HSC Study

The Basis of Free Trade

Why economies trade at all, how comparative advantage answers it, what opening one market actually does to consumers and producers, and where the case for free trade runs out.

70 min · HSC Topic One - The Global Economy

Assumes you have read International Division of Labour and Migration.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

Economies trade because they are different: different resources, different climates, different capital stocks, different skills. Trade lets each concentrate on what it gives up least to produce.

Absolute advantage is being able to produce more of a good with the same resources. Comparative advantage is being able to produce a good at a lower opportunity cost. Only the second one matters, because an economy that is worse at making everything still gives up less to make some things than others, so it still has something to sell.

Trade is worth doing for both sides whenever the terms of trade, the rate at which one good exchanges for the other, sit between the two economies' opportunity costs.

In one market, opening to trade moves the domestic price to the world price. Someone always loses: consumers if the price rises, domestic producers if it falls. The net gain is real but it is smaller than either the gain or the loss it nets out, which is why the losers are visible and organised and the winners are not.

The advantages of free trade are efficiency, lower prices, wider choice, economies of scale, technology transfer and faster growth. The disadvantages are structural unemployment while industries adjust, greater exposure to the international business cycle, the loss of industries an economy might want for strategic reasons, and environmental costs that no trade price includes.

Why economies trade at all

AnswersWhy do countries trade rather than produce everything themselves?

Free trade

International trade that takes place without any government restriction on the movement of goods and services across borders: no tariffs, no subsidies to domestic producers, no quotas, no local content rules.

An economy trades because producing a good at home has a cost measured in the other goods it could have produced instead. Five differences between economies make that cost differ.

Natural resources. Australia has iron ore, coal, gas, arable land and sunlight. Japan has almost none of these and buys them.

Climate and geography. Some goods can only be grown in some places, and distance to a market is itself a cost.

Capital stock. An economy with more machinery per worker produces more per worker, so it makes capital intensive goods cheaply.

Skills and technology. A skilled workforce and an established technology base give an economy an advantage in goods that need them, and that advantage can be built rather than inherited.

Scale. A firm serving the world market can spread its fixed costs over far more units than one serving a domestic market, so it can produce at a lower average cost.

Only the first two are given. The last three are made, which matters for the development lessons, because an economy that cannot change its resources can change its capital, its skills and the scale it produces at.

Common mistake

Australia trades because it cannot produce manufactured goods.

Why it happens: The pattern of trade looks like a list of things the country can and cannot do.

Australia can produce almost anything. It chooses not to produce most of it, because the resources used would earn more in mining, agriculture, construction and services. That is a statement about opportunity cost, not about capability, and getting it the right way round is the difference between describing trade and explaining it.

Absolute and comparative advantage

AnswersWhat is the difference between absolute and comparative advantage?

Absolute advantage

The ability to produce more of a good than another economy using the same quantity of resources.

Comparative advantage

The ability to produce a good at a lower opportunity cost than another economy, where the opportunity cost is the quantity of the other good given up to produce it.

The whole of the theory is in one observation: an economy that is better at producing everything is not better at producing everything by the same margin, and the margin is what decides what it should make.

Comparative advantage and the gains from tradeEconomy A gives up 0.50 rolls of cloth for a tonne of wheat and Economy B gives up 2.00, so A has the comparative advantage in wheat.A specialises hereB specialises here0100200300400500600050100150200250300350400Wheat (t)Cloth (rolls)
  • Economy A, what it can produce
  • Economy B, what it can produce
  • Economy A, what it can consume with trade
  • Economy B, what it can consume with trade
Absolute advantage is about who produces more. Comparative advantage is about who gives up less, which is the slope of the line rather than its position. Trade raises consumption in both economies whenever the terms of trade lie between the two opportunity costs, and the readout says when they do not.
6.0 t
3.0 rolls
2.0 t
4.0 rolls
0.75 rolls per t
Absolute advantage
Economy A produces more wheat and Economy B produces more cloth.
Opportunity cost of a tonne of wheat in A
0.50 rolls of cloth given up
Opportunity cost of a tonne of wheat in B
2.00 rolls of cloth given up
Comparative advantage
Economy A in wheat, because it gives up less cloth to grow it. Economy B therefore has it in cloth.
Terms of trade that work
Between 0.50 and 2.00 rolls of cloth for a tonne of wheat. Outside that range one economy does better making the good itself, so it will not trade.
At the terms you have set
Both gain. Economy A ends up with about 150 more rolls of cloth and Economy B about 333 more tonnes of wheat than either could produce alone.
What the model leaves out
Transport costs, adjustment costs for the workers who move industry, economies of scale, and everything a country might want from an industry other than output. Those are where the disadvantages of free trade live.

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Start with the initial settings. Economy A makes more wheat per worker and Economy B makes more cloth, so the comparative advantage and the absolute advantage point the same way and nothing is surprising. Now raise B's wheat and cloth figures until B produces more of both. The lines cross differently but the slopes do not change, so the comparative advantage stays exactly where it was. That is the point of the model: the slope, not the position.

Worked example6 marks

Finding the comparative advantage and the range of useful terms of trade

With one hundred workers each, Economy A can produce 600 tonnes of wheat or 300 rolls of cloth. Economy B can produce 200 tonnes of wheat or 400 rolls of cloth.

Determine which economy has the comparative advantage in each good, and the range of terms of trade at which both would agree to trade.

Find each economy's opportunity cost of one good in terms of the other

For Economy A, giving up all 300 rolls of cloth buys 600 tonnes of wheat, so one tonne of wheat costs rolls of cloth.

For Economy B, giving up all 400 rolls buys 200 tonnes, so one tonne of wheat costs rolls of cloth.

The lower opportunity cost is the comparative advantage

Economy A gives up 0.5 rolls for a tonne of wheat and Economy B gives up 2 rolls, so A has the comparative advantage in wheat.

The other good follows automatically, and it is worth doing the reciprocal rather than assuming it. In A, one roll of cloth costs tonnes of wheat. In B, one roll costs tonnes. So B has the comparative advantage in cloth.

Set the range of terms of trade

A will not sell a tonne of wheat for less than 0.5 rolls of cloth, because it can make 0.5 rolls itself by not growing the wheat. B will not pay more than 2 rolls, because above that it is cheaper to grow the wheat itself.

So the terms of trade must lie between 0.5 and 2 rolls of cloth per tonne of wheat.

Answer

Economy A has the comparative advantage in wheat, Economy B in cloth, and both gain at any terms of trade strictly between 0.5 and 2 rolls of cloth per tonne of wheat. The closer the terms sit to 2, the larger A's share of the gain, and the closer to 0.5, the larger B's.

Is that answer sensible?

Test the endpoints. At exactly 0.5 rolls per tonne A is indifferent, since trading gives it precisely what producing at home would. At exactly 2, B is indifferent. Terms outside the range make one economy worse off than producing at home, so it refuses. A range that came out backwards, with the lower bound above the upper, means the two opportunity costs were divided the wrong way up.

Two phrasings that lose marks

First, "Economy A has a comparative advantage in wheat because it produces more wheat." That is absolute advantage with the wrong label, and examiners are looking for exactly this sentence. The reason must be the opportunity cost.

Second, using the terms of trade in the syllabus sense without saying so. In this theory the terms of trade means the exchange rate between two goods. In Topic 2 and Topic 3 it means Australia's export price index over its import price index. Both are examinable, they are related, and writing the wrong one in the wrong question is a common way to lose an otherwise sound paragraph.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

With the same resources, Vietnam can produce 900 tonnes of rice or 300 units of clothing. Thailand can produce 800 tonnes of rice or 400 units of clothing.

Calculate Vietnam's opportunity cost of producing one tonne of rice, measured in units of clothing.

Hint 1Opportunity cost of rice means clothing given up, so divide the clothing total by the rice total.

Hint 2Vietnam gives up all 300 units of clothing to produce all 900 tonnes of rice.

Hint 3300 divided by 900.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student writes: "Germany can produce more cars and more wine than Portugal with the same resources, so there is no reason for the two countries to trade."

What is wrong with this reasoning?

Select one answer

Hint 1The claim is about absolute advantage. Which kind of advantage determines the pattern of trade?

Hint 2Ask what Germany gives up to make a bottle of wine, and what Portugal gives up.

Hint 3Being better at both does not mean being better at both by the same margin.

What opening one market actually does

AnswersWho gains and who loses when a market is opened to trade?

The two economy model shows that trade creates something. This model shows who gets it, which is what an evaluate question is really asking about.

What opening one market to trade doesA world price of $6.00 against a domestic price of $11.00, so the economy imports 40 units and gains about 100 in welfare.Price with no tradeWorld priceImports 4001020304050607005101520Quantity (units)Price ($)
  • Domestic demand
  • Domestic supply
  • Net gain from trade
  • Imports
The triangle is the whole argument for free trade in one market: the gain to the side that wins is larger than the loss to the side that loses, so the economy as a whole gains. It is also the whole argument about who should be compensated, because the winners and the losers are different people and the triangle does not move income between them.
6.0 $
20 $ choke price
2.0 $
Price with no trade
$11.00, where domestic demand meets domestic supply
What opening the market does
The world price of $6.00 is below the domestic price, so buyers import. Domestic production falls to 16 units and consumption rises to 56.
Consumers
Gain about 230 in surplus: they pay less and buy more.
Producers
Lose about 130 in surplus: they sell less at a lower price, and the workers in the industry are the ones who bear it.
Net gain to the economy
About 100, the shaded triangle. It is a gain in efficiency, not a transfer.
Why the gain is not the end of the argument
The triangle is smaller than either the gain or the loss it nets out, so a large group can be made worse off while the economy gains. Structural adjustment assistance and retraining exist to deal with that, and an evaluate question needs both halves.

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Read the import case first, with the world price below the domestic price. Consumers pay less and buy more, so they gain. Domestic producers sell less at a lower price, so they lose, and the loss is concentrated on the workers and firms in that industry. The shaded triangle is what is left after the gain and the loss cancel, and it is positive, which is the entire economic case for free trade in one market.

Then push the world price above the domestic price. The roles swap. Producers gain, consumers pay more, and the triangle is positive again, which is why an exporting economy gains from trade as well as an importing one.

Chain of reasoning

Why free trade raises output

  1. Specialisation rises

    Each economy shifts resources into what it gives up least to produce, so the same resources produce more in total.

  2. Competition rises

    Domestic firms face world competitors, which forces down costs and prices and removes the protection that lets an inefficient firm survive.

  3. Economies of scale rises

    Producing for a world market spreads fixed costs over more units, which lowers average cost further than specialisation alone.

  4. Technology transfer rises

    Imported capital goods and the firms that invest alongside trade carry technology and management practice into the economy.

  5. Living standards rises

    Lower prices raise real income, and wider choice raises it again in a way the price index does not fully capture.

Where it breaks: Every link assumes resources released from one industry are re-employed in another. Where they are not, the gain is smaller than the theory says and the adjustment cost is real.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

An economy opens a market to trade. The world price of the good is below the price that prevailed domestically.

Using a demand and supply diagram, explain the effect on domestic consumers, domestic producers and total welfare. (4 marks)

Hint 1Draw the domestic demand and supply curves, mark the domestic equilibrium, then draw the world price as a horizontal line below it.

Hint 2Read the two quantities off the world price line: what domestic producers supply, and what domestic consumers buy. The gap is imports.

Hint 3The net welfare gain is the triangle between the two curves and the world price line. Say why it is smaller than the consumer gain.

The advantages and the disadvantages

AnswersWhat are the advantages and disadvantages of free trade?

AdvantageThe mechanismThe disadvantage that sits beside it
Efficiency in resource allocationResources move to their highest valued use, so the same inputs produce more.The movement is not costless. Workers in the contracting industry face structural unemployment, and the skills they have may not transfer.
Lower prices and wider choiceImport competition puts a ceiling on domestic prices, and consumers reach goods no domestic firm makes.Domestic producers who cannot match world costs close, and in a region built around one industry the closure takes the town with it.
Economies of scaleA world market lets firms produce at a scale a domestic market could never support.Scale concentrates production, so an economy can end up dependent on a small number of suppliers or a single export market.
Technology transfer and productivity growthTrade carries capital goods, ideas and management practice across borders.The transfer runs mainly towards economies that already have the skills to absorb it, which widens the gap rather than closing it.
Faster economic growth and higher living standardsMore output per unit of input, compounding over decades.Growth measured as output ignores environmental costs no price includes, and ignores who receives the growth.
Export income and foreign exchangeExport earnings finance imports and reduce reliance on foreign borrowing.Greater exposure to the international business cycle, since export income now depends on foreign demand the economy does not control.
Structural unemployment

Unemployment that arises because the skills, location or experience of workers no longer match the jobs the economy has, typically after an industry contracts. It is the main cost of trade liberalisation and it falls on a specific group of people rather than on the economy in general.

This is where the two halves of the dot point meet. The welfare triangle is positive, so the economy gains, but the triangle is smaller than either the gain to the winners or the loss to the losers. Nothing in the theory moves income from one to the other. That is why trade liberalisation is almost always accompanied by structural adjustment assistance, retraining and regional programs, and why a response that says free trade makes everyone better off has misread the diagram it just drew.

Common mistake

Free trade benefits everyone in the economy.

Why it happens: The net gain is positive, so it sounds as though there is nothing on the other side.

Free trade benefits the economy in aggregate and harms an identifiable group within it. Say both. The gain is diffuse, a few dollars to every consumer, and the loss is concentrated, a livelihood to each worker in the industry, which is also the political economy reason protection is so hard to remove.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Which is the most significant economic cost of trade liberalisation for an economy that removes protection from a long established manufacturing industry?

Select one answer

Hint 1The cost has to be economic and specific to liberalisation, not a general complaint about trade.

Hint 2Think about the resources released by the industry that contracts, and whether they are immediately re-employed.

Hint 3The theory assumes resources move between industries costlessly. What is the cost when they do not?

What the theory assumes, and what happens when the assumptions fail

The model has four assumptions, and each one is a live argument in trade policy.

Resources move between industries. The theory compares two end states and says nothing about the path between them. If a steelworker cannot become a software developer, the resources released by closing the steel mill are not re-employed and the gain never fully arrives. The gap between the theory and the outcome is exactly the adjustment cost, which is why the policy question is usually about the speed of liberalisation rather than its direction.

Costs are constant. Real production runs into diminishing returns, so complete specialisation is rarely optimal and the production possibility frontier is a curve rather than a line. The direction of the result survives; the extent of specialisation it recommends does not.

Prices reflect all costs. Where production damages an environment nobody is paying for, the world price is below the true cost and trade moves production towards the economy with the weakest environmental standards rather than the lowest real cost. This is the substance of the environmental management dot points in Topic 3.

Technology is fixed. It is not, and this is the strongest argument against taking comparative advantage as a permanent instruction. An economy that specialises in what it is currently good at may lock itself into low value activities, while an economy that protects an industry temporarily can acquire the skills and the scale to become genuinely competitive. Korea's move from textiles to shipbuilding to semiconductors was not what its comparative advantage in the 1960s recommended. That is the infant industry argument, and the reason it does not justify protection everywhere is that the temporary protection is rarely temporary.

The terms of trade, in both of its meanings

In this lesson the terms of trade is the rate at which two goods exchange, a number with no units beyond goods per good. In Topics 2 and 3 it is an index, the ratio of export prices to import prices, and a rise means each unit of exports buys more imports than before.

The connection is that both measure the same thing: what an economy gets for what it gives up. For a commodity exporter the index moves with world commodity prices, so a rise in the terms of trade raises national income without any rise in the volume produced, which is why the terms of trade and the exchange rate move together in Australia and why both belong in an answer about the effect of the international business cycle.

Putting it together

Exam question

Hardest asked · about 15 min

8 marks

Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of free trade for an economy. (8 marks)

Hint 1Discuss wants both sides and a position. Decide the position first: free trade raises output, and whether it raises welfare depends on what the government does about the losers.

Hint 2Build each advantage as a mechanism rather than a label. Specialisation raises output because resources move to where they are given up least.

Hint 3Pair each advantage with the disadvantage that sits beside it, so the response reads as one argument rather than two lists.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Writing two lists, advantages then disadvantages, with no connection between them.

    Why it happens: The dot point is phrased as two lists, so the response copies the structure.

    Pair each advantage with the disadvantage that arises from the same mechanism. Specialisation raises output and displaces workers; both come from resources moving.

  • Ending with 'therefore free trade has both advantages and disadvantages'.

    Why it happens: Discuss is read as a requirement to present both sides and stop.

    Discuss still requires a position. Name the conditions under which the advantages dominate, which converts a summary into a judgement.

Written for this site.

Through a marker’s eyes

5 marks

Explain the basis of free trade between economies.

The attempt

2 out of 5

Free trade is trade without any restrictions like tariffs or quotas. Countries trade because they have different resources and cannot produce everything themselves. Australia has a lot of natural resources like iron ore and coal so it exports these, and it imports cars and electronics from Japan and China because they are better at producing these goods. This is called comparative advantage. Free trade makes both countries better off because they each produce what they are best at.

What the marker sees

Two marks: the definition is right and the direction of Australian trade is right. Everything after that is absolute advantage wearing the wrong name. "Better at producing" is the phrase the criteria are built to catch, because comparative advantage is about what is given up, not about what is produced. There is no opportunity cost anywhere in the response, no terms of trade, and no reason why specialisation produces more in total rather than simply producing differently.

The same answer, fixed

5 out of 5

Free trade is international trade with no government restrictions such as tariffs, quotas or subsidies. Economies trade because the opportunity cost of producing a good differs between them, and that difference is what makes exchange worth doing.

An economy has an absolute advantage in a good if it can produce more of it with the same resources, and a comparative advantage if it gives up less of other goods to produce it. Only the second determines the pattern of trade, because an economy that is less productive in every good still sacrifices less to produce some goods than others, so it still has something worth selling.

If Australia gives up 0.5 units of manufactured goods to produce a tonne of iron ore while Japan would give up 2, then Australia has the comparative advantage in ore and Japan in manufactures, even though Japan may be more productive in both. Each specialises where it gives up least, so the same total resources produce more output than the two economies produced separately.

Trade then occurs at terms of trade lying between the two opportunity costs, here between 0.5 and 2 units of manufactures per tonne. Within that range both economies consume beyond what they could produce alone, which is the basis of free trade. Outside it, one economy is better off producing the good itself and no trade occurs.

Exam question

Harder · about 7 min

4 marks

Country X can produce 400 units of steel or 200 units of textiles. Country Y can produce 300 units of steel or 300 units of textiles.

Determine the comparative advantage of each country and the range of terms of trade at which both would agree to trade. Explain what happens at terms of trade outside that range. (4 marks)

Hint 1Work out the opportunity cost of one unit of steel in each country first, then the reciprocal for textiles.

Hint 2The range of useful terms of trade runs between the two opportunity costs, because neither country accepts terms worse than producing at home.

Hint 3Outside the range, one country is better off making the good itself. Say which one and why.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Giving the range as a single number.

    Why it happens: The question looks like a calculation with one answer.

    The theory gives a range, not a price. Which point in the range is reached depends on bargaining power, market size and the elasticity of demand, none of which the theory determines.

  • Reporting the range in the wrong units, for example textiles per textile.

    Why it happens: The reciprocal step is done mechanically and the unit is not carried through.

    Write the unit into every line: units of textiles per unit of steel. If the two bounds do not share a unit, one of them was inverted.

Written for this site.

Exam question

Harder · about 9 min

5 marks

Explain why free trade can raise total welfare in an economy while making a large group of people worse off, and outline how governments respond to that. (5 marks)

Hint 1Start from the welfare triangle: it is a net figure, and a net figure hides two larger numbers.

Hint 2Describe the distribution: the gain is spread thinly over consumers, the loss is concentrated on one industry.

Hint 3The policy response has three parts: assistance to the people affected, the speed of the liberalisation, and support for the region rather than the firm.

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Concluding that because some people lose, free trade is not worth pursuing.

    Why it happens: The distributional argument is the more vivid one, so it displaces the aggregate one.

    The efficiency gain and the distributional cost are separate findings. The policy conclusion is to liberalise and compensate, not to choose between the two halves of the diagram.

  • Listing protection itself as the response to adjustment costs.

    Why it happens: Protection does prevent the adjustment, so it looks like a solution.

    Protection avoids the cost by giving up the gain, and it makes the eventual adjustment larger because the industry has had longer to become uncompetitive. Adjustment assistance keeps the gain and reduces the cost.

Written for this site.