Australia's Trade Policy
How Australia went from one of the most protected economies in the world to one of the most open, why governments cut protection, and the forms of assistance that remain, from anti-dumping duties to the Future Made in Australia tax incentives.
35 min · HSC Topic Two - Australia's Place in the Global Economy
Assumes you have read Methods of Protection and Their Effects and Effects of Exchange Rate Fluctuations.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
- Until the 1970s Australia was one of the most protected economies in the world, with high tariffs and quotas protecting manufacturing behind a small domestic market.
- Governments cut protection over five decades: a 25 per cent across-the-board tariff cut in 1973, the 1988 and 1991 statements that took general tariffs to 5 per cent, and slower schedules for the car (PMV) and textiles, clothing and footwear (TCF) industries, whose rent-seeking delayed their cuts.
- The aims: raise international competitiveness, shift resources towards comparative advantage, give consumers and firms goods at world prices, and drive structural change.
- Today 91 per cent of imports by value enter duty free (2024-25), and 457 "nuisance" tariffs were abolished in 2024, with 497 more to go.
- Protection has not disappeared; it has changed form. Industry budgetary assistance reached $16.8 billion in 2024-25, half of it tax concessions, plus anti-dumping duties (30 in force) and the Future Made in Australia agenda of production tax incentives for hydrogen and critical minerals.
Why Australia reduced protection
AnswersWhat were the aims of reducing protection in Australia?
Historically, governments protected Australian manufacturers because a small population and low production volumes made it hard for them to compete with larger foreign producers. From the early 1970s the Industries Assistance Commission (now the Productivity Commission), the Treasury and the National Farmers' Federation argued that protection bred inefficiency, raised prices, misallocated resources and lowered living standards. Exporters, especially farmers, also paid for it: tariffs raised the cost of their inputs and kept the dollar higher than it would otherwise have been.
Your notes set out four aims of reducing protection:
- Raise international competitiveness. Exposing import competing industries to foreign competition forces them to cut costs and innovate.
- Reallocate resources. Labour and capital move away from industries that cannot become competitive, towards those where Australia has a comparative advantage.
- Gain from integration. Consumers and businesses buy goods and services at lower world prices and with more variety, raising living standards.
- Drive structural change. In the long run, efficient firms produce what the global economy wants.
- Sunrise and sunset industries
A sunrise industry is new and emerging, often built on new technology. A sunset industry is declining or past its peak, often because of new technology or foreign competition. Car manufacturing and much of textiles, clothing and footwear became sunset industries in Australia once protection was removed.
From fortress to open economy
AnswersHow did Australia reduce protection over time?
Before the 1970s, tariffs on most imported goods were very high, and quotas limited the quantity of some imports, so imports often cost far more than local goods. Tariff reform came in stages:
| When | Policy | What it did |
|---|---|---|
| 1973 | Whitlam government | A 25 per cent across-the-board cut to all tariffs |
| 1970s and 1980s | Quotas on cars and TCF | Kept by the most heavily protected industries, whose tariffs reached as high as 65 per cent |
| 1988 | May Economic Statement (Hawke government) | General tariffs phased down to between 10 and 15 per cent |
| 1991 | March Industry Statement | General tariffs phased down to 5 per cent by 1996 |
| 1990s to 2010 | Car (PMV) schedule | Quotas abolished; tariff cut to 15 per cent (2000), 10 per cent (2005) and 5 per cent (2010) |
| 1990s to 2015 | TCF schedule | Tariffs cut to 25 per cent (2000), falling to a maximum of 5 per cent (2015) |
| 2016 to 2017 | End of car production | Ford closed in 2016, Toyota and Holden in October 2017, after government support ended |
| 2024 | Nuisance tariffs | 457 tariffs abolished from 1 July 2024; 497 more from 2026-27 |
The PMV and TCF schedules were slower than the general cuts for two reasons. First, the industries employed many workers in particular regions, so the government gave them time to adjust (retraining workers or retrenching them) and paid for adjustment programs. Second, these industries lobbied hard to keep their protection.
- Rent-seeking
Lobbying by an industry for government favours, such as tariffs or subsidies, that raise its income at the expense of consumers, taxpayers or other industries, without producing anything more.
The car industry shows both sides of reform. Tariff cuts and the end of annual subsidies led to the closure of local car making in 2017 and the loss of thousands of jobs in Adelaide, Melbourne and Geelong. But consumers now buy cars at close to world prices, and the labour and capital moved into other industries.
- Domestic demand
- Domestic supply
- Resources wasted in high cost production
- Consumption given up
- Tariff revenue
- Method
- Tariff
- Price consumers pay
- $9.00
- Price producers receive
- $9.00
- Domestic output
- 16.0 to 28.0
- Imports
- 40.0 to 16.0
- Who collects the transfer
- The government, as tariff revenue
- Transfer on imports
- $48.0
- Deadweight loss
- $36.0
- What the diagram does not show
- The retaliation, because this is one market in one economy.
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
Set the method to 1 (tariff) and reduce the protection per unit towards zero. Domestic production falls, imports rise, the domestic price falls towards the world price, and the deadweight loss shrinks. That is the logic of every row in the table.
Common mistake
Australia removed all protection in the 1980s when it floated the dollar.
Why it happens: The float and tariff reform were both part of opening the economy in the 1980s.
Floating the dollar (1983) was financial deregulation, not trade policy. Tariff reduction started in 1973, took general tariffs to 5 per cent only in 1996, and took until 2015 for TCF. A 5 per cent general tariff and some duties remain today.
Exam question
Straightforward · about 5 min
3 marks
Outline THREE aims of the Australian government in reducing protection. (3 marks)
Hint 1Think about the firms that faced import competition.
Hint 2Where should resources go?
Hint 3What do consumers gain?
Where students lose marks on this one
Listing "to sign free trade agreements" as an aim.
Why it happens: FTAs are part of trade liberalisation.
FTAs are a method; the aims are the outcomes the government wanted.
Written for this site.
Exam question
Standard · about 5 min
3 marks
Explain why tariffs on passenger motor vehicles (PMV) and textiles, clothing and footwear (TCF) were reduced more slowly than tariffs on other goods in Australia. (3 marks)
Hint 1What is rent-seeking?
Hint 2Where were these industries' workers?
Hint 3Why might governments allow time to adjust?
Where students lose marks on this one
Saying these industries were more efficient.
Why it happens: They kept higher tariffs.
They kept higher tariffs because they were less competitive, not more.
Written for this site.
How protected is Australia today?
AnswersHow much protection does Australia still have?
By international standards, very little. The Productivity Commission's Trade and Assistance Review 2024-25 reports:
| Measure | 2024-25 |
|---|---|
| Share of imports by value entering duty free | 91 per cent |
| of which duty free without any preference | 44 per cent |
| of which duty free through a preferential trade agreement | 34 per cent |
| Tariff revenue collected | $1.9 billion |
| Cost to businesses of claiming tariff preferences | $1.4 billion to $4.1 billion |
| Industry budgetary assistance | $16.8 billion, up 6.4 per cent |
| Share of budgetary assistance delivered as tax concessions | 51.6 per cent |
The comparison of the last two tariff rows is the Productivity Commission's main argument for removing the remaining tariffs. The government collects $1.9 billion a year, yet importers spend up to $4.1 billion on paperwork, such as proving where goods were made, to claim preferential rates under trade agreements. Many remaining tariffs raise little revenue and protect no local industry; these are the nuisance tariffs the government is abolishing.
Exam question
Standard · about 3 min
2 marks
In 2024-25, 91 per cent of Australia's imports by value entered duty free. Of these duty free imports, 34 percentage points entered through a preferential trade agreement. What percentage of the duty free imports entered through a trade agreement? Round to the nearest whole number.
Hint 1The 34 is a share of all imports.
Hint 2Divide by the duty free share.
Hint 3Multiply by 100.
Where students lose marks on this one
Giving 34.
Why it happens: The figure is in the data.
34 is a share of all imports, not of duty free imports.
Written for this site.
The forms protection takes now
AnswersWhat forms of assistance and protection does Australia use today?
Your notes make the key point: Australia has moved away from tariffs and quotas towards indirect assistance, such as tax breaks, grants and targeted duties, which is less visible but still shifts resources towards favoured industries.
- Budgetary assistance: $16.8 billion (2024-25). Grants and tax concessions, including the research and development tax incentive. Relative to their size in the economy, agriculture, forestry and fishing received 5.4 times, and manufacturing 3.0 times, their share of budgetary assistance.
- Future Made in Australia. Announced in the 2024-25 Budget, this industry policy supports clean energy and critical minerals. Its production tax incentives, legislated in February 2025, pay $2 per kilogram of renewable hydrogen produced and 10 per cent of the processing and refining costs of critical minerals, from 2027-28 to 2039-40. The Productivity Commission projects they will provide more than $11 billion in assistance over the next decade and beyond. Supporters see it as a response to large subsidies overseas, such as the US Inflation Reduction Act, and to national security risks in supply chains. Critics see a return to picking winners.
- Anti-dumping and countervailing duties. Extra duties on imports sold below their normal price or subsidised by foreign governments, mostly on steel, aluminium and other metals. There were 30 measures in force at 1 July 2026. The Productivity Commission has long argued these protect a few firms at the expense of the many that use their products.
- Export assistance. The Export Market Development Grants scheme, run by Austrade since 1974, reimburses small and medium exporters for part of their marketing costs abroad.
- Other barriers. A 5 per cent tariff on new cars from countries without an FTA with Australia, strict limits on importing used cars, and local content rules in defence purchasing, such as building AUKUS submarines in Australia.
Common mistake
Australia has no protection because almost all imports enter duty free.
Why it happens: Tariffs are the most visible form of protection.
Tariffs are now small, but budgetary assistance of $16.8 billion, anti-dumping duties and production tax incentives still assist particular industries. Assistance has changed form; it has not disappeared.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Which of the following best describes the Future Made in Australia production tax incentives?
Hint 1They are not a tariff.
Hint 2They reward production in Australia.
Hint 3Which industries are named?
Exam question
Harder · about 7 min
4 marks
Assess the extent to which Australia is a free trading economy today. (4 marks)
Hint 1What do the tariff figures show?
Hint 2What forms of assistance remain?
Hint 3Reach a judgement on the extent.
Where students lose marks on this one
Judging only by tariffs.
Why it happens: Tariffs are the textbook example.
Budgetary assistance is now far larger than tariff revenue.
Written for this site.
Exam question
Standard · about 2 min
1 mark
A student writes: 'The closure of Australia's car industry in 2017 proves that reducing protection lowered Australian living standards.' What is wrong with this?
Hint 1Who gained from lower car tariffs?
Hint 2Where did the resources go?
Hint 3Is one industry the whole economy?
Where students lose marks on this one
Judging a policy by its most visible losers.
Why it happens: Plant closures make the news.
Gains are spread thinly across many people and are easy to miss.
Written for this site.
Effective protection
A tariff on a finished good protects its producer, but a tariff on the producer's inputs works against it. The effective rate of assistance measures the combined effect on an industry's value added: it rises with tariffs on its output and falls with tariffs on its inputs. This is why the Productivity Commission reports effective rather than nominal rates, and why the high tariffs of the 1970s did so much harm to exporters, whose inputs were taxed while their outputs sold at world prices. A small worked case: if a firm sells a good for $100 using $60 of imported inputs, its value added is $40. A 10 per cent tariff on the good lets it charge $110, raising its value added to $50, an effective rate of 25 per cent. A 10 per cent tariff on the inputs as well would raise their cost to $66 and cut value added back to $44, an effective rate of only 10 per cent.
The new industrial policy debate
For forty years the consensus in Australian policy was to cut assistance, run by an independent body (the Productivity Commission) that published its costs. The rise of subsidies overseas, the US tariffs of 2025 and 2026 and concerns about supply chains for critical minerals have revived arguments for targeted industry policy. The key question for an evaluation is whether Future Made in Australia fixes a genuine market failure, such as the risk of depending on one country for critical minerals processing, or simply transfers income to favoured firms, as the car subsidies did.