Globalisation Through Trade, Investment and Transnational Corporations
The first of the three components the syllabus lists under the effects of globalisation: how global value chains, foreign investment and transnational corporations change what a developing economy produces, what it keeps and what its statistics actually show.
80 min · HSC Topic One - The Global Economy
Assumes you have read The Effects of Globalisation.
The full teaching. Start here.
- Global value chain
A production process split into stages performed in different economies under the coordination of one firm, so that a finished good crosses several borders before it is sold. About four fifths of world trade now moves through chains of this kind.
- Transnational corporation
A firm that produces in more than one economy, usually through subsidiaries it controls. Transnational corporations account for roughly half of world trade, much of it trade between their own subsidiaries.
- Foreign direct investment
The purchase of a lasting interest in a foreign enterprise, conventionally at least ten per cent of the voting shares, which gives the investor a say in how it is run. It is long term and carries technology and management with it, which is what distinguishes it from portfolio investment.
The five things worth carrying out of this lesson:
- Which stage of the chain matters more than how much is exported. Assembly captures the smallest share of the price of a finished good and provides the most jobs; design and branding capture the most. Moving stage is development. Producing more units at the same stage is not.
- Foreign direct investment and portfolio investment behave differently. Direct investment brings technology and stays through a downturn; portfolio capital is liquid and leaves when sentiment turns, which is what makes it destabilising.
- What the host keeps depends on local linkages, tax paid and profits retained, not on the size of the investment. The enclave case, imported inputs, negligible tax and profits remitted in full, is the standing warning about foreign investment.
- Transnational corporations choose where to report profit. Transfer pricing moves profit to low tax jurisdictions, developing economies lose most as a share of their revenue, and the agreed fifteen per cent global minimum tax, in force in the European Union, the United Kingdom, Japan and Australia from 2024, is the policy response.
- Read the basis of an investment statistic before quoting it. African inflows rose seventy-five per cent in 2024 and about twelve per cent without one project in Egypt. Both figures are correct.
Global value chains: which stage an economy performs
Trade is no longer mostly finished goods leaving one economy for another. It is stages of production crossing borders repeatedly inside chains coordinated by a single firm, which is why the composition of a developing economy's exports says less about its development than the stage those exports come from.
- Share of the final price kept by each stage
The numbers behind this graph
| Stage | Share of the final price, % | Kept from a US$900 good |
|---|---|---|
| Research and design | 29.9 | US$269 |
| Components | 14.0 | US$126 |
| Assembly | 9.0 | US$81 |
| Distribution | 15.1 | US$136 |
| Branding and service | 32.1 | US$289 |
- At assembly
- The economy keeps 9.0 per cent of the price, which is US$81 on a good selling for US$900
- The stage that keeps most
- Branding and service, at 32.1 per cent, or US$289 a unit, which is 3.5 times what this economy keeps
- What the shape means
- The stages at the ends of the chain are the intangible ones, design at the start and brand, distribution and after-sales service at the end, and they are the hardest to copy, so they hold their margins. Assembly in the middle competes against every other economy that can assemble, so its margin is driven down.
- Why output is not the answer
- An economy at assembly that doubles the number of units still keeps the same share of each one, and adding capacity in the same stage invites the competition that lowers the margin further. Moving stage changes the share; making more does not.
- How economies move stage
- Schooling and technical training, requirements that a foreign firm buy from local suppliers, protection of intellectual property so that design work stays, and public investment in research. This is industrial upgrading, and it is slow, which is why so few economies have done it.
- What this leaves out
- The employment side. Assembly keeps the smallest share of the price and provides by far the most jobs, so a chain that looks exploitative in value terms can still be the largest single source of paid work in an economy. Both belong in the answer.
- Read it as
- A model of how value is divided along a chain, not data on any particular product. The shape is the examinable point.
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
The shape has a name, the smile curve, and it is the single most useful picture in this dot point. The intangible stages at the two ends, research and design at the start and brand, distribution and after-sales service at the end, hold their margins because they are hard to copy. Assembly in the middle competes against every other economy that can assemble, so the margin there is driven towards the cost of the labour and the capital it uses.
Move the knowledge intensity slider up and the middle collapses further, which is what has happened as products have become more software than hardware.
Chain of reasoning
How a chain both develops an economy and limits it
The stage chosen is usually assembly, because it is the one whose cost is mostly wages, and wages are what differ most between economies.
Assembly is labour intensive, so the employment effect is large and immediate, and the goods leaving the country are counted as exports at their full value even though most of that value was imported as components.
The economy keeps the assembly margin, which the figure shows is the smallest share of the price. Gross export figures therefore overstate what the economy actually earns, which is why value added measures of trade exist.
Local firms learn the standards, the logistics and eventually the engineering. Some move into components, a few into design. This requires schooling, technical training, links to local suppliers and a government prepared to require them.
If wages rise without upgrading, the firm relocates the same stage to a cheaper economy and the employment goes with it. The economy that never upgraded is left where it started, which is the trap this dot point is really describing.
Common mistake
Why it happens:
Treating gross exports as income earned. A phone that leaves an assembly economy is recorded as an export at its full price, but most of that price was imported components. The country keeps the assembly margin. When a response cites export values to prove that a chain has enriched an economy, it has measured the wrong thing; value added is what matters.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
An economy assembles smartphones from imported components and exports them. Its gross exports are large and rising. Which statement best describes what those export figures show about its development?
Hint 1Ask where the value in an assembled phone was created.
Hint 2What did the economy have to import before it could export?
Hint 3There is a measure of trade designed to fix exactly this problem.
Foreign investment: two kinds of money that behave differently
The dot point speaks of investment as one thing and the examinable distinction is that it is two.
| Foreign direct investment | Portfolio investment | |
|---|---|---|
| What is bought | A lasting interest, conventionally ten per cent or more of the voting shares | Shares and debt securities, with no control |
| Time horizon | Long term, tied to a physical operation | Short term and liquid |
| What comes with it | Technology, management, supplier standards, export access | Finance only |
| Behaviour in a downturn | Largely stays, because the plant cannot be moved quickly | Leaves quickly, and the exits reinforce each other |
| Effect on the host | Raises productive capacity, and creates a permanent income outflow | Deepens capital markets, and transmits foreign shocks |
Two facts about direction are worth holding. Direct investment has long favoured the economies that already have industrial capacity and large consumer markets, and since 2020 the flows to developing economies have exceeded those to developed economies in some years, chiefly because returns in fast growing economies are higher. The least developed economies remain outside this: their share of world inflows has stayed small throughout, which is the same result the aid and trade evidence gave in the reasons for differences lesson.
Common mistake
Why it happens:
Calling any foreign money foreign direct investment. The ten per cent control threshold is the definition and it exists because control is what brings technology and permanence. Portfolio flows leaving an economy in a week is a different phenomenon from a factory closing, and a response that uses one term for both cannot explain either the development benefit or the instability.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A response uses the term foreign direct investment for all capital entering a developing economy, including share purchases by foreign funds. Why does the distinction matter?
Hint 1One kind of investor wants a say in how the firm is run.
Hint 2Ask which kind of capital can be withdrawn in a week.
Hint 3Technology and management arrive with only one of the two.
Transnational corporations: what the host economy actually keeps
The size of an investment is reported as though it were the benefit. It is not. What the host keeps out of each dollar of revenue depends on three things it can influence.
- Local suppliers
- Wages in the host economy
- Tax to the host government
- Profit reinvested locally
- Imported inputs, leaves the economy
- Overheads paid to the parent, leaves the economy
- Profit sent to the parent, leaves the economy
The numbers behind this graph
| Where it goes | These settings, US$ | Enclave plant, US$ |
|---|---|---|
| Local suppliers | 24.8 | 8.3 |
| Wages in the host economy | 20.0 | 20.0 |
| Tax to the host government | 3.0 | 1.0 |
| Profit reinvested locally | 5.1 | 0.9 |
| Imported inputs | 30.3 | 46.8 |
| Overheads paid to the parent | 5.0 | 5.0 |
| Profit sent to the parent | 11.9 | 18.1 |
- What stays in the host economy
- US$53 of every US$100 of revenue, against US$30 for the enclave plant, a difference of US$23 on the same investment
- Local linkages
- Buying from local suppliers is the largest single lever here, because it turns one foreign plant into demand for domestic firms and transfers standards and technology to them. Host governments pursue it through local content requirements and supplier development programmes, and it is what separates an investment that develops an economy from one that merely occupies land in it.
- Tax actually paid
- A transnational corporation can set the prices at which its own subsidiaries trade with each other, so profit can be reported wherever tax is lowest. Estimates of revenue lost to profit shifting run to hundreds of billions of dollars a year, and developing economies lose the most as a share of their revenue. The agreed 15 per cent global minimum tax, in force in the European Union, the United Kingdom, Japan, Australia and others from 2024, is the policy response.
- Profit sent to the parent
- Remitted profit is recorded in the primary income account, so a large stock of foreign owned capital produces a permanent income outflow. This is why foreign investment improves the capital account and worsens the current account for as long as it earns.
- What the model leaves out
- The jobs themselves, the skills workers take with them when they leave, the export access the parent provides, and the tax revenue from wages rather than profit. All of them favour the investment, and all belong in a balanced judgement.
- Read it as
- A model of where the money goes, not data on any particular firm. The levers are the examinable point.
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
Local linkages. An operation that buys from domestic suppliers turns one foreign plant into demand for local firms and passes on standards and technology as it does. An operation that imports everything but labour is an enclave: it employs people and little else. Host governments pursue linkages through local content requirements and supplier development programmes, and this lever moves the outcome more than any other on the figure.
Tax actually paid. A transnational corporation sets the prices at which its own subsidiaries trade with each other, so profit can be reported wherever tax is lowest, a practice known as transfer pricing. Estimates of the revenue lost run to hundreds of billions of dollars a year, and developing economies lose the most relative to the size of their budgets, which is the connection back to development: the revenue lost is revenue that would have funded schooling and infrastructure. Governments also compete for investment by offering tax holidays, which lowers the paid rate further.
Profit retained or remitted. Profit sent to the parent is recorded in the primary income account, so a large stock of foreign owned capital produces a permanent outflow. This is why foreign investment improves the financial account when it arrives and worsens the current account for as long as it earns, and it is the mechanism behind Australia's persistent net primary income deficit.
What lifts this to a Band 6
The policy response has a date and a number, so use them. The agreed global minimum tax of 15 per cent on the profits of large multinational groups took effect in the European Union, the United Kingdom, Japan, Australia and others from 2024. It is the clearest available example of governments acting collectively on a problem no government could address alone, and it is recent enough that almost no textbook covers it.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A foreign owned subsidiary earns US$200 million of revenue in its host economy in a year. It buys US$110 million of inputs, of which 40 per cent comes from local suppliers, pays US$40 million in wages to local workers, and pays US$10 million in overheads to its parent company overseas. It pays tax at 15 per cent on its profit, and sends 80 per cent of its after tax profit to the parent. Calculate the amount that stays in the host economy, in US$ million, correct to one decimal place.
Hint 1Four things stay: payments to local suppliers, wages, tax paid, and the profit that is reinvested rather than sent away.
Hint 2Profit is revenue minus inputs, wages and overheads.
Hint 3Of the after tax profit, the share that stays is the part not sent to the parent.
Reading trade and investment statistics without being misled
The skill dot point asks you to analyse statistics on trade and financial flows. Investment data is the hardest place to do that, because it is lumpy: a single transaction can set a regional figure.
The numbers behind this graph
| Measure | US$ billion |
|---|---|
| World inflows 2024 | 1500 |
| Africa inflows 2023 | 55 |
| Africa inflows 2024 | 97 |
| Ras El Hekma project | 35 |
| Egypt inflows 2024 | 47 |
| ASEAN inflows 2024 | 225 |
| Africa share of world inflows 2024 | 4 |
- Growth on these settings
- 75 per cent, from US$55 billion to US$97 billion
- As published
- A rise of 75 per cent, a record for the region, with the whole project counted
- Without the project
- A rise of about 12 per cent, which is what the rest of the continent did
- Why one project can do this
- The Ras El Hekma development in Egypt was worth about US$35 billion on its own. Egypt's inflows rose to about US$47 billion, close to half of everything recorded for the continent, and Africa still accounted for only 4 per cent of world inflows.
- The same problem in the world figure
- World inflows were about US$1500 billion in 2024, a rise of 4 per cent as published and a fall of 11 per cent once the financial flows routed through a few European economies are excluded. The publisher reports both, because only the second measures productive investment.
- What to write instead
- Quote the basis with the figure. A response that says investment into Africa rose 75 per cent in 2024, driven almost entirely by a single project in Egypt, while the region still receives about 4 per cent of world inflows, has used the statistic properly.
- Source
- UN Trade and Development, World Investment Report 2025, 2024 data, published June 2025
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
Drag the project out of the total and the record breaking year becomes an ordinary one. Both numbers are published, both are correct, and they support opposite conclusions about whether investment is returning to Africa.
The same problem runs through the world figure. Inflows in 2024 rose about four per cent on the published basis and fell about eleven per cent once the financial flows routed through a handful of European economies are excluded, because those flows are accounting movements rather than factories. The publisher reports both.
| Question to ask | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Gross or value added? | Gross exports count imported components, so an assembly economy looks richer than it is. |
| Does one transaction dominate? | A single project set the African figure for 2024. |
| Are conduit flows included? | Money passing through a jurisdiction is not investment in it. |
| Level or growth rate? | A large percentage rise on a small base is still a small flow. |
| Nominal or real, and which currency? | Flows are usually quoted in current United States dollars, so a stronger dollar shrinks everything measured in it. |
What lifts this to a Band 6
Quote the basis with the figure and you have shown the skill in one sentence: investment into Africa rose about seventy-five per cent in 2024, driven almost entirely by a single project in Egypt, while the region still received only about four per cent of world inflows. That sentence gives a fact, its qualification and its context, which is what analyse means when the evidence is a statistic.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
World foreign direct investment inflows in 2024 were about US$1.5 trillion, a rise of about 4 per cent on the published basis and a fall of about 11 per cent once financial flows routed through a small number of European economies are excluded. Inflows to Africa rose about 75 per cent to about US$97 billion, of which one development project in Egypt accounted for roughly US$35 billion. Analyse what these figures show about the direction of world investment.
Hint 1Two of the four figures are adjusted measures. Ask what each adjustment removes.
Hint 2Work out what the African figure looks like without the single project.
Hint 3A large growth rate on a small base is still a small flow.
The judgement: what these channels do to development
| For development | Against |
|---|---|
| Capital that domestic saving could not fund, and at scale | The stage located is usually the lowest value one in the chain |
| Technology, management practice and supplier standards that spread to local firms | Profit shifting removes the tax revenue that would fund development |
| Employment, often the largest single source of formal paid work | Wages and conditions are set by the threat that the stage can move again |
| Access to the parent's export markets, which no local firm could open | Remitted profits are a permanent drain on the current account |
| Competitive pressure that raises the productivity of domestic firms | Market power over small host governments, and competition between governments to offer concessions |
The judgement the evidence supports is conditional rather than positive or negative. The economies that gained most, in East and South East Asia, combined foreign investment with schooling, infrastructure, requirements to buy locally and an intention to upgrade. The economies that gained least took the same investment without any of that and kept the assembly margin. The variable that explains the difference is the host government's policy, which is why this dot point ends up in the same place as the reasons for differences between nations.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Explain why joining a global value chain at the assembly stage may not, on its own, lead to economic development.
Hint 1Start with the share of the final price that the assembly stage keeps.
Hint 2Ask what happens to that stage when local wages rise.
Hint 3What would have to change for the economy to keep more?
Why supply chains are being rearranged. The pandemic exposed how concentrated critical chains had become, and the policy response since 2022 has been to relocate production for security rather than cost: subsidies for semiconductors and clean technology in the United States, the European Union and Japan, and sourcing shifted to economies regarded as politically safe. The volume of trade has held up; its direction has been redrawn. For a developing economy this cuts both ways, since the same rearrangement that closes one door opens another, and South East Asian and Indian export industries have gained from it.
Trade between subsidiaries of the same firm. A large share of world trade is one subsidiary selling to another inside the same corporation. The prices in those transactions are set internally, which is the mechanism behind transfer pricing and also means that a good deal of what is recorded as trade between economies is really movement inside a single balance sheet.
Digital firms and where value is taxed. The largest transnational corporations by market value now sell services that need no physical presence in the market they sell to, which broke the assumption underneath the old tax rules that profit is taxed where a firm is located. The two part international agreement, reallocating some taxing rights and setting the fifteen per cent minimum, is the attempt to fix that, and its implementation is uneven enough that the outcome is still open.
The employment qualification. Every criticism on this page is about the value captured, and none of it changes the fact that assembly stage work is often the largest source of formal paid employment in the economies that host it, with wages above the local alternative. The strongest responses state both, because a judgement that treats a chain as pure exploitation has to explain why the economies inside them grew faster than the ones outside.
Where this sits. This is the first of the three components the syllabus lists under the effects of globalisation. Environmental sustainability and the international business cycle are the other two, and the essay on globalisation, priority 12, draws on all three together with the five objectives from the effects lesson.
Worked example3 marks
Analysing an investment statistic in one sentence
Foreign direct investment into Africa rose by 75 per cent in 2024, to about US$97 billion. Analyse what this statistic shows about investment in the region.
State the figure and its basis
Analyse requires the evidence before the interpretation, and the basis is part of the evidence.
Recorded inflows rose about 75 per cent in 2024 to roughly US$97 billion, a record for the region as published.
Identify what dominates the number
One transaction set the figure, and a response that misses it has drawn the wrong conclusion from a correct number.
A single development project in Egypt accounted for roughly US$35 billion of the increase. Excluding it, inflows rose about 12 per cent, and Egypt alone received close to half of everything recorded for the continent.
Put it in context
The level matters as much as the growth rate, and the share of world flows is what the comparison needs.
Even at the record level, Africa received only about four per cent of world inflows, so the rise changed the region's position very little.
Answer
Recorded foreign direct investment into Africa rose about 75 per cent in 2024 to roughly US$97 billion, which was a record on the published basis, but a single development project in Egypt accounted for about US$35 billion of that increase, and without it the rise was about 12 per cent. Egypt received close to half of all inflows recorded for the continent, and the region as a whole still received only about four per cent of world inflows. The statistic therefore shows that investment flows are lumpy enough for one transaction to set a regional total, and that the underlying improvement, while real, left Africa's share of world investment broadly where it was.
Is that answer sensible?
Three marks: the figure with its basis, the qualification that identifies what dominates it, and the context that gives the level rather than the growth rate. A response that quotes 75 per cent as evidence that investment is returning to Africa earns one.
Exam question
Harder · about 11 min
6 marks
Discuss the effects of foreign direct investment and transnational corporations on the economic development of a developing economy.
Hint 1Separate what arrives from what stays.
Hint 2Give mechanisms, not a list of adjectives.
Hint 3The variable that decides the outcome is the host government's policy.
Where students lose marks on this one
Writing two lists, benefits then costs, with no mechanism under either
Why it happens: Discuss is read as an instruction to collect points on both sides.
Discuss requires the issues argued through. Each point needs the mechanism that produces it, and the response needs a variable that explains which side dominates.
Naming corporations without naming what they do
Why it happens: Examples feel like evidence.
An example earns marks only when it carries a mechanism, such as a chain stage located for its labour cost or a profit reported in a low tax jurisdiction.
Written for this site.
Through a marker’s eyes
5 marks
Explain how transnational corporations affect economic development in the economies they invest in.
The attempt
2 out of 5
TNCs are companies that operate in more than one country, such as Apple and Nike. They bring foreign investment into developing countries which increases economic growth and creates jobs for local people. They also bring new technology which improves productivity. However, TNCs exploit workers by paying low wages and they damage the environment because developing countries have weaker regulations. They also send their profits back to their home country instead of investing locally. Therefore TNCs have both positive and negative effects on economic development.
What the marker sees
Two marks. Every item on the list is defensible and the list is the problem: each point is asserted in a single clause with no mechanism behind it, so nothing is explained. Technology is said to arrive without saying how it reaches local firms; profits are said to be remitted without identifying where that is recorded or why it matters; exploitation is asserted without the mechanism, which is that the stage can be relocated if wages rise. There is no account of the variable that decides which list dominates, so the conclusion that the effects are mixed is a restatement rather than a judgement. Explain asks for mechanisms, and a response that names five effects with mechanisms for none caps here.
The same answer, fixed
5 out of 5
Transnational corporations affect development through what they bring into a host economy and through how much of what they earn stays there.
The gain is capital that domestic saving could not fund, and what travels with it. A subsidiary brings production technology, management practice and quality standards, and these reach local firms mainly through supply relationships: a domestic supplier that has to meet the parent's specifications learns to meet them, and the learning stays when the contract ends. Employment is the other immediate gain, since the stages located in developing economies are labour intensive, and the wage offered is usually above the local alternative.
What the host keeps is a separate question from what arrives. An operation that imports its inputs, pays little tax and remits its profit is an enclave: it employs people and transfers almost nothing else. The three levers that decide the outcome are local sourcing, which turns one plant into demand for domestic firms, the tax actually paid, and the share of profit reinvested rather than sent to the parent. Remitted profit is recorded in the primary income account, so a large foreign owned capital stock produces a permanent current account outflow.
Tax is where the development loss is largest. A corporation sets the prices at which its own subsidiaries trade with each other, so profit can be reported in low tax jurisdictions, and developing economies lose more relative to the size of their budgets than advanced economies do. That revenue is what would have funded schooling and infrastructure, which is the direct link to development. The agreed 15 per cent global minimum tax, in force in the European Union, the United Kingdom, Japan and Australia from 2024, is the collective response.
The bargaining position explains the labour and environmental criticisms. Because the stage can be relocated, governments compete for it with tax concessions and lighter regulation, and wages are bounded by the cost of moving the stage elsewhere rather than by the productivity of the work.
The effect on development therefore depends on the host government's policy rather than on the corporation. The East and South East Asian economies that combined foreign investment with schooling, infrastructure and requirements to source locally moved from assembly into components and design; those that took the same investment without those conditions kept the assembly margin and lost the stage as soon as wages rose.
Exam question
Hardest asked · about 20 min
10 marks
Analyse the impact of trade, investment and transnational corporations on economic development in the global economy.
Hint 1Three channels are named in the question. Give each one a section with a mechanism and evidence.
Hint 2The skill being tested alongside is reading trade and investment statistics, so quote a figure with its basis.
Hint 3The conclusion has to explain why the same channels produced different outcomes in different economies.
Where students lose marks on this one
Describing the three channels separately and never connecting them
Why it happens: The question names three things, which invites three unrelated paragraphs.
Transnational corporations coordinate the chains and make the investment, so the three channels are one system. Saying so is what makes the response an analysis.
Quoting investment figures without their basis
Why it happens: The headline figures are the ones that are reported.
Investment data is lumpy and includes conduit flows. Naming what dominates a figure is the skill the paired dot point is testing.
Concluding that globalisation either develops or exploits, without a condition
Why it happens: A single verdict feels more decisive than a conditional one.
The evidence supports a conditional judgement. Name the domestic conditions that decide the outcome and the conclusion becomes specific rather than hedged.
Written for this site.