Applications of the Motor Effect
How a DC motor turns, why it slows its own current with a back emf, how the same machine run backwards becomes a generator, how an induction motor spins with no electrical contact at all, and why Lenz's law is conservation of energy in disguise.
65 min · Module 6: Electromagnetism
Assumes you have read The Motor Effect and Electromagnetic Induction.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
A DC motor is a coil in a magnetic field. The motor effect pushes one side of the coil up and the other down, which gives a torque
where is the angle between the field and the normal to the coil. The torque is largest when the plane of the coil lies along the field. A split ring commutator reverses the current in the coil every half turn so the torque always turns it the same way.
A turning coil also has a changing flux through it, so it generates an emf that opposes the supply: the back emf. It is zero when the motor is still, which is why the starting current is large, and it grows with speed, which is why the current falls as the motor speeds up.
Drive the same coil round by hand and it is a generator. With slip rings the output is AC; with a split ring commutator it is DC that pulses but never reverses. The peak emf is , reached when the coil plane lies along the field.
An AC induction motor has no electrical connection to its rotor. A rotating field in the stator induces currents in the bars of a squirrel cage rotor, and those currents feel a motor effect force that drags the rotor round after the field. The rotor always turns a little slower than the field; if it caught up, nothing would be induced.
Lenz's law is conservation of energy. An induced current always opposes the change that made it, so work must be done to keep the change going. That work is where a generator's electrical energy comes from, and it is why magnetic brakes slow things down rather than speeding them up.
The DC motor
A current loop in a field turns
AnswersThe motor effect pushes a wire sideways. How does that become rotation?
Bend a wire into a rectangle and put it in a magnetic field with its axle across the field. Current goes along one long side and comes back along the other. The two sides carry opposite currents, so the palm rule pushes one up and the other down. Two equal, opposite forces that do not act along the same line are a couple, and a couple turns things.
That is the whole of a motor. Everything else in it exists to keep the turning going in one direction, make it stronger, or connect the spinning coil to a still power supply.
3D model
A rectangular coil on an axle between the north and south poles of a magnet. A split ring commutator and two brushes feed it current from a supply. The forces on the two long sides of the coil are drawn as arrows, and the coil turns under the torque they produce, speeding up until its back emf limits the current.
A DC motor: a rectangular coil on an axle between the north and south poles of a magnet. The coil's ends connect to the two halves of a split ring, and two fixed brushes press on the ring and connect it to the power supply.
Press play. Watch the green force arrows: one side of the coil is always pushed up and the other down. As the coil passes the vertical, the brushes cross the gap in the ring and the current in the coil reverses. Switch the commutator to slip rings and the current never reverses; the coil rocks back and forth about the vertical and never makes a full turn.
What each part does
| Component | Function |
|---|---|
| Magnets (the stator) | Provide the field the coil turns in. Permanent magnets in small motors, electromagnets called field coils in large ones. Curved pole pieces make the field radial, so the coil sides cross it at right angles for most of a turn. |
| Coil (on the rotor) | Carries the current that feels the motor effect force. Many turns multiply the torque by . |
| Armature | The laminated soft iron core the coil is wound on. It concentrates the field through the coil, increasing the torque, and its thin insulated layers stop large eddy currents heating it. |
| Split ring commutator | Two half rings on the axle, one connected to each end of the coil. Every half turn they swap which brush they touch, reversing the current in the coil so the torque keeps the same direction. |
| Brushes | Fixed carbon blocks, pressed against the commutator by springs. They carry current between the still external circuit and the spinning coil. Carbon conducts, lubricates itself and wears away instead of wearing the commutator. |
| Axle | The axis of rotation, which carries the torque out to whatever the motor drives. |
Common mistake
Saying the commutator turns the supply's DC into AC for the motor, or that it reverses the current in the external circuit.
Why it happens: The commutator does reverse a current, and AC reverses too, so the two ideas blur together.
The supply current never changes direction. Only the current in the coil reverses, and only at the moment the coil passes the vertical, where the torque would otherwise swap direction. Name both the timing (every half turn, when the coil plane is perpendicular to the field) and the purpose (keeping the torque in one direction).
The torque
Derivation
The torque on a coil
- Starts from
- the motor effect force on each side of the coil
- Ends at
- Holds only if
- The field is uniform
- The coil is rectangular, with its axle through the middle and across the field
- θ is the angle between the field and the normal to the coil
The torque on a coil
3 steps
- 1
The force on one side
Each side of length l is perpendicular to the field whatever the coil's angle, so the whole current crosses it.
The factor counts the turns: each turn's wire lies alongside the others and each carries the current .
- 2
The turning effect of that force
Torque is force times the perpendicular distance from the axle to the force's line of action.
With the coil width , each side is from the axle. The force is always perpendicular to the field, so its lever arm is , where is the angle between the field and the normal to the coil.
- 3
Add both sides
The two forces are opposite in direction and on opposite sides of the axle, so their torques add.
Torque on a current-carrying coil in a magnetic fieldon the NESA formulae sheet
- Symbols
- torque on the coil about its axleN m
- number of turns in the coil1
- current in the coilA
- area of the coilm²
- magnetic field strengthT
- angle between the field and the normal to the coil°
- Valid when
- The coil is flat, the field is uniform and the axle lies across the field. The torque is largest when the plane of the coil lies along the field, θ = 90°.
- Not valid when
- θ is taken as the angle between the plane of the coil and the field, which swaps sine for cosine, or the field is radial, where the coil sides always cross the field at right angles and the torque is nIAB at every position.
- Rearranged
- for I: for B: for n:
- Where it turns up
- Finding the torque of a DC motor at a given coil position
- Explaining why the torque of a single coil motor falls to zero twice a turn
- Comparing the effect of turns, current, area and field on a motor's torque
- Where marks go missing
- Measuring θ from the plane of the coil instead of its normal
- Leaving out the number of turns
- Using an area in square centimetres
The angle catches students out. When the coil's plane lies along the field, its normal is perpendicular to the field, , and the torque is largest. When the coil faces the poles squarely, the normal is along the field, , and the forces pull straight outwards through the axle with no turning effect. The coil coasts through that position on its own momentum, and that is exactly where the commutator reverses the current.
Worked example3 marks
Torque on a motor coil
A motor coil has turns and measures cm along the axle by cm across. It carries A in a uniform T field. Find the torque when the plane of the coil is parallel to the field, and when the normal to the coil is at to the field.
Area in square metres
The formula needs SI units, and squaring centimetres is where marks go.
Coil plane along the field
The normal is then perpendicular to the field, so θ = 90°.
Normal at 30° to the field
The coil has turned 60° further towards facing the poles.
Answer
The torque is N m with the coil plane along the field and N m with the normal at to the field.
Is that answer sensible?
Build it from the forces instead. Each cm side feels N. Each is cm from the axle, so the couple is N m, the same answer.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A motor coil of turns has an area of and carries a current of A in a uniform T magnetic field. The normal to the coil makes an angle of with the field.
Calculate the torque on the coil.
Give it to 2 significant figures.
Hint 1Which formula on the data sheet gives the torque on a coil?
Hint 2In the angle is between the field and the normal to the coil, which is the angle given.
Hint 3
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A single coil DC motor runs at a steady speed with a constant current in its coil. At which position of the coil is the torque on it largest?
Hint 1The forces on the sides of the coil are always perpendicular to the field.
Hint 2When do those forces have the longest lever arm about the axle?
Hint 3In , is the angle between the field and the normal to the coil.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
What is the function of the split ring commutator in a DC motor?
Hint 1What would happen to the direction of the torque after the coil passed the vertical if nothing changed?
Hint 2Which current does the commutator reverse: the one in the coil or the one from the supply?
Hint 3When in each turn does it do this?
Exam question
Standard · about 6 min
4 marks
Describe the function of each of these parts of a DC motor: the magnets, the armature, the split ring commutator and the brushes.
Hint 1Which part makes the field, and which part makes it stronger inside the coil?
Hint 2Which part is a switch, and when does it switch?
Hint 3How does current get from a still supply into a spinning coil?
Where students lose marks on this one
Describing the armature as the whole rotating part, including the commutator.
Why it happens: Some diagrams label everything on the axle as the armature.
For a function mark, describe what the iron core does: it strengthens the field through the coil.
Saying the brushes conduct current "to the coil" without mentioning the rotation.
Why it happens: Treating the brushes as ordinary wires.
The point of a brush is that it slides. It connects a fixed circuit to a spinning one.
Written for this site.
Making a motor smoother and stronger
A single coil gives a torque that rises and falls twice every turn, and dips to zero twice. Real motors fix this three ways:
- Many coils at different angles, each with its own pair of commutator segments. While one coil is at its dead point, another is near its peak, so the total torque stays close to steady.
- Radial fields from curved pole pieces and an iron armature, so each coil side cuts across the field at right angles for most of its path. The force on each side is then constant, and so is its lever arm.
- More turns, more current, a stronger field, straight from .
Back emf
Every motor is also a generator
AnswersA motor on a steady supply feels a steady torque. Why doesn't it keep speeding up for ever?
The coil of a running motor is a loop turning in a magnetic field, so the flux through it changes all the time. By Faraday's law that changing flux induces an emf in the coil. By Lenz's law the induced emf opposes the change that makes it, which here is the rotation driven by the supply. So it pushes against the supply voltage. It is called the back emf.
The current in the coil is driven by what is left over:
The faster the coil turns, the faster the flux changes, and the larger the back emf. So speed brings its own brake: more speed, more back emf, less current, less torque. An unloaded motor with no friction would speed up until the back emf equalled the supply, the current fell to zero and the torque vanished. A real motor settles a little below that, where the small remaining torque just balances friction.
Back emf explains three things a motor does:
- The starting current is large. At switch on the coil is still, the back emf is zero and the whole supply voltage drives current through a coil of small resistance. Large motors start through a resistor that is cut out as the speed and the back emf rise.
- A load makes the motor draw more current. A load slows the motor, which lowers the back emf, which lets more current flow, which raises the torque until it matches the load. The motor adjusts itself to the job.
- A stalled motor burns out. Jam the axle and the back emf stays at zero. The large starting current flows continuously and all of the electrical energy becomes heat in the coil.
Try all three in the model above. Raise the load slider: the speed drops and the current and torque climb. Set a load the motor cannot overcome and watch the current sit at its stall value.
Worked example4 marks
Where the power goes
A V DC motor has a coil resistance of . When it runs at its working speed it draws A. Find the current when it is stalled, the back emf at working speed, and how the W taken from the supply at working speed is shared out.
Stalled
With no rotation there is no back emf, so only the resistance limits the current.
All W becomes heat in the coil.
Back emf when running
The net emf drives the current through the resistance.
The power split
Energy is conserved: supply power equals heating plus mechanical work.
Heating in the coil: W.
The rest, W, is the work done turning the axle, and it equals W.
Answer
The stall current is A. At working speed the back emf is V, and of the W supplied, W heats the coil and W does mechanical work.
Is that answer sensible?
The mechanical power is the back emf times the current. That is no coincidence: the back emf is the voltage the supply spends pushing current against the motor's own generator action, and that is the energy that leaves as work. A motor with no back emf, the stalled one, does no work at all.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A V DC motor has a coil resistance of . At its working speed it draws a current of A.
Calculate the back emf in the motor at this speed.
Give it to 2 significant figures.
Hint 1The current is driven by the supply voltage minus the back emf.
Hint 2
Hint 3
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A DC motor is switched on and speeds up to its working speed with no load. When is the current in its coil largest?
Hint 1What drives the current is the supply voltage minus the back emf.
Hint 2How does the back emf depend on the speed?
Hint 3What is the speed at the instant the motor is switched on?
Exam question
Harder · about 6 min
4 marks
A DC motor drives a conveyor belt. A heavy load is placed on the belt, and the motor slows down but keeps running. The load is then increased until the belt jams and the motor stops.
Explain the changes in the current through the motor, and why the stalled motor may overheat.
Hint 1What generates the back emf, and how does it depend on speed?
Hint 2How does the current depend on the back emf?
Hint 3With no rotation, where does all the electrical energy go?
Where students lose marks on this one
Saying the stalled motor draws no current because it is not turning.
Why it happens: Linking current to motion, as if a still motor were switched off.
The supply is still connected. Nothing opposes it except the resistance, so the current is at its largest.
Written for this site.
Generators
Turn a motor's axle by hand and connect a lamp to its terminals: it lights. A generator is a motor run backwards. Mechanical work turns the coil, the flux through the coil changes, and Faraday's law gives an emf.
Derivation
The emf of a turning coil
- Starts from
- Faraday's law and the flux through a coil at angle θ
- Ends at
- Holds only if
- The coil turns at constant angular speed ω
- The field is uniform
- θ is measured between the field and the normal to the coil, starting from 0
The emf of a turning coil
3 steps
- 1
The flux at time t
The coil turns through θ = ωt.
- 2
Faraday's law
The emf is minus N times the rate of change of flux, the gradient of the flux against time graph.
- 3
The peak
The sine reaches 1 when θ = 90°, the coil plane along the field.
The emf is largest when the flux is zero, because that is where the flux is changing fastest. The emf is zero when the flux is largest, facing the poles, where the flux momentarily stops changing.
The formula is not on the data sheet, but the pieces are. The slope reasoning is what examiners want: a graph of emf against time is the negative gradient of the flux graph.
3D model
A coil turned by hand between the poles of a magnet, connected to a lamp. With slip rings the lamp receives alternating current; with a split ring commutator the current in the lamp always flows the same way. The induced current in the coil, and the magnetic force that opposes the turning, are drawn as arrows.
A generator: a coil turned by hand between magnetic poles, connected through slip rings or a split ring to a lamp. The output emf and the flux through the coil are graphed against time.
Set the model to slip rings and watch the trace: a sine wave that swings positive and negative, with its peaks where the flux curve crosses zero. Switch to the split ring: the same shape, but every negative half is flipped up. Look at the force labels too. The lamp's current in the coil feels a motor effect force, and it always opposes the turning.
AC and DC generators compared
| AC generator | DC generator | |
|---|---|---|
| Connection to the coil | Two slip rings, each always joined to the same end of the coil | One split ring commutator |
| Emf in the coil | Alternating | Alternating |
| Output at the brushes | Alternating, a sine wave | One direction only, pulsing from zero to peak twice a turn |
| Output frequency | Equal to the rotation frequency | Pulses at twice the rotation frequency |
| Wear | Brushes slide on smooth rings; little sparking | Brushes cross the gaps and spark; more wear |
The emf induced in the coil is always alternating. The commutator of a DC generator does not change what happens in the coil; it reverses the connections to the outside at the moment the coil's emf reverses, so the outside circuit sees one direction. Real DC generators use many coils and commutator segments so the output barely dips.
Worked example4 marks
A farm generator
A generator coil has turns, each of area , and turns at revolutions per second in a T field. Find the peak emf, state the position of the coil at the peak, and describe the output if the slip rings are replaced by a split ring commutator.
Angular speed
The formula needs ω in radians per second, not revolutions per second.
Peak emf
The coil's peak comes from Faraday's law applied to a steadily turning coil.
Position at the peak
The emf follows the rate of change of flux, not the flux.
The coil plane is parallel to the field. The flux through it is zero, but the sides are moving straight across the field lines, so the flux is changing fastest.
With a split ring
The commutator swaps the connections each half turn.
The peak stays V, but the output never reverses. It rises from zero to V and back times a second, twice per revolution.
Answer
The peak emf is about V ( V), reached when the plane of the coil is parallel to the field. With a split ring the output is DC that pulses between and V at Hz.
Is that answer sensible?
Doubling the speed doubles both the frequency and the peak emf, because the flux changes twice as fast. A generator spun slowly makes a small emf, which is why a bicycle dynamo lamp dims at walking pace.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A generator coil of turns, each of area , rotates at revolutions per second in a uniform T magnetic field.
Calculate the peak emf of the generator.
Give it to 2 significant figures.
Hint 1The peak emf of a coil turning at a steady rate is .
Hint 2Convert revolutions per second into radians per second first.
Hint 3, then
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Compare the output of a generator fitted with slip rings with the output of the same generator fitted with a split ring commutator. Refer to the emf induced in the coil.
Hint 1Is the emf induced in the coil itself different in the two cases?
Hint 2Slip rings keep each end of the coil joined to the same brush. What does a split ring do every half turn?
Hint 3Sketch both outputs against time over one turn.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student turns the handle of a hand generator at a steady speed, first with its terminals unconnected and then with a lamp connected across them. Which statement is correct?
Hint 1Is an emf induced in each case?
Hint 2In which case does a current flow in the coil?
Hint 3What does a current in a coil in a magnetic field feel?
The AC induction motor
A motor with no wires to its rotor
AnswersNothing is connected to the rotor of an induction motor. Where does its current come from?
The stator is a ring of electromagnets fed with AC. In a three phase motor there are three pairs of coils around the ring, each fed with a current that peaks a third of a cycle after the one before. The combined field of the three pairs does not just pulse; it keeps its strength and rotates around the ring, once per cycle of the supply for one pair of poles per phase.
The rotor is a squirrel cage: copper or aluminium bars set in laminated iron and joined at each end by a ring, so every pair of bars makes a closed loop. Nothing connects it to the supply.
The rotor turns in two steps.
- Induction. The rotating field sweeps across the bars, so the flux through each loop of the cage changes. By Faraday's law emfs are induced in the bars, and because the loops are closed, currents flow. By Lenz's law these currents oppose the change, which is the field moving past the bars.
- The motor effect. The induced currents now sit in the stator's field, so they feel forces. Those forces push the bars in the direction the field is moving. The rotor is dragged round after the field.
The rotor speeds up, and the field moves past its bars more slowly, so the induced currents and the forces get smaller. If the rotor ever turned as fast as the field, the bars would see an unchanging field, nothing would be induced and there would be no force. So the rotor always turns slightly slower than the field. The difference is called slip, and it is not a flaw: the slip is what makes the motor work. Put a load on it and the rotor slows, the slip grows, larger currents are induced and the torque rises to meet the load.
3D model
Three pairs of stator coils fed with three-phase alternating current surround a squirrel cage rotor. The arrow in the centre is the combined magnetic field of the stator, which rotates at the supply frequency. The rotor bars glow where the rotating field induces the largest currents in them, and the rotor follows the field at slightly less than its speed.
An AC induction motor: six stator coils around a ring, in three pairs fed with three phases, and a squirrel cage rotor of bars joined by end rings in the middle. Arrows show the field of each pair and their rotating resultant.
Watch the three phase arrows swell and shrink one after another while their sum, the thick arrow, keeps its length and turns. The rotor bars glow where current is induced in them: brightly at start up, when the field sweeps past fastest, and faintly once the rotor is up to speed. Raise the load and the rotor falls further behind the field, and the bars glow brighter.
What lifts this to a Band 6
Some books say an induction motor works "by induction, not the motor effect", meaning its rotor current is induced rather than supplied. Both steps are needed for a full answer: induction makes the current, and the motor effect force on that current makes the torque. An answer that stops at "a current is induced" has not explained why the rotor turns.
Why the starting torque is low
You might expect the largest torque at start up, when the field sweeps past the still bars fastest and induces the largest emf. In practice an induction motor starts with a modest torque, which climbs to a peak as it speeds up and then falls steeply near full speed.
The reason is the inductance of the rotor bars. At start up the field passes each bar at the full supply frequency, so the current in each bar has to reverse rapidly. A current that changes quickly induces an opposing emf in its own circuit, by Lenz's law, and at high frequency this holds the current well below what the emf alone would drive. So the start up current is limited, and so is the torque.
As the rotor gains speed, the field passes the bars more slowly and the bar currents reverse less often, so the inductance holds them back less. The torque rises. Near the field's speed the emf itself becomes small, and the torque falls away to zero. The two effects pull in opposite directions, which gives a peak torque at a moderate slip.
| Feature | DC motor | AC induction motor |
|---|---|---|
| Supply | DC | AC, often three phase |
| Current in the rotor | Supplied through brushes and a commutator | Induced by the rotating field |
| Field | Fixed magnets or field coils | Rotating, from the stator coils |
| Speed | Varies with the supply voltage and the load | Just below the field's speed, set by the supply frequency |
| Starting torque | Large | Modest |
| Upkeep | Brushes and commutator wear and spark | No brushes: little wear, no sparking |
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Why does the rotor of an AC induction motor always turn slightly slower than the rotating magnetic field of the stator?
Hint 1Where does the current in the rotor bars come from?
Hint 2What must be changing for a current to be induced?
Hint 3What would the bars see if they turned at the same speed as the field?
Exam question
Harder · about 9 min
5 marks
Analyse the operation of an AC induction motor, and compare it with a DC motor.
Hint 1What does the stator's field do when the coils carry AC with the phases offset?
Hint 2Two steps turn the rotor: how is the current made, and what does that current then feel?
Hint 3Why must the rotor lag the field? What does the induction motor lack that a DC motor has?
Where students lose marks on this one
Stopping after "a current is induced in the rotor".
Why it happens: Thinking the word induction explains the motion by itself.
A current does not turn anything on its own. Finish with the force on the current in the field, which is the torque.
Saying the rotor is magnetised and follows the field like a compass.
Why it happens: Picturing the rotor as a permanent magnet.
The cage is copper or aluminium. The forces come from the induced currents, which only exist while the field moves past the bars.
Written for this site.
Analysetypically 4 to 7 marks
- Demands
- Break the situation into its parts and show how they relate and affect each other.
- Shape
- Identify the components, then the relationships, then what follows from them.
- Loses marks
- Summarising the stimulus rather than taking it apart.
Through a marker’s eyes
5 marks
Analyse the operation of an AC induction motor. (5 marks)
The attempt
2 out of 5
An AC induction motor uses AC in the stator. This creates a changing magnetic field which induces a current in the rotor by Faraday's law. The rotor then spins. It is used in washing machines because it has no brushes.
What the marker sees
Faraday's law and the absence of brushes earn marks. But "analyse" asks how the parts work together to produce the result. The response never says the field rotates, never gives the motor effect force that actually turns the rotor, and misses slip, the reason the rotor must lag the field. Applications earn nothing here.
The same answer, fixed
5 out of 5
The stator coils carry AC with the phases offset, so their combined field rotates around the stator at a speed set by the supply frequency.
The rotating field moves past the bars of the squirrel cage rotor, changing the flux through the closed loops of the cage. By Faraday's law emfs are induced, and currents flow in the bars; by Lenz's law they oppose the relative motion of field and bars.
The induced currents lie in the stator's field, so by the motor effect they feel forces, and these give a torque that turns the rotor in the direction the field rotates.
The rotor must turn slower than the field. If it matched the field's speed the flux through the cage would be constant, no current would be induced and there would be no torque. This slip increases when a load slows the rotor, inducing larger currents and a larger torque.
With no brushes or commutator the motor has little wear and no sparking.
Lenz's law is conservation of energy
Opposing the change costs work
AnswersWhy must an induced current oppose the change, and never help it?
Imagine it helped. Push a magnet towards a coil, and suppose the induced current made a pole that attracted the magnet. The magnet would speed up, the flux would change faster, the current would grow, the attraction would grow, and the magnet would accelerate on its own while the coil heated up. Kinetic energy and heat would appear from nothing. That never happens, because it would break conservation of energy.
So the induced current must oppose the change. Keeping the change going then takes work against that opposing force, and that work is exactly the electrical energy that appears in the circuit. Lenz's law is the rule that makes induction pay its way.
The same bookkeeping runs through every machine in this topic:
- Generator. The current in the coil feels a motor effect force that opposes the turning. The more current the load draws, the harder the coil is to turn. With the circuit open no current flows, there is no opposing force, and the coil turns freely. The mechanical work done becomes the electrical energy delivered.
- DC motor. The back emf opposes the supply. The electrical energy the supply spends pushing current against it, each second, becomes mechanical work. The rest, , becomes heat.
- Magnetic braking. Kinetic energy becomes heat in the conductor, with no contact between the moving parts.
Magnetic braking
When a conductor moves through a magnetic field, or a field moves over a conductor, the flux through loops within the metal changes. Emfs are induced and currents swirl in closed paths inside the metal: eddy currents. By Lenz's law they oppose the relative motion, so they produce a force that slows the conductor down. The kinetic energy lost becomes heat in the metal through its resistance.
A magnet dropped down a copper pipe shows it. Below the magnet the flux through each ring of pipe is increasing, so the induced current makes a pole that repels the magnet. Above it the flux is falling, so the induced current makes a pole that attracts the magnet back. Both forces act upwards on the magnet, which falls slowly at a steady speed.
3D model
A magnet dropped down a vertical pipe one metre long. Above the magnet the flux through the pipe is falling and below it the flux is rising, so induced currents run one way above and the other way below. Both senses obey Lenz law: the ring above acts as a magnet that attracts the falling magnet and the ring below acts as one that repels it, so both hold it back. The retarding force grows with speed until it balances the weight, and the magnet falls at a steady terminal speed.
Watch the speed trace settle. The magnet speeds up only until the retarding force has grown to match its weight, after which it falls at a steady terminal speed. Switch the pipe to plastic and the current rings vanish, because an insulator gives the induced emf nowhere to drive a current, and the magnet falls freely.
Three sliders change the terminal speed, and each one changes it for a reason worth stating in an answer. A stronger magnet both induces a larger emf and feels a larger force from the current, so the retarding force goes as . A thicker wall gives the current a lower resistance path, so more current flows. A heavier magnet has more weight to balance, so it must fall faster before the force can match it.
Eddy current brakes on trains, roller coasters and exercise bikes have three features worth naming in an answer:
- No contact, so no wear on the braking surfaces and no brake dust.
- The force depends on speed. Faster motion means faster flux change, larger eddy currents and a larger force. As the object slows, the force fades, which gives a smooth stop but also means eddy current brakes cannot hold something still. A friction brake is needed for the last part.
- The conductor heats up, which is where the kinetic energy goes.
3D model
A metal disc spinning between the poles of a magnet, set going and then left alone. Where the metal enters and leaves the field the flux through it changes, so currents swirl in closed loops inside the metal. By Lenz law those currents oppose the motion, and the disc runs down. Cut the disc into slots and the loops are broken, so the braking almost disappears: this is why motor armatures and transformer cores are laminated.
The disc is set spinning and then left alone. The braking torque follows , so it is largest at the start and fades as the disc slows, which is the second feature in the list above made visible: an eddy current brake gives a smooth stop but can never quite hold something still.
Switch the disc from solid to slotted. The radial cuts break the long current paths, so only small loops survive near each slot, the braking torque falls to a fraction of what it was, and the disc coasts for far longer. This is the same trick as laminating a motor armature or a transformer core, used there to stop eddy currents wasting energy rather than to brake anything.
Worked example3 marks
Slowing a train without friction
A kg train uses eddy current brakes to slow from to in s. How much energy do the brakes transform, where does it go, and what is the average braking power?
The kinetic energy lost
Conservation of energy: whatever kinetic energy the train loses, the brakes must transform.
Where it goes
The eddy currents flow through a resistive conductor.
The kinetic energy becomes electrical energy in the eddy currents and then heat in the rail or brake disc.
Average power
Power is energy per unit time.
Answer
The brakes transform J of kinetic energy into heat in the conductor, an average of MW.
Is that answer sensible?
The braking force is larger at than at , so the train slows fastest at the start and the power is highest then. The MW is an average over a braking force that falls as the train slows.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A kg roller coaster car is slowed by eddy current brakes from to on a level track.
Calculate the energy transformed into heat by the brakes, ignoring friction and air resistance.
Give it to 2 significant figures.
Hint 1By conservation of energy, the heat produced equals the kinetic energy lost.
Hint 2
Hint 3
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A train is slowed by an eddy current brake, in which magnets on the train move close to the steel rail. Which statement about the braking force is correct?
Hint 1What makes the eddy currents in the rail?
Hint 2How does the rate of change of flux depend on the speed?
Hint 3What happens to the force as the train approaches rest?
Exam question
Harder · about 8 min
5 marks
Explain how Lenz's law is a consequence of the law of conservation of energy. Apply your explanation to a DC motor and to a magnet falling through a vertical copper pipe.
Hint 1Suppose the induced current helped the change instead of opposing it. What would happen to the energy?
Hint 2In a DC motor, which induced emf opposes what?
Hint 3In the pipe, what happens to the flux through the rings of copper below and above the magnet?
Where students lose marks on this one
Stating Lenz's law and then stating conservation of energy, with nothing linking them.
Why it happens: Remembering that the two are related without the argument.
Give the thought experiment: an aiding current would feed itself and make energy from nothing. That is the link.
Saying the magnet slows because copper is magnetic.
Why it happens: Assuming any metal is attracted to a magnet.
Copper is not attracted to a still magnet. The force exists only while the magnet moves and induces eddy currents.
Written for this site.
The motor and generator equations are one equation
A DC motor with back emf obeys . Multiply by :
Supply power equals heating plus mechanical power. Run the machine as a generator and the same equation holds with the signs of the current and the work reversed: mechanical power in equals electrical power out plus heating. Electric cars use exactly this. When the driver lifts off, the motor becomes a generator, its opposing torque slows the car, and the kinetic energy charges the battery. That is regenerative braking, magnetic braking that keeps the energy.
Why a stalled motor is so dangerous
Back emf is proportional to speed. For a small DC motor the stall current can be ten times the running current, and the heating, , a hundred times. A motor jammed for a few seconds survives; one jammed for a minute can melt the insulation on its windings. Motor controllers watch the current and cut the supply if it stays near the stall value.
Where this reappears
Module 7 opens with Maxwell's unification of electricity and magnetism: a changing magnetic field makes an electric field, which is the induction behind every machine in this lesson, and a changing electric field makes a magnetic field. Together they predict electromagnetic waves.