HSC Study

Reasons for Differences Between Nations

Why economies at similar starting points end up decades apart, separated into the global environment an economy is handed and the domestic resources, institutions and policies it controls, and how the two interact.

75 min · HSC Topic One - The Global Economy

Assumes you have read Developing, Emerging and Advanced Economies.

The full teaching. Start here.

Global factors

The features of the world economy that an economy is handed rather than chooses: the trade system it exports into, the financial architecture it borrows in, the aid it receives and the terms on which technology reaches it.

Domestic factors

The features an economy's own decisions shape: its natural resources and how they are used, the size and quality of its labour force, its access to capital, its institutions and the policies its government runs.

The five things worth carrying out of this lesson:

  • Two categories, and the marks are in the interaction. Global factors set the opportunities available; domestic factors decide whether an economy can take them. Neither category alone accounts for anything, because both were the same for economies that ended up far apart.
  • Accumulation is the mechanism underneath most domestic factors. Income funds saving, saving funds investment, investment raises output per person. Break the chain anywhere, through low income, fast population growth or institutions that make investment unsafe, and it does not restart on its own.
  • Institutions are the single factor with the best evidence behind them. Two economies with the same resources and the same access to markets diverge on the security of property, the enforcement of contracts, the absence of corruption and the delivery of schooling and health.
  • Global factors work through four channels. Trade access, financial flows and debt, aid, and technology. Learn one piece of recent evidence for each and the essay is half written.
  • The strongest evidence available is a comparison, not an assertion. East Asia opened to trade and investment, saved at high rates and built state capacity; parts of sub-Saharan Africa faced the same world prices with weaker institutions, higher dependency ratios and heavier debt. The world environment was shared, so the difference has to be explained by what was not.

The two categories and why the order matters

Write the global factors first and the domestic factors second, then finish with the interaction. This is not a stylistic preference. The global environment is the constraint every economy faces, so it belongs first as the setting; domestic factors are what vary between economies inside that setting, so they carry the explanation; and the interaction is what turns two lists into an account.

The test of whether a response has done this is whether it can answer one question: if the global environment explains underdevelopment, why did some economies develop inside it? An answer that cannot is a description.

What lifts this to a Band 6

The command word does the arranging. Account means give reasons and show how they connect, so every factor needs a consequence attached and a rank against the others. A paragraph that names agricultural protection and stops has described a policy; a paragraph that names it, prices the loss in export earnings, and says that the loss matters most for an economy with a narrow agricultural export base and no capacity to diversify, has given a reason.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A response argues that differences in development are caused entirely by the global trade, finance and aid systems. What is the strongest objection to that argument?

Select one answer

Hint 1A cause has to vary if it is going to explain a difference.

Hint 2East Asia and sub-Saharan Africa faced the same trade rules over the same decades.

Hint 3What has to be true of a variable for it to account for divergence?

Domestic factors: the machine underneath them

Most domestic factors act through one mechanism, so it is worth building the mechanism once and then hanging the factors on it.

An economy's output per person depends on how much capital each worker has to work with, and capital comes from investment, which is funded out of saving, which comes out of income. Capital also wears out, and a growing population spreads the same capital across more workers. So an economy with low income saves little, invests little, and can find that new investment barely replaces what wears out and equips the extra people.

Why two economies that start together pull apartWith 8 per cent of income saved, population growth of 2.5 per cent and an institutional setting of 35, income per person reaches 86 on the index after 40 years against 421 for the comparison economy.Both start hereThe gap after a working lifetime0102030400100200300400500600700YearsOutput per person (index, both economies start at 100)
  • The comparison economy
  • The economy you are setting
Three domestic factors, one picture. Saving funds the investment, population growth dilutes it, and the institutional setting decides how much output each unit of capital yields. Low saving with fast population growth produces a flat line, which is the vicious cycle of poverty drawn as a graph. Notice also that the curve bends: the same extra capital adds less income the more of it an economy already has, which is why poorer economies can grow faster when the other two settings allow it.
The numbers behind this graph
YearThe economy you are settingThe comparison economy
0100100
1094217
2091306
3088372
4086421
8 %
2.5 %
35
Income per person after 40 years
86 on the index, against 421 for the comparison economy
Average growth over the period
-0.37 per cent a year, so income per person is falling
Where this path is heading
83 on the index, the level at which new investment only replaces what wears out and equips the extra people
What each slider is doing
Saving funds the investment, population growth of 2.5 per cent spreads the capital thinner each year, and the institutional setting multiplies the output that each unit of capital yields.
The trap
Below about 8 per cent saved, with population growth above 2 per cent, investment does not replace what wears out. Income per person stalls or falls, saving stays low because income is low, and the cycle closes on itself.
What this figure leaves out
Every global factor. Access to export markets, the terms on which finance and technology arrive, debt servicing and aid all sit outside this model, and they are why an economy can do everything on these three sliders and still not converge.
Read it as
A model, not data. The index has no dollar value and the numbers are illustrative.

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Set the first slider low and the second high and the line flattens or falls while the comparison economy pulls away. That flat line is the vicious cycle of poverty: income is too low to save, so investment is too low to raise income, so income stays too low to save.

The third slider is the one that does the most work over the full range. It scales how much output each unit of capital yields, which is how institutions enter: investment in an economy where contracts are not enforced, officials expect payment and electricity is unreliable simply produces less than the same investment elsewhere.

Chain of reasoning

How a domestic constraint becomes a development gap

  1. Most income is consumed because it has to be. National saving is a small share of a small income.

  2. Domestic saving is thin and the financial system is shallow, so firms cannot borrow. Foreign investment could fill the gap, but it goes where returns are safest, which is where institutions are already strong.

  3. Population growth is fast, so the capital stock is divided among more workers each year. Dependency ratios are high, which means a smaller share of the population is producing and a larger share needs schooling and health care.

  4. Output per worker depends on the capital and the skills behind each worker. Neither rises, so wages and profits stay low.

  5. Low income means low saving and low tax revenue. Low tax revenue means the government cannot supply the education, health and infrastructure that would raise productivity. The starting condition is reproduced.

The three factors the syllabus expects beside this mechanism are the ones that determine what goes into it.

Natural resources are an advantage that can reverse. Abundant reserves raise export income directly, which is why several oil exporters have income per person at advanced economy levels. They can also narrow the export base, push up the exchange rate so that manufacturing and agriculture become uncompetitive, and tie the budget to a price set on world markets. The label for this is the resource curse, and the mechanism is why a resource discovery is not automatically a development strategy.

Labour supply and quality work through both the size and the skill of the workforce. Rapid population growth raises the dependency ratio; barriers to schooling, and in particular to schooling for girls, cut the productivity of the workers an economy already has and lower participation for decades.

Institutions and policy are the multiplier on everything else. Secure property, enforceable contracts, a functioning tax system and the absence of conflict decide whether saving is invested at home rather than sent abroad, and whether foreign investors arrive at all. Roughly a quarter of the world's people live in places affected by conflict or institutional fragility, and no other factor on this list survives contact with that one.

Common mistake

Why it happens:

Treating population growth as a cause of poverty in itself. The number of people is not the constraint; the ratio of capital and services to people is. An economy with fast population growth and fast capital accumulation raises income per person perfectly well, which several East Asian economies did. State the mechanism, which is that fast growth in the workforce requires matching investment simply to hold capital per worker constant, and the point earns its mark.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Which sequence correctly describes the vicious cycle of poverty?

Select one answer

Hint 1Start with where investment funds come from.

Hint 2What share of a very low income can be saved?

Hint 3Close the loop: what does low investment do to the income you started with?

Global factors: four channels, one recent piece of evidence each

The global environment is not neutral between economies. It is the product of rules written mostly by the economies that were already rich, and it works through four channels.

The trade system. Developing economies export what they can produce, which is disproportionately agricultural goods and simple manufactures, and these are the categories where protection in high income economies remains heaviest. Support to producers in OECD economies has fallen by about half since the mid 1980s, but it is still around 40 per cent of farm income in Japan and Korea, and the European Union's Common Agricultural Policy remains a large share of the Union's budget. The Doha Development Round, opened in 2001 precisely to address this, has never been concluded. The dispute settlement system that a small economy would use to challenge a large one has been unable to hear appeals since the Appellate Body lost its quorum in 2019. The one recent success to quote is the WTO agreement on fisheries subsidies concluded in 2022, which is narrow and took twenty years.

Financial flows and debt. Foreign direct investment now goes disproportionately to developing economies, but it concentrates in the larger emerging ones; the 46 least developed economies receive a very small share of global inflows. Short term flows arrive when returns are attractive and leave when they are not, which is why financial crises have set development back by years in East Asia and Latin America. Debt is the channel that has moved most since 2020: borrowing rose through the pandemic, then world interest rates rose sharply from 2022, and the result was a wave of debt distress in low income economies, with Zambia, Ghana and Sri Lanka all restructuring. The Debt Service Suspension Initiative of 2020 and 2021 deferred payments rather than cancelling them, and the G20 Common Framework that replaced it has been slow because the creditor group is now much wider than the traditional lenders.

Aid. The promise is old and the shortfall is measurable.

Development aid against the promiseAustralia gives 0.19 per cent of its national income as aid, against a target of 0.70 per cent, and 5 of the 12 donors shown reach it.Norway1.09Luxembourg0.99Sweden0.91Germany0.79Denmark0.74United Kingdom0.58France0.50Japan0.44Canada0.38Committee total0.37Italy0.27United States0.24Australia0.19Target 0.70%00.250.50.751Aid given as a share of the donor's national income (%)
The target has been 0.7 per cent of national income since 1970 and the committee as a whole has never reached half of it. The useful exam point is not that aid is small but that its size is a choice: the bars show that donors of similar wealth give three and four times as much as each other, so the shortfall is a policy decision rather than a constraint.
The numbers behind this graph
DonorAid, % of national incomeNational income, US$ billion
Norway1.09545
Luxembourg0.9960
Sweden0.91620
Germany0.794100
Denmark0.74410
United Kingdom0.583300
France0.503000
Japan0.444400
Canada0.382100
Committee total0.3755000
Italy0.272200
United States0.2427000
Australia0.191700
13
0.70 %
Australia
0.19 per cent of national income, which is 0.27 times the target of 0.70 per cent
Donors at or above the target
5 of 12 shown
Aid actually given by these donors
About 183 billion United States dollars in the reference year
What the target would add
About 170 billion dollars more a year if every donor shown reached 0.70 per cent
Committee average
0.37 per cent, roughly half the promise made in 1970
What counts as aid here
The published figures include the cost of housing refugees inside the donor economy, which rose sharply after 2022. That money is counted as aid and never leaves the donor, so the share reaching developing economies is smaller than the bars suggest.
Why the amount is not the whole argument
Tied aid, which must be spent on the donor’s own goods, and the share paid to consultants in donor countries both cut what reaches the recipient. Aid directed by strategic interest also goes to the economies a donor cares about rather than the ones in most need.
Source
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, Development Assistance Committee, official development assistance statistics, 2023 preliminary data

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Move the donor slider along the bars. The spread is the argument: economies of similar wealth give three and four times as much as one another, which means the shortfall is a choice rather than a constraint. Move the target slider and the readout prices the choice.

The quality argument matters as much as the quantity. Aid counted in the published figures includes the cost of housing refugees inside the donor economy, which rose sharply after 2022 and never leaves the donor. Tied aid, which must be spent on the donor's own goods and services, raises the cost of what is delivered. A share is paid to consultants in donor economies, and a share is debt relief on past loans rather than new spending. Aid is also allocated with strategic interests in view, so it does not flow to where need is greatest, and multilateral aid, which is better targeted, is less than a third of the total.

Technology. Adoption requires the electricity, the network and the schooling to use it, so diffusion is fastest where development is already highest. About a third of humanity was still not using the internet in 2022, and almost all of those people live in developing economies. Intellectual property rules under the TRIPS agreement raise the cost of access and require administrative systems that are themselves expensive to run; the limited waiver agreed for COVID-19 vaccines in June 2022 came after the period in which it would have mattered most. The same divergence appeared in the pandemic itself: high income economies had vaccinated most of their populations before many low income economies had reached a tenth of theirs.

What lifts this to a Band 6

One reform in the other direction is worth knowing, because it lets you write a balanced paragraph rather than a complaint. The OECD and G20 agreement on a global minimum corporate tax rate of 15 per cent, which more than 135 jurisdictions signed and which began applying in the European Union and elsewhere from 2024, targets exactly the profit shifting that costs developing economies a disproportionate share of their revenue base. Naming a reform, its rate and its start date is worth more than a paragraph of adjectives.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Explain how the global financial system contributes to differences in economic development between economies.

Hint 1Separate the kinds of flow: direct investment, short term flows and borrowing.

Hint 2Ask what each one requires from the recipient, and what it does when conditions elsewhere change.

Hint 3Debt is the channel that has moved most since 2020. What changed in 2022?

Putting the two together, which is where the marks are

The global environment was broadly shared. The outcomes were not, and the comparison is the strongest evidence a response can use.

FactorEast Asian economies from the 1970sMany sub-Saharan African economies
OpennessOpened to trade and foreign investment early, and exported manufacturesExported primary commodities into protected markets, with a narrow base
SavingNational saving rates among the highest recordedLow saving from low income, with limited financial depth
PopulationGrowth slowed as incomes rose, lowering dependency ratiosHigh growth and high dependency ratios for longer
InstitutionsEffective administration and heavy public investment in schoolingConflict and institutional fragility in a significant number of cases
DebtLargely avoided debt crisesRepeated debt distress, most recently from 2022

Read across the table rather than down it. The first row is a domestic policy choice about a global opportunity, which is the interaction in one line: the trade system was there for both, and only one group of economies had the ports, the workforce and the investor confidence to use it.

The honest qualification is that the direction of causation is not settled. Do good institutions cause development, or does development pay for institutions? Both operate, which is why the relationship is a cycle and why the reasons reinforce each other rather than sitting side by side. Saying so is a mark, not a hedge.

Common mistake

Why it happens:

Blaming the global system alone, or the developing economy alone. Both are single cause answers and both cap at a middle band. The global system left development possible but expensive, and the economies that developed did so by building the domestic capacity to pay that cost. Write the constraint, then write the response to it.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

East Asian economies and many sub-Saharan African economies faced the same global economic conditions after 1970 but developed at very different rates. Explain why.

Hint 1If the global conditions were shared, what has to carry the explanation?

Hint 2Compare saving rates, population growth, institutional capacity and openness to trade and investment.

Hint 3Finish with the interaction rather than with a list.

The middle income trap. A great many economies have moved from low income to middle income and then stopped. The reason is that the strategy which delivered the first move, shifting workers out of subsistence agriculture into low cost manufacturing, is exhausted once wages rise: the economy is no longer the cheapest producer and is not yet an innovator. Escaping it requires a second set of institutions, which is research capacity, tertiary education and a financial system that will fund risky projects. This is why the group of economies classified as emerging is so much larger than the group that has joined the advanced economies.

Convergence is conditional. Standard theory predicts that poorer economies grow faster, because capital added where there is little of it yields more. Observed growth has converged only among economies with similar institutions, savings rates and access to markets. The model in this lesson shows why: each economy's path heads for its own level, set by its own savings rate, population growth and institutional quality, so convergence happens within groups of similar economies rather than across all of them.

What the pandemic did to the gap. COVID-19 reversed the pattern of the previous three decades in a specific way. Advanced economies had the fiscal capacity and the borrowing cost to spend their way through it, running deficits that a low income economy could not have financed at any interest rate; they also secured vaccine supply first. Extreme poverty rose for the first time in a generation, the recovery was slower where fiscal support was smaller, and the debt taken on during the pandemic became a servicing burden once world interest rates rose from 2022. The gap widened because of a shared shock, which is a precise illustration of how global conditions interact with domestic capacity.

The climate dimension. The economies with the lowest historical emissions face the largest losses from climate change relative to output, and they borrow at the highest cost to adapt. The promise of US$100 billion a year in climate finance, made in 2009 for 2020, was reported met for the first time in 2022, and the new goal agreed in 2024 is US$300 billion a year by 2035. Most of what is delivered is loans rather than grants, which adds to the debt burden that already constrains development spending. Expect this to appear in future papers as a development question rather than an environmental one.

A caution on the evidence. The comparisons in this lesson are between groups of economies over decades, and the factors move together, so no single study isolates one cause. Be precise in the essay about what is established, which is that institutions, openness and accumulation are all associated with development and reinforce one another, and what is contested, which is their ranking.

Essay planpriority 10 of 16 · 20 marks

Account for the differences in economic development between economies.

Account for
Give the reasons something happens, as a chain of cause and effect that ends at the observation.
Thesis
Differences in development are produced by the interaction of a global environment that makes development possible but expensive and a set of domestic factors that determine whether an economy can pay that cost. The global factors explain why development is difficult everywhere; the domestic factors, and institutions above all, explain why it happened in some economies and not others facing the same conditions.
  1. The global trade system sets the terms on which a developing economy can earn its way out, and those terms are worst in the goods it actually exports.

    The counterargument is the one to concede and then use. If the trade system were the binding constraint, the economies that grew through exporting manufactures could not have done it. What the system explains is the cost and the difficulty, and in particular why an economy with an agricultural export base faces a steeper climb than one that can move into manufactures.

    Theory
    An economy specialising by comparative advantage requires access to the markets where its exports are sold. Protection in the importing economy lowers the price received and the volume sold, so it reduces export income and the saving available for investment.
    Diagram
    The methods of protection figure, read from the exporter's side: the subsidy and the tariff both shrink the quantity supplied by the foreign producer at every price.
    Evidence
    Agricultural support of about 40 per cent of farm income in Japan and Korea and the European Union's Common Agricultural Policy; total OECD producer support roughly halved since the mid 1980s but concentrated in exactly the categories developing economies export; the Doha Development Round opened in 2001 and never concluded; the WTO Appellate Body unable to hear appeals since 2019, leaving a small economy without a forum against a large one; the narrow fisheries subsidies agreement of 2022 as the one recent success, after twenty years of negotiation.
    Against
    Trade access has improved in absolute terms. Average applied tariffs are far lower than in 1990, preferential access schemes for least developed economies exist, and the economies that used the system hardest, in East Asia, developed fastest inside the same rules.
  2. Financial flows and debt determine whether an economy can invest beyond its own saving, and since 2022 this channel has tightened sharply.

    The evaluative move is to separate the flow from its terms. The problem is not that developing economies receive foreign capital but that they receive the volatile kind on terms set by conditions in the lending economies, so a decision taken in Washington or Frankfurt for domestic reasons arrives as a development constraint.

    Theory
    Investment can exceed domestic saving only by importing capital. Foreign direct investment brings capital and technology together but goes where returns are most secure; borrowed capital must be serviced in a foreign currency, so a rise in world interest rates or a depreciation raises the real burden without any change in the borrower's behaviour.
    Diagram
    The IMF programme figure, where conditionality contracts the economy in the short run in exchange for restored access to finance.
    Evidence
    The 46 least developed economies receiving close to 1 per cent of global foreign direct investment inflows while emerging economies receive the bulk; portfolio flows reversing in the East Asian crisis of 1997 and in Latin America in the early 2000s; borrowing through the pandemic followed by the fastest rise in world interest rates in four decades from 2022; sovereign defaults and restructurings in Zambia, Sri Lanka and Ghana; the Debt Service Suspension Initiative of 2020 and 2021 deferring rather than cancelling payments; the G20 Common Framework slowed by a creditor group that now includes large bilateral lenders outside the traditional group; corporate tax avoidance estimated in the hundreds of billions of dollars a year, with the OECD and G20 minimum rate of 15 per cent applying from 2024 as the counter measure.
    Against
    Capital mobility has also financed development. Foreign investment built the export manufacturing base in South East Asia, remittances now exceed aid and foreign direct investment combined for many low income economies, and the IMF's allocation of special drawing rights in 2021 provided reserves without conditions.
  3. Aid and technology transfer were the mechanisms designed to close the gap, and both are too small and too badly targeted to do it.

    The distinction that earns the mark is between the quantity of aid and its quality. A response that only says aid is below the target has made one point; a response that shows the published figure overstates what arrives, because of in-donor refugee costs, tied purchases and consultants in donor economies, has explained why raising the number alone would not close the gap.

    Theory
    A transfer from a high income to a low income economy raises the recipient's capacity to invest without requiring servicing. Its development value depends on the amount, on whether the money is spent in the recipient economy and on whether it reaches the economies with the greatest need.
    Diagram
    The aid figure, with the target line at 0.7 per cent of national income and the spread between donors of similar wealth.
    Evidence
    The 0.7 per cent target set in 1970 and reached by only a handful of donors; the committee average around 0.37 per cent of national income in 2023, roughly half the promise; in-donor refugee costs counted as aid and rising sharply after 2022; tied aid requiring purchases from the donor; multilateral aid, which is better targeted at the poorest economies, under a third of the total; about a third of the world not using the internet in 2022, almost all in developing economies; TRIPS raising the cost of access to technology, with the COVID-19 vaccine waiver agreed only in June 2022, after the period in which it mattered; vaccination rates in high income economies far ahead of low income economies through 2021.
    Against
    Aid has clear successes where it is directed at specific health and education outcomes, and the multilateral organisations are measurably better at targeting than bilateral donors. Technology transfer through foreign investment and through mobile networks has moved faster than aid, and mobile banking in East Africa is the standard example.
  4. Domestic factors carry the weight of the explanation, because they varied between economies that faced the same global environment.

    This is where the judgement is stated rather than implied. The domestic factors carry more of the explanation because they vary where the global factors are common, and the strongest evidence for that is the comparison itself: the same trade rules, the same aid architecture and the same technology regime produced East Asian convergence and sub-Saharan African divergence over the same forty years.

    Theory
    Output per person rises when capital per worker and productivity rise. Saving funds the investment, population growth dilutes it, and institutions determine the return on it and whether investment occurs at all. Where income is too low to save and institutions make investment unsafe, the constraint reproduces itself, which is the vicious cycle of poverty.
    Diagram
    The accumulation figure, with two economies starting at the same income and separating on savings, population growth and institutional quality alone.
    Evidence
    East Asian saving rates among the highest recorded, matched with openness to foreign investment and heavy public investment in schooling; dependency ratios above 100 per cent in the poorest economies against roughly 55 per cent in Australia; about a quarter of the world's population living in areas affected by conflict or institutional fragility; the Corruption Perceptions Index separating the highest and lowest development groups almost completely; the resource curse, where an export boom appreciates the exchange rate and narrows the export base; middle income economies containing a large share of the world's poorest people, which shows that national income growth alone does not deliver development; the inability of developing economy governments to reduce inequality through tax and transfer because their tax bases are narrow.
    Against
    Domestic factors are themselves partly produced by global ones. Institutions in many economies were shaped by colonial administration and by borders drawn externally, and repeated commodity price shocks and debt crises have destroyed state capacity that was being built. The causation runs both ways, so the ranking is a judgement rather than a finding.
  5. Recent events have widened the gap rather than closed it, which is what makes the question current.

    Ending here rather than on a general statement is what separates a strong response. The question is set in the present, and the most recent decade supplies a test of the whole argument: a shared shock produced different outcomes, in the direction that the domestic capacity to respond would predict.

    Theory
    A common shock has uneven effects where the capacity to respond is uneven. Fiscal capacity, borrowing cost and access to supply determine how much of a shock an economy can absorb, so a shared event increases dispersion.
    Diagram
    The extreme poverty figure, where the world line turns up in 2020 for the first time in a generation, with the regional lines separating.
    Evidence
    Advanced economies financing large deficits through the pandemic at low interest rates while low income economies could not; vaccine access divided sharply by income through 2021; extreme poverty rising in 2020 for the first time in a generation; the rise in world interest rates from 2022 turning pandemic borrowing into debt distress; food and energy price rises after 2022 falling hardest on economies that import both; climate finance of US\$100 billion a year, promised in 2009 for 2020 and reported met only in 2022, with the new goal of US\$300 billion a year by 2035 agreed in 2024 and delivered mostly as loans.
    Against
    The divergence is not uniform. Several emerging economies recovered quickly, remittances proved more stable than expected, and the poverty rate resumed its fall after 2021, so the reversal was a setback to the trend rather than a change in its direction.

Judgement

Domestic factors carry more of the explanation, because the global environment was broadly common to economies whose outcomes diverged by decades of life expectancy. The global factors are not a footnote: they set the price of development and they have tightened since 2022 through debt servicing costs and the erosion of the trade rules. But the decisive variable is institutional capacity, since it determines saving, investment, the return on both and an economy's ability to use whatever global opportunity exists.

The full response also needs: The indicators lesson supplies the measurement, so define development and name the Human Development Index rather than assuming them. If the question is set on globalisation instead, this material becomes the explanation of uneven benefits and priority 12 is the plan to follow. If it is set on a single economy, the case study in priority 8 supplies the evidence and this structure supplies the argument.

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 11 min

6 marks

Account for the differences in economic development between economies, with reference to both global and domestic factors.

Hint 1Account asks for reasons with a relationship between them, so rank them and connect them.

Hint 2Use two global channels and two domestic factors rather than listing eight.

Hint 3Attach a consequence to every factor, and state which category carries more of the explanation.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Listing eight factors with a sentence each

    Why it happens: The notes present the material as two lists, so it is reproduced as two lists.

    Four factors with mechanisms and evidence outscore eight named factors. Account requires relationships between reasons, which a list cannot show.

  • Finishing without a ranking

    Why it happens: Both categories look equally important when each is written well.

    State which carries more of the explanation and why. The argument that domestic factors vary while global factors are common is the standard way to earn that mark.

Written for this site.

Through a marker’s eyes

5 marks

Explain how global factors contribute to differences in economic development between economies.

The attempt

2 out of 5

Global factors are important reasons for differences in development between countries. Developed countries have more power in the global economy, so they write the rules to suit themselves. They protect their agriculture, which stops developing countries from exporting. They also do not give enough foreign aid, as the amount is well below what was promised. Global financial markets are unstable and cause crises in developing countries. Technology is also concentrated in developed countries. All of these factors mean that developing countries find it hard to develop and the gap between rich and poor countries gets bigger.

What the marker sees

Two marks. Four channels are named, which is the identification requirement, and the direction of each effect is right. Nothing beyond that is done. No figure appears anywhere, not even the 0.7 per cent target that the response alludes to, and no mechanism is completed: agricultural protection is said to stop exports without saying that the loss of export income is what reduces the saving available for investment. The last sentence asserts a widening gap, which is contestable and, in the case of poverty, wrong for most of the period. A five mark explain question needs the chain from the global factor to the development outcome, and the chain is missing.

The same answer, fixed

5 out of 5

Global factors shape development by determining the terms on which an economy can earn, borrow and learn.

Trade access is the first channel. Protection in high income economies is concentrated in agriculture and simple manufactures, which are what developing economies export: producer support is still about 40 per cent of farm income in Japan and Korea, and the Doha Development Round opened in 2001 to address this has never concluded. Lower export prices and volumes mean lower export income, which means less national saving available to fund investment, so the constraint arrives as a lower rate of capital accumulation.

Finance is the second. Foreign direct investment is drawn to security of return, so the 46 least developed economies receive close to 1 per cent of global inflows while emerging economies receive the bulk. Borrowing must be serviced in foreign currency, so the rise in world interest rates from 2022 turned pandemic era borrowing into debt distress in Zambia, Sri Lanka and Ghana, where debt servicing now competes directly with spending on health and education.

Aid is the third, and the shortfall is measurable rather than rhetorical. The target of 0.7 per cent of national income, set in 1970, is met by a handful of donors, and the committee average was about 0.37 per cent in 2023. The published figure also overstates delivery, because it includes the cost of housing refugees inside the donor economy and aid tied to purchases from the donor.

Technology is the fourth. Adoption requires electricity, networks and schooling, so diffusion is slowest where development is lowest; about a third of the world was still not using the internet in 2022, almost all of them in developing economies, and intellectual property rules raise the price of access.

These factors explain why development is expensive for every developing economy. They do not by themselves explain the differences between them, since economies facing the same global conditions have diverged, which is why domestic institutions and accumulation complete the account.

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 20 min

10 marks

Analyse the extent to which global factors, rather than domestic factors, account for differences in economic development between economies. Use recent evidence in your answer.

Hint 1The question asks for an extent, so the answer is a ranking with reasons, not a survey.

Hint 2Take the global factors in channels: trade access, finance and debt, aid, technology.

Hint 3The pandemic and the rise in world interest rates since 2022 give you a test of the argument rather than an illustration of it.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Answering with two lists and no extent

    Why it happens: The material is learned as global factors and domestic factors.

    The question asks how far one set accounts for the differences. Decide, argue it, and use the other set to show what the first cannot explain.

  • Using evidence that stops before 2020

    Why it happens: The standard examples in most notes were written earlier.

    The pandemic, the interest rate rise from 2022 and the resulting debt distress are the strongest available evidence and are directly on this question.

Written for this site.