HSC Study

The Effects of Globalisation

What integration into the world economy does to growth, to living standards, to unemployment, to inflation and to external stability, separating the transition from the permanent change and the winners from the losers.

75 min · HSC Topic One - The Global Economy

Assumes you have read Reasons for Differences Between Nations.

The full teaching. Start here.

Transition effect

The change that occurs while resources move between industries after an economy opens, and which fades once the reallocation is complete. Usually the largest number in the series and always temporary.

Permanent effect

The change in the level of an objective that remains once the adjustment is finished. Usually much smaller than the transition and the part that decides whether opening was worth it.

The five things worth carrying out of this lesson:

  • Separate the transition from the permanent change on every objective. Most weak responses give one and call it the effect. The marks are in giving both and saying which one the question is about.
  • Growth rose and converged, unevenly. World growth was faster in the two decades before the pandemic than in the two before that, and the fastest growth was in the economies that integrated hardest, which is why East Asia closed a gap that had been open for a century.
  • Unemployment moves before it settles. Import competing industries shed workers years before exporting industries absorb them, and the workers are rarely the same people in the same region, so the cost is structural, concentrated and politically decisive.
  • Inflation fell and then became someone else's decision. Cheaper imports and stronger competition lowered inflation for two decades, and the same openness is why a supply shock abroad arrives here as inflation, which is what happened from 2021.
  • Every effect is a distribution as well as an average. Globalisation raised world output, lowered extreme poverty and widened inequality inside most economies at the same time, and all three statements are true together.

The shape of the effect on each objective

An effect with a sign but no timing is half an answer. The figure traces each objective after an economy opens, against the level it would have held had it stayed closed.

What opening an economy does to each objectiveEconomic growth peaks at 4.6 per cent in year 0 and settles at 2.9 per cent after twenty years, against 2.5 per cent for an economy that stayed closed.The transition gainThe permanent change051015200123456Years after openingEconomic growth (% a year)
  • If the economy stayed closed
  • After opening
The shape is the argument. Every objective has a transition that fades and a permanent change in the level, and the two are often opposite in sign, which is why a response that gives only the transition sounds like an argument against globalisation and one that gives only the permanent change sounds like an advertisement for it. The retraining slider matters because it changes the unemployment path and nothing else, which is precisely the case for adjustment policy rather than for protection.
The numbers behind this graph
Years after openingEconomic growthIf the economy stayed closed
04.62.5
33.92.5
53.62.5
103.12.5
153.02.5
202.92.5
1
70 %
30 %
Economic growth at the peak of the adjustment
4.6 per cent in year 0, against 2.5 per cent if the economy had stayed closed
After twenty years
2.9 per cent, which is 0.4 of a percentage point above the closed economy level, and an improvement on this objective
Growth
Rises sharply while resources move to industries with a comparative advantage and foreign capital arrives, then settles at a level only modestly above the closed economy, because the large gain is a one off reallocation rather than a permanently faster rate.
Unemployment
Rises first and falls later. Import competing industries shed workers before the exporting industries absorb them, and the workers are rarely the same people in the same place, so the cost is structural and regional. Retraining does not remove it; it shortens it.
Inflation
Falls through cheaper imports and stronger competitive pressure on domestic firms, then becomes more exposed to shocks from abroad. An open economy imports world prices for energy and freight, which is how a supply shock elsewhere becomes inflation here.
External stability
The current account deficit widens first, because investment rises above domestic saving and the extra investment is funded by foreign capital, then narrows as the export capacity that investment built comes on line. A deficit that funds investment is on different terms from one that funds consumption.
Read it as
A model of the standard adjustment path, not data and not a forecast. The shapes are the examinable point; the numbers on the axis are illustrative.

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Move the objective slider through all four positions with the openness slider high, and the same shape appears each time in a different form: a transition that is large and temporary, then a permanent change that is small and lasting, and the two usually have opposite signs.

Growth rises sharply while resources reallocate towards industries with a comparative advantage and while foreign capital arrives, then settles only modestly above the closed economy level. This matters for the essay, because the large number belongs to a one off reallocation rather than to a permanently faster growth rate, and a response that promises permanent acceleration is claiming more than the theory does.

The third slider only touches the unemployment path. That is the case for adjustment policy stated as a mechanism: retraining and mobility support shorten and shallow the transition cost without giving up the permanent gain, which protection cannot do because protection removes the gain along with the cost.

Common mistake

Why it happens:

Quoting the transition as though it were the permanent effect. Both directions of this error are common. Naming the job losses in a displaced industry and concluding that globalisation raises unemployment ignores the later absorption; naming the growth surge of an opening decade and projecting it forward ignores that the surge is a reallocation. Say which part of the path the evidence belongs to.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A response argues that globalisation permanently raises an economy's rate of economic growth, citing the growth surge in the decade after an economy opens. What is the strongest objection?

Select one answer

Hint 1Ask whether the cause of the surge can repeat every year.

Hint 2Moving resources into their most productive use is something an economy does once.

Hint 3Separate a change in the level of output from a change in its rate of growth.

Growth, convergence and the quality of life

The growth record is the strongest evidence in favour of globalisation, and it needs to be stated precisely rather than enthusiastically.

The international business cycle: world output growthIn 2020 world output grew by -2.9 per cent, with the advanced economies at -4.2 per cent and the emerging and developing economies at -1.8 per cent. Trough.Trend, about 3.5%Global financial crisisCOVID-19200020052010201520202025-6-30369YearReal GDP growth (% a year)
  • Emerging and developing economies
  • Advanced economies
  • World
The international business cycle is the movement of world output around this trend, not the trend itself. Two features do most of the work in an answer: the two troughs, 2009 and 2020, are the only years growth falls near or below zero, and the emerging and developing economies sit above the advanced economies in every year of the series, which is why they now supply most of world growth.
The numbers behind this graph
YearWorldAdvancedEmerging and developing
20004.94.16.0
20012.51.53.8
20023.11.84.7
20034.32.16.6
20045.53.38.0
20054.92.97.4
20065.63.28.3
20075.62.78.6
20083.10.35.9
2009-0.1-3.42.8
20105.53.27.4
20114.41.86.4
20123.61.35.4
20133.51.45.1
20143.62.14.7
20153.42.44.3
20163.31.84.5
20173.82.54.8
20183.62.34.6
20192.81.83.6
2020-2.9-4.2-1.8
20216.65.67.0
20223.62.94.1
20233.51.94.4
20243.31.84.3
20253.21.64.2
2020
World growth in 2020
-2.9 per cent
Advanced economies
-4.2 per cent
Emerging and developing economies
-1.8 per cent
Phase of the cycle
Trough: a world recession, where output itself falls
What was happening
The COVID-19 pandemic. Borders close, supply chains break and the world economy enters its deepest recession since the 1930s.
Gap between the two groups
2.4 percentage points, emerging economies above advanced
Source
International Monetary Fund, World Economic Outlook database, October 2025 release

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

World growth averaged more in the two decades before the pandemic than in the two decades before that, and the composition of that growth changed: the fastest growing economies were those that opened to trade and foreign investment, which produced convergence between the emerging economies and the advanced ones for the first sustained period on record. Advanced economy growth was slower over the same period, and slower still after the global financial crisis.

Extreme poverty: the world and three regionsIn 2020, 10 per cent of the world lived in extreme poverty, against 38 per cent in 1990, with sub-Saharan Africa at 36 per cent.The pandemic reverses the trend19901995200020052010201520200204060YearExtreme poverty rate (% of population)
  • Sub-Saharan Africa
  • South Asia
  • East Asia and the Pacific
  • World
The world line falls by about three quarters over the series, which is the strongest single piece of evidence that globalisation raised living standards. The regional lines are what make it an argument rather than a slogan: East Asia and South Asia account for almost all of the fall, sub-Saharan Africa falls far less, and the world line turns up in 2020 for the first time in a generation.
The numbers behind this graph
YearWorldEast Asia and PacificSouth AsiaSub-Saharan Africa
199038665055
200029484055
201016142845
20151141640
201991935
20201021236
202291935
2020
World in 2020
10 per cent, against 38 per cent in 1990
East Asia and the Pacific
2 per cent, from 66 per cent in 1990
South Asia
12 per cent, from 50 per cent in 1990
Sub-Saharan Africa
36 per cent, from 55 per cent in 1990
Change in the world rate
Down 28 percentage points since 1990, with the fall concentrated in Asia
Which line to quote
These figures use the line of 2.15 United States dollars a day in 2017 prices. In 2025 the World Bank moved its headline line to 3.00 dollars a day in 2021 prices, which raises the measured rate by about a percentage and a half with no change in anyone’s living standard. Name the line beside the figure.
Source
World Bank, Poverty and Inequality Platform, 2025 update

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Living standards are where the case is made. The share of the world in extreme poverty fell by roughly three quarters between 1990 and 2019, human development improved in almost every economy, and the improvement was largest where integration was deepest. The exceptions are informative rather than awkward: development fell in economies that went through a disorderly transition from central planning and in economies in conflict, which is the domestic institutional factor from the previous lesson reappearing.

What lifts this to a Band 6

Write growth and development as separate effects with separate evidence. Growth is the output number; development is the poverty rate, the Human Development Index and what happened to health and schooling. The quality of life clause in the syllabus is asking for the second, and a response that answers it with growth statistics alone has covered half the question.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

An emerging economy has income per person of US$4000, growing at 6 per cent a year. Calculate the number of years it takes for income per person to reach US$8000, using the rule of 70. Give your answer correct to one decimal place.

Hint 1Reaching US$8000 from US$4000 is a doubling.

Hint 2The rule of 70 estimates a doubling time as 70 divided by the annual growth rate in per cent.

Hint 3Divide 70 by 6.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Over the decades of rapid globalisation, income gaps between economies narrowed while income inequality widened inside most economies. Which statement best explains how both can be true at once?

Select one answer

Hint 1Ask which workers in which economies gained and which lost.

Hint 2The same relocation of production appears as a gain in one place and a loss in another.

Hint 3Between country and within country inequality are separate measures.

Unemployment: where the losses actually fall

This is the effect that decides elections, so it is worth being precise about the mechanism.

Chain of reasoning

How opening produces structural unemployment before it produces jobs

  1. Domestic buyers can now purchase from the cheapest world supplier, so the domestic import competing industry loses sales at its existing price.

  2. Firms that cannot match the world price close or shrink. The job losses are immediate, concentrated in particular regions and concentrated in particular skills.

  3. Export industries grow because resources are cheaper and foreign markets are open, but investment and capacity take years, and the new jobs appear in different places and often require different skills.

  4. A displaced textile worker in one region is not a mining or services worker in another. The mismatch of skill and location is why the transition shows up as unemployment rather than as a smooth transfer.

  5. Retraining, income support during the transition and assistance with mobility shorten the gap. Protection closes it by removing the gain as well, which is why the standard conclusion is to compensate the worker rather than to protect the industry.

Two further labour market effects belong in a full answer. The international division of labour moves the location of production to where each stage is cheapest, which raises employment in the receiving economy and lowers it in the sending one. And the mobility of skilled labour draws qualified workers to the economies that pay most, which raises their own incomes and removes exactly the skills a developing economy needs, a loss usually described as a brain drain and partly offset by the remittances those workers send home.

Common mistake

Why it happens:

Treating the job losses as evidence that trade destroys jobs overall. Trade changes the composition of employment rather than its total, which is set by the growth of the economy and the operation of the labour market. The defensible statement is that the losses are concentrated and immediate while the gains are dispersed and slower, which is why the politics runs ahead of the economics.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Explain why the effect of globalisation on unemployment differs in the short term and the long term.

Hint 1Two industries move in opposite directions and not at the same speed.

Hint 2Ask whether the workers who lose jobs are the workers the expanding industries need.

Hint 3Name the type of unemployment the mismatch produces.

Inflation and external stability

Inflation. Two effects, in opposite directions and in that order. For roughly two decades, access to lower cost production abroad and stronger competitive pressure on domestic firms held traded goods prices down, which is a substantial part of why inflation across the advanced economies stayed low through the 1990s and 2000s. The same openness then means an open economy imports world prices: the supply disruptions of the pandemic, followed by the energy and food price rises after the invasion of Ukraine in 2022, produced the fastest inflation in four decades in economies whose domestic conditions had not changed nearly that much. Openness lowered the average rate of inflation and raised its exposure to shocks from elsewhere.

External stability. Opening the capital account allows investment to exceed domestic saving, so the current account deficit widens first, and that is the intended effect rather than a failure: the deficit is financing capital that the economy could not have funded from its own saving. The deficit narrows later as the export capacity that investment built comes on line. The risks are on the financing side rather than the deficit itself, since short term capital can reverse quickly, a depreciation raises the burden of debt denominated in foreign currency, and a foreign owned capital stock sends income payments abroad in perpetuity, which is why Australia's net primary income deficit is persistent.

What lifts this to a Band 6

The distinguishing sentence on external stability is about what the borrowing funds. A current account deficit that finances investment adds to the economy's future capacity to service it, and one that finances consumption does not. Say which, and the difference between a sustainable deficit and an unsustainable one has been explained rather than asserted.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Analyse the effect of increased globalisation on the external stability of an economy.

Hint 1Start with what opening the capital account does to the relationship between saving and investment.

Hint 2Ask what the borrowing is funding, and whether that changes the answer.

Hint 3The risks sit in how the deficit is financed rather than in its size.

The distribution of the effects, which is the live argument

Three statements that are all true at once, and holding them together is what separates the top responses:

  • World output grew faster in the globalisation era than before it.
  • Extreme poverty fell by roughly three quarters, and the gap between economies narrowed.
  • Inequality widened inside most economies over the same period.

The mechanism behind the third is the same one behind the second. Production moved to where labour was cheapest, which raised incomes there and removed the jobs that had supported middle incomes in the advanced economies. Foreign investment concentrated in higher skill sectors, which rewarded the workers who already earned most, and technology did the same thing independently, which is why the share of the widening that can be attributed to trade rather than to technology is contested.

GroupWhat happened to themWhy
Workers in emerging economy export industriesLarge gains in real incomeNew access to world demand and to foreign capital
Owners of capital and high skill workers everywhereLarge gainsReturns concentrated where investment and technology went
Middle income workers in advanced economiesWeak or no growth in real incomeImport competition and the relocation of production
The very poorest economiesSmallest gainsLittle foreign investment, narrow export base, weak institutions

The political consequence follows from the table rather than from opinion. The group whose incomes stagnated votes in the economies that write the trade rules, which is why protection returned to the policy agenda from 2018 and why the disciplines that were meant to prevent it have weakened.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Explain why globalisation has reduced extreme poverty while increasing income inequality within many economies.

Hint 1Both outcomes come from the same relocation of production.

Hint 2Identify which groups gained and which did not.

Hint 3Technology moved in the same direction over the same period.

The slowdown in integration. World trade grew faster than world output for three decades and has not clearly done so since the mid 2010s. Tariff escalation from 2018, the supply disruptions of the pandemic, the subsidy programmes introduced in the United States, the European Union and Japan from 2022, and the relocation of production for security rather than cost reasons all point the same way. Whether this is a reversal of globalisation or a reorganisation of it is genuinely open; the defensible position in an essay is that the volume of trade has held up while its direction has been redrawn along political lines.

What the pandemic revealed about integration. The shock reached every economy through the same channels that had delivered the gains: supply chains transmitted it, so did tourism and migration, and the economies with the most exposure to global demand fell furthest in 2020. The recovery then ran the other way, with the economies that could finance support recovering fastest. Integration raised the average and raised the variance, and the syllabus objective this belongs to is external stability as much as growth.

Inflation as the clearest test case. From 2021 to 2023 inflation rose sharply in almost every advanced economy at once, and the common component was in traded goods, energy and freight rather than in domestic wage pressure. This is the strongest available evidence that an open economy imports price shocks, and it is recent enough that most published notes do not use it.

A caution about attribution. Everything in this lesson happened alongside technological change, and the two are hard to separate, since the same container shipping and communications that made offshoring possible also automated the jobs that offshoring did not take. Where the evidence is contested, the strongest responses say which part is contested and continue, rather than asserting a single figure for how much of the change globalisation caused.

Where the essay plan for this material lives. Essay priority 12, on the impact of globalisation on growth and development, is planned in the international and regional business cycles lesson, and it takes the effects material from here as its evidence base. Work through this lesson first and that plan second.

Worked example4 marks

Using the adjustment path to answer a four mark effects question

Explain the effect of increased globalisation on unemployment in an economy that opens to trade.

Name both parts of the effect before describing either

A four mark explain question on an effect that changes sign is marked on whether both parts appear.

Opening changes the composition of employment, raising unemployment during the transition and lowering it once the reallocation is complete.

Give the mechanism for the transition

The mark is for the mismatch, not for the job losses.

Import competing industries lose sales to cheaper world suppliers and contract immediately. Exporting industries expand, but investment and capacity take years, and the new jobs require different skills in different regions. The mismatch of skill and location is structural unemployment.

Give the mechanism for the permanent position

Without this the answer has argued that trade destroys jobs, which is not the examined position.

Once resources have moved, output per worker is higher in the industries that remain and the economy is producing what it produces most efficiently, so employment recovers and real wages in the expanding industries rise.

Name the policy that separates the two

It shows the cost is a policy problem rather than an argument against trade.

Retraining, income support and assistance with mobility shorten the transition without giving up the permanent gain. Protection removes both.

Answer

Opening an economy to trade changes the composition of employment rather than its level, but the change is not simultaneous, so it appears first as unemployment. Import competing industries lose sales to cheaper world suppliers and shed workers immediately, while the exporting industries that will absorb those workers expand only as investment builds capacity, and they do so in different regions and with different skill requirements. That mismatch is structural unemployment, and it is concentrated in the regions where the protected industry was, which is why the cost is felt more sharply than the dispersed gain from lower prices. Once the reallocation is complete, employment recovers and output per worker is higher, because resources are in the industries where the economy has a comparative advantage. The size and length of the transition depend on policy: retraining, income support and mobility assistance shorten it while keeping the permanent gain, whereas protection avoids the cost by giving up the gain as well.

Is that answer sensible?

Four marks requires both directions, one mechanism for each, and the policy point. A response that names only the job losses caps at two, however well it describes them.

Exam question

Harder · about 11 min

6 marks

Examine the impact of globalisation on economic growth and the quality of life in the global economy.

Hint 1Growth and quality of life need separate evidence, not the same statistic twice.

Hint 2Give the transition and the permanent change on growth.

Hint 3The exceptions are as informative as the average: say which economies gained least and why.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Answering the quality of life half with growth statistics

    Why it happens: Growth data is more familiar and appears to cover living standards.

    Quality of life is measured by poverty rates, life expectancy, schooling and human development. Quote at least one measure that is not an output figure.

  • Reaching a verdict without naming the economies that gained least

    Why it happens: The aggregate story is clear and the exceptions look like distractions.

    Examine asks for the case on both sides. The least developed economies are the evidence that openness on its own is not sufficient, and they carry the qualification mark.

Written for this site.

Through a marker’s eyes

6 marks

Analyse the effects of globalisation on inflation and external stability.

The attempt

3 out of 6

Globalisation has reduced inflation because countries can import cheap goods from countries with lower production costs, especially China. This means domestic firms have to keep their prices low to compete. However, during COVID-19 inflation increased a lot because supply chains were disrupted, and the war in Ukraine also increased prices of energy. Globalisation also affects external stability because countries can borrow from overseas, which increases the current account deficit. This means the country has to pay interest to foreign lenders, which is a problem for external stability. Overall globalisation has had mixed effects on inflation and external stability.

What the marker sees

Three marks. Both objectives are addressed and the inflation half is largely right, including the reversal after 2021, which is the recent evidence a marker is looking for. The external stability half does not analyse. It states that borrowing raises the deficit without distinguishing what the borrowing funds, does not mention that the deficit narrows as the investment produces exports, and treats the servicing obligation as a problem rather than asking whether the capacity to service it rose with it. The word mixed in the last sentence stands in for a judgement rather than making one. Analyse asks for the relationship between the parts, so the response needs to connect the same openness to both the lower average inflation and the greater exposure to shocks, and to connect the deficit to the investment that caused it.

The same answer, fixed

6 out of 6

Globalisation affects both objectives through the same mechanism, which is that domestic prices and domestic funding are now set in world markets rather than at home.

On inflation, openness produced two effects in sequence. For roughly two decades, access to lower cost production abroad and the competitive pressure of imports held traded goods prices down, which is a substantial part of why inflation across the advanced economies remained low and stable through the 1990s and 2000s despite sustained growth. The same openness then transmits foreign supply shocks directly: the disruption to supply chains through the pandemic and the energy and food price rises after 2022 produced the fastest inflation in four decades across economies whose domestic labour market conditions had changed far less. The net effect is a lower average rate of inflation and a higher variance, which is not the same claim as saying globalisation is inflationary or disinflationary.

On external stability, opening the capital account allows investment to exceed domestic saving, so the current account deficit widens. That is the intended result rather than a failure, because the deficit is financing capital the economy could not have funded from its own saving, and it narrows as the export capacity built by that investment comes on line. The relevant distinction is what the borrowing funds: a deficit financing investment raises the future capacity to service it, while one financing consumption does not.

The risks sit on the financing side. Short term capital can reverse quickly, which is what turned current account deficits into crises in East Asia in 1997; a depreciation raises the real burden of debt denominated in foreign currency, which is the valuation effect; and a foreign owned capital stock sends income payments abroad permanently, which is why Australia runs a persistent net primary income deficit even when trade is in surplus.

The two objectives are connected. The same integration that lowered average inflation also made both the price level and the financing of investment depend on decisions taken elsewhere, so globalisation improved the average performance on each objective while reducing the domestic control over either.

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 20 min

10 marks

Evaluate the effects of globalisation on economic growth, unemployment, inflation and external stability in the global economy.

Hint 1Four objectives, four sections, each with a transition effect and a permanent effect.

Hint 2Evaluate requires a judgement on each objective, not a summary at the end.

Hint 3Recent evidence from 2020 onwards is available on every one of the four.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Writing a list of advantages followed by a list of disadvantages

    Why it happens: It is the structure most naturally suggested by the word evaluate.

    Structure by objective, and make the judgement inside each section. A balanced list with a verdict bolted on the end reads as undecided.

  • Using only pre-pandemic evidence

    Why it happens: Textbook and note material largely stops before 2020.

    Every one of the four objectives has strong recent evidence: the 2020 contraction, the inflation of 2021 to 2023, the tariff escalation from 2018 and the subsidy programmes from 2022. Recent evidence is the cheapest available mark in this question.

  • Treating globalisation as a policy that can be adopted or reversed at will

    Why it happens: It is discussed in the same sentences as trade policy.

    Distinguish the process, driven by technology and cost, from the policy settings that permit or restrict it. Recent policy has redirected trade more than it has reduced it.

Written for this site.