy is near capacity.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Which use of a budget surplus would most directly improve Australia's current account balance in future years?
Hint 1Primary income.
Hint 2Foreign liabilities.
Hint 3Interest paid abroad.
The surpluses of 2022-23 and 2023-24
AnswersHow were Australia's recent budget surpluses used?
After 14 years of deficits, the budget recorded surpluses of $22.1 billion (0.9 per cent of GDP) in 2022-23 and $15.8 billion (0.6 per cent of GDP) in 2023-24.
Why they occurred. They came mostly from revenue upgrades, not spending cuts: high iron ore, coal and gas prices raised company tax, and a strong labour market and high inflation raised income tax receipts through bracket creep.
How they were used. Under the fiscal strategy of banking most revenue upgrades, the surpluses were used mainly to reduce borrowing. The government issued fewer bonds than planned, so gross debt as a share of GDP was much lower than forecast at the October 2022 Budget, and future interest costs fell.
Why they did not last. When commodity prices and wage growth eased, revenue growth slowed while spending on the NDIS, aged care, defence and interest kept rising, and the budget returned to deficit in 2024-25. This showed that surpluses built on the cyclical component of the budget are temporary: Treasury estimates the structural balance remained in deficit.
Chain of reasoning
Using a surplus to retire debt
Budget surplus rises
revenue exceeds spendingGovernment bond issuance falls
the government borrows less and repays maturing debtPublic debt and interest payments falls
future budgets have more roomNational saving rises
less reliance on foreign saving and less pressure on interest rates
Exam question
Standard · about 7 min
4 marks
Explain why Australia recorded budget surpluses in 2022-23 and 2023-24, and how they were used. (4 marks)
Hint 1Revenue upgrades.
Hint 2Banking upgrades.
Hint 3Structural balance.
Where students lose marks on this one
Attributing the surpluses to spending cuts.
Why it happens: Surpluses usually follow restraint.
They came mainly from cyclical revenue upgrades.
Written for this site.
Choosing how to use a surplus
AnswersHow should a government decide how to use a surplus?
The best use depends on economic conditions.
- Economy near capacity, inflation above target. Retiring debt is best. Spending the surplus or cutting taxes would add to demand and work against the Reserve Bank. This was the situation in 2022-23 and 2023-24.
- High foreign debt, large current account deficit. Repaying foreign debt helps external stability.
- Large future costs. Saving through funds such as the Future Fund spreads the cost of predictable future spending, such as superannuation liabilities, across generations.
- Slowing economy. Tax cuts or productive spending, such as infrastructure and education, can support activity and raise future productive capacity.
Common mistake
A surplus means the government has too much money and should spend it.
Why it happens: A surplus looks like spare cash.
A surplus is usually the result of cyclical revenue gains, and it is often better used to reduce debt so that the government has room to respond in the next downturn. Spending it when the economy is near capacity is pro-cyclical and adds to inflation.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student writes: 'When the economy is near full employment and inflation is above target, the best use of a budget surplus is a large tax cut.' Which response is best?
Hint 1Aggregate demand.
Hint 2Pro-cyclical.
Hint 3Retire debt.
Lessons from the 2000s
From 1997-98 to 2007-08 the budget recorded surpluses in almost every year, driven by strong growth, the mining boom and asset sales, including Telstra. The government eliminated net debt by 2005-06, then created the Future Fund with surpluses and the proceeds of Telstra shares.
Critics later argued that much of the late-2000s mining boom revenue was spent on permanent tax cuts and new payments, which left a structural deficit once the boom faded. Budgets then stayed in deficit for 14 years after the GFC. Treasury has since built the lesson into its analysis: it now estimates the structural balance, and the fiscal strategy of banking most revenue upgrades is designed to avoid treating temporary commodity revenue as permanent.