HSC Study

The Electromagnetic Spectrum

How Maxwell's equations predicted electromagnetic waves travelling at the speed of light, how that speed was measured until it became the definition of the metre, and how the spectrum of light from a lamp or a star reveals the elements, temperature, motion and density of its source.

75 min · Module 7: The Nature of Light

Assumes you have read Electromagnetic Induction.

The full teaching. Start here.

The short version

Maxwell combined the laws of electricity and magnetism into four equations, adding one idea of his own: a changing electric field makes a magnetic field. Together with Faraday's law, the reverse, this means changing fields can sustain each other and travel through empty space as a wave. The speed of that wave comes out of two electrical constants,

which is the speed of light. So light is an electromagnetic wave. Hertz later made and detected radio waves, confirming the prediction.

Electromagnetic waves are produced by accelerating charges. The electric and magnetic fields oscillate in phase, at right angles to each other and to the direction of travel, and need no medium. Every part of the spectrum travels at in a vacuum, with .

The speed of light was measured with ever cleverer timing, from Jupiter's moons and Fizeau's toothed wheel to lasers. It is now fixed exactly at , and the metre is defined as the distance light travels in of a second.

Spectra. A hot dense object gives a continuous spectrum; a hot thin gas gives bright emission lines; cool gas in front of a hot source gives dark absorption lines. Each element's lines are unique, so they identify it. A star's spectrum gives its temperature (the peak, by Wien's law), its velocity (lines shifted, red for receding), its rotation (lines broadened), its density (broader lines in denser atmospheres) and its composition (which lines are present).

Maxwell unifies electricity and magnetism

By the 1850s four laws described electric and magnetic fields. Two were about where fields come from: electric field lines begin and end on charges (Gauss's law), and magnetic field lines always form closed loops, because there are no magnetic monopoles (Gauss's law for magnetism). Two linked the fields: a changing magnetic field produces an electric field (Faraday's law), and an electric current produces a magnetic field (Ampère's law).

Maxwell's missing piece

AnswersFaraday showed a changing magnetic field makes an electric field. Does a changing electric field make a magnetic field?

Maxwell noticed that Ampère's law gave a contradiction for a charging capacitor. Current flows in the wires, so there is a magnetic field around them, but no charge crosses the gap between the plates. Yet the magnetic field is found around the gap too.

What is happening in the gap is that the electric field between the plates is growing. Maxwell proposed that a changing electric field produces a magnetic field, exactly as a current does. He added this term to Ampère's law, which is why it is now called the Ampère–Maxwell law.

With that addition the equations are symmetric. A changing magnetic field makes an electric field, and a changing electric field makes a magnetic field. Electricity and magnetism are no longer separate subjects with a few connections: they are two sides of a single electromagnetic field, described by one set of four equations.

LawWhat it says
Gauss's lawElectric fields start and end on charges.
Gauss's law for magnetismMagnetic field lines are closed loops; there are no isolated poles.
Faraday's lawA changing magnetic field produces an electric field.
Ampère–Maxwell lawA current or a changing electric field produces a magnetic field.

A prediction: waves

Put the last two laws together. Suppose an electric field somewhere is changing. It creates a changing magnetic field around it, which creates a changing electric field around that, and so on. Maxwell showed the equations have solutions in which this disturbance travels outwards as a wave, with no charges or currents needed to carry it along. He predicted electromagnetic waves.

A second prediction: their speed

The equations also give the speed of the wave. It depends only on two constants that had been measured in electrical laboratories: the magnetic constant , from the force between currents, and the electric constant , from the force between charges.

Speed of electromagnetic waves from Maxwell's equationsnot on the formulae sheet, learn it

Symbols
  • speed of electromagnetic waves in a vacuumm s⁻¹
  • magnetic constant (permeability of free space)T m A⁻¹
  • electric constant (permittivity of free space)C² N⁻¹ m⁻²
Valid when
Electromagnetic waves travelling through a vacuum. Both constants were measured in electrical experiments with charges and currents, with no light involved.
Not valid when
The wave travels through a material such as glass or water, where it is slower and the constants of the material replace μ₀ and ε₀.
Rearranged
for \mu_{0}\varepsilon_{0}:
Where it turns up
  • Showing that Maxwell's predicted wave speed matches the measured speed of light
  • Explaining why light was identified as an electromagnetic wave
Where marks go missing
  • Forgetting the square root and getting 9 × 10¹⁶
  • Multiplying the constants instead of taking the reciprocal

Where this comes from

Worked example3 marks

Maxwell's speed from two electrical constants

The data sheet gives and . Calculate the speed of electromagnetic waves predicted by Maxwell, and explain why this result led him to conclude that light is an electromagnetic wave.

Multiply the constants

The formula needs their product first.

Take the reciprocal of the square root

c equals one over the square root of the product.

Compare with light

The question asks why the number mattered.

Fizeau and Foucault had measured the speed of light at about . Nothing optical went into Maxwell's calculation, only constants from experiments with magnets, currents and charges, yet the answer is the speed of light.

Answer

Maxwell's equations predict waves travelling at . This matched the measured speed of light too closely to be a coincidence, so he concluded that light is an electromagnetic wave, and that other, invisible electromagnetic waves should exist.

Is that answer sensible?

The units work out: times reduces to , so one over its square root is in .

Maxwell's own constants gave about , within a few per cent of the measured speed of light. That was enough. In 1864 he wrote that light is "an electromagnetic disturbance propagated through the field according to electromagnetic laws".

Hertz confirms the prediction

Maxwell died in 1879 without seeing electromagnetic waves made on purpose. In 1888 Heinrich Hertz built a circuit in which sparks jumped across a small gap, making charges oscillate rapidly back and forth. A few metres away, a loop of wire with its own tiny gap showed faint sparks: waves had crossed the room and induced a voltage in it.

Hertz showed that these invisible waves could be reflected, refracted and polarised, and that they formed standing waves between a metal sheet and the source. From the standing wave spacing and the frequency of his oscillator he found they travelled at about the speed of light. They were what we now call radio waves, electromagnetic waves exactly as Maxwell predicted, only with much longer wavelengths than light.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

The magnetic constant is and the electric constant is .

Use Maxwell's result to calculate the speed of electromagnetic waves in a vacuum, in .

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1Maxwell's equations give the wave speed from the two constants alone.

Hint 2The speed is one over the square root of their product.

Hint 3

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Why was the speed Maxwell calculated for electromagnetic waves so significant?

Select one answer

Hint 1Where did the numbers in his calculation come from?

Hint 2What was the speed close to?

Hint 3What would it mean if an electrical calculation gave the speed of something optical?

Exam question

Standard · about 4 min

3 marks

Outline how Maxwell unified electricity and magnetism.

Hint 1What were electricity and magnetism thought to be before Maxwell, and what had Faraday and Ampère already linked?

Hint 2What did Maxwell add to Ampère's law?

Hint 3How many equations did he need, and what did they describe together?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Saying Maxwell discovered that a changing magnetic field produces a current.

    Why it happens: Crediting Maxwell with Faraday's law.

    Faraday found induction. Maxwell's new idea was the reverse: a changing electric field produces a magnetic field.

Written for this site.

How electromagnetic waves are produced and travel

From a shaking charge to a travelling wave

AnswersWhy does an accelerating charge radiate, when a charge at rest or moving steadily does not?

A charge at rest has a steady electric field. A charge moving at constant velocity is a steady current, with steady electric and magnetic fields. Nothing changes, so nothing radiates.

Now make the charge accelerate, for example by driving electrons back and forth along a radio antenna. The electric field around it now changes. By the Ampère–Maxwell law, the changing electric field produces a changing magnetic field. By Faraday's law, the changing magnetic field produces a changing electric field a little further out. Each field keeps regenerating the other, and the disturbance moves away from the antenna on its own. That is an electromagnetic wave.

The wave carries energy away from the charge, and it keeps going after the charge stops, because it no longer needs the charge: the fields sustain each other.

3D model

An oscillating charge in an antenna sends out an electromagnetic wave. The electric field oscillates vertically and the magnetic field horizontally, at right angles to each other and to the direction the wave travels, and the two oscillate in phase.

100 MHz
6.0 V m⁻¹

A travelling electromagnetic wave drawn along its direction of motion: the electric field oscillates in one plane and the magnetic field in the plane at right angles to it, in phase, both perpendicular to the direction of travel. Controls set the frequency and field amplitude and show either field alone.

Maxwell showed that a changing electric field makes a magnetic field and a changing magnetic field makes an electric field, so each sustains the other and the wave needs no medium. Drag to turn the model; scroll or pinch to zoom.

Turn the model and check each of Maxwell's predictions against it:

  • The electric and magnetic fields are perpendicular to each other and to the direction of travel, so the wave is transverse.
  • They are in phase: both reach their maximum at the same place and time.
  • The magnetic field amplitude is , tiny in tesla because is so large.
  • Nothing is needed to carry the wave, so it travels through a vacuum, which is how sunlight reaches us.
  • Raising the frequency shortens the wavelength but leaves the speed at .

The wave equation for lighton the NESA formulae sheet

Symbols
  • speed of light in a vacuum, 3.00 × 10⁸m s⁻¹
  • frequencyHz
  • wavelengthm
Valid when
Any electromagnetic wave in a vacuum, and very nearly in air. Every part of the spectrum travels at the same speed c; only f and λ differ.
Not valid when
The wave is in a material, where the speed is less than c, or f and λ are for different waves.
Rearranged
for f: for \lambda:
Where it turns up
  • Converting between the frequency and wavelength of radio waves, light or X-rays
  • Finding the speed of light from a standing wave's spacing and a known frequency
Where marks go missing
  • Leaving the wavelength in nanometres
  • Thinking higher frequency waves travel faster

Where this comes from

Spreading out from a small source, the energy of the wave is shared over a sphere of area , so its intensity falls as , the inverse square law.

The whole spectrum comes from the same physics. Radio waves come from electrons oscillating in antennas, microwaves from electrons in resonant cavities, infrared from vibrating molecules, visible and ultraviolet light from electrons changing energy levels in atoms, X-rays from electrons decelerating sharply in a metal target, and gamma rays from changes in the nucleus. They differ only in frequency, from about Hz to beyond Hz.

Worked example4 marks

A radio antenna

Electrons in an FM radio antenna oscillate at MHz. Describe how this produces an electromagnetic wave that travels away from the antenna, and calculate its wavelength.

The source

Production needs an accelerating charge.

The oscillating electrons are continually accelerating, so the electric field around the antenna changes at MHz.

The propagation

Relate each step to one of Maxwell's laws.

The changing electric field produces a changing magnetic field (Ampère–Maxwell law), which produces a changing electric field (Faraday's law), and so on. The mutually sustaining fields travel outwards at , oscillating in phase and at right angles to each other and to the direction of travel.

The wavelength

The frequency of the wave is the frequency of the source.

Answer

The accelerating electrons produce changing electric and magnetic fields that regenerate each other and travel away as a transverse wave at , needing no medium. Its wavelength is m.

Is that answer sensible?

FM antennas on cars are often about m long, a quarter of this wavelength, which is a common design.

Common mistake

Saying the electric and magnetic fields are a quarter of a cycle apart, or that one creates the other only after a delay.

Why it happens: Picturing the fields taking turns, like energy swapping between kinetic and potential in a pendulum.

In a travelling electromagnetic wave the electric and magnetic fields are in phase: where one is at its maximum, so is the other. They regenerate each other continuously, not in turns.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Radio waves, visible light and X-rays all reach the Earth from the Sun. Which statement about them in the vacuum of space is correct?

Select one answer

Hint 1What is oscillating in an electromagnetic wave?

Hint 2Does anything in Maxwell's speed depend on the frequency?

Hint 3What does change from one part of the spectrum to another?

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

An FM radio station broadcasts at MHz. Calculate the wavelength of its radio waves, in metres.

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1All electromagnetic waves travel at in air, very nearly.

Hint 2Use the wave equation.

Hint 3

Describetypically 2 to 4 marks

Demands
State the features and characteristics. What happens, not why.
Shape
Specific detail: quantities, directions, order of events.
Loses marks
Explaining the cause. It is not wrong, but it earns nothing here and eats the clock.

Exam question

Harder · about 5 min

4 marks

Describe how an electromagnetic wave is produced and how it propagates, relating each process to Maxwell's electromagnetic theory.

Hint 1What must a charge be doing to radiate?

Hint 2Which law says a changing magnetic field makes an electric field, and which says the reverse?

Hint 3How are E and B oriented relative to each other and to the direction of travel, and does the wave need a medium?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Saying a charge moving at constant velocity produces an electromagnetic wave.

    Why it happens: Remembering that moving charges make magnetic fields.

    A steady current makes a steady field. Only an accelerating charge makes the changing fields that radiate.

  • Drawing E and B a quarter of a cycle out of step.

    Why it happens: Thinking one field is at maximum while the other is zero, as with energy in an LC circuit.

    In a travelling wave, E and B peak together at the same place and time.

Written for this site.

Measuring the speed of light

Light crosses a laboratory in a few nanoseconds, so every method is a way of timing a very short trip, or of replacing the timing with something easier to measure.

MethodYearHow it workedResult, km s⁻¹
Rømer1676Eclipses of Jupiter's moon Io came later when the Earth was further from Jupiterabout 214 000
Bradley1728The tilt of starlight caused by the Earth's orbital motion (stellar aberration)about 301 000
Fizeau1849A toothed wheel chopped a beam sent to a mirror 8.6 km away and backabout 313 000
Foucault1862A rotating mirror turned slightly while light made a round tripabout 298 000
Rosa and Dorsey1907Calculated from carefully measured electrical constants299 788
Essen1950The resonant frequency of a microwave cavity of known size299 792.5
Laser interferometry1972A laser's frequency counted against atomic clocks and its wavelength measured with an interferometer, 299 792.457

Fizeau's toothed wheel

Fizeau's toothed wheelWith the mirror 8.63 km away the light takes 5.75 × 10⁻⁵ seconds for the round trip. A wheel of 720 teeth first blocks the returning light at 12.1 turns per second, when it turns through half a tooth period in exactly that time. At 6.0 turns per second, 50 per cent of the light gets back through.First dark01020304050607080020406080100Wheel speed (rev s⁻¹)Light returned (%)
  • Light returned
Slowly, the light comes back through the same gap. Faster, the next tooth has moved into its path and the returning light is blocked. The first dark setting gives the time for the round trip, and so the speed of light. Fizeau used 720 teeth and a mirror 8.63 km away, and found the first eclipse near 12.6 turns per second, which gives 3.13 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹, about 4 % high.
8.63 km
720
6.0 rev s⁻¹
Round trip, 2d
17.26 km
Time for the round trip
5.75 × 10⁻⁵ s
Light returned at this speed
50 %
First dark at
12.1 rev s⁻¹
Wheel turns half a tooth period in
5.75 × 10⁻⁵ s
So c = 2d ÷ that time
3.000 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

A beam of light passes through a gap between the teeth of a wheel, travels to a distant mirror, and comes back. With the wheel still, it returns through the same gap. Spin the wheel, and by the time the light returns the wheel has turned a little. At one speed the gap has been replaced exactly by the next tooth and the returning light is blocked. Slide the wheel speed to the first dark setting on the graph.

3D model

Light from a lamp is reflected by a half silvered plate through a gap in a spinning toothed wheel, travels to a mirror kilometres away, and comes back. Pulses of light are drawn going out and returning. While the wheel is slow the light returns through the same gap and the observer sees it; at the eclipse speed a tooth has taken the gap’s place and the observer sees nothing.

8.63 km
6.0 rev s⁻¹

The apparatus in three dimensions. Light from the lamp is turned along the axis by a half silvered plate, chopped into pulses by the gaps in the spinning wheel, and sent to a mirror kilometres away. The returning pulses, drawn in a second colour, meet the wheel again. Raise the wheel speed until each pulse comes back to a tooth instead of a gap and the observer's view goes dark.

The mirror is drawn eight scene lengths away rather than 8.63 km, and the round trip is slowed to about two seconds. The wheel is drawn with 40 teeth instead of 720 and turned 18 times faster, so which tooth or gap meets the returning light is exactly right while the teeth stay countable. Drag to turn the model; scroll or pinch to zoom.

Two measurements give the answer: the distance to the mirror, measured once with a surveyor's chain, and the wheel speed at which the light first disappears. Everything else is counting teeth. With teeth, the wheel moves from the middle of a gap to the middle of the next tooth in of a second, so .

Worked example3 marks

Fizeau's result

Fizeau's wheel had teeth, and his mirror was km away. The returning light was first blocked when the wheel turned at revolutions per second. Calculate the speed of light from his results.

How far the wheel turns

The light is blocked when a tooth replaces the gap it left through.

With teeth and gaps, going from the middle of a gap to the middle of the next tooth is of a turn.

How long that takes

The wheel turns 12.6 times each second.

The speed

In that time the light makes the round trip.

Answer

Fizeau's data give , about above the modern value.

Is that answer sensible?

The main difficulty was judging by eye the exact wheel speed at which the light vanished. The graph shows why: the light fades gradually on either side of the minimum, so a small misjudgement of the eclipse speed gives a few per cent error in .

Rømer and the eclipses of Io

Rømer noticed that Jupiter's moon Io emerged from Jupiter's shadow later than predicted when the Earth was moving away from Jupiter, and earlier when it was approaching. While the Earth recedes, each orbit of Io appears slightly longer, because each successive signal has a little further to travel. Added up over half a year, the delays amount to the time light takes to cross the Earth's orbit, which he estimated as 22 minutes. That gives about , the first evidence that light's speed is finite, though too low because the size of the orbit was poorly known.

The Earth and Jupiter moving on their orbits, with the distance between them drawn as a dashed line. Io disappears into Jupiter’s shadow every 42.5 hours, and each eclipse is seen on Earth later than the last while the Earth is moving away, because the light has further to travel. The strip below plots that delay over the last fourteen months.

16.6 min
Fizeau's toothed wheelWith the mirror 8.63 km away the light takes 5.75 × 10⁻⁵ seconds for the round trip. A wheel of 720 teeth first blocks the returning light at 12.1 turns per second, when it turns through half a tooth period in exactly that time. At 6.0 turns per second, 50 per cent of the light gets back through.First dark01020304050607080020406080100Wheel speed (rev s⁻¹)Light returned (%)
  • Light returned
The same situation drawn as a graph, shown because this page has no JavaScript to animate it.
The clock and Io are both keeping perfect time. What changes is the travel time of the signal. From opposition, when the Earth is closest, to conjunction, half the distance across the Earth’s orbit is added to every signal, so the eclipses run late by the time light takes to cross the orbit. Rømer put that at 22 minutes; it is about 16.6.

3D model

The Earth and Jupiter on their real orbits, drawn to the true ratio of 5.2 to 1, with Io circling Jupiter every 42.5 hours and disappearing into its shadow each time round. Every time Io reappears a signal sets out for the Earth. Watch the gap between the two planets widen after opposition and the signal take longer and longer to arrive.

The same argument in three dimensions. Io circles Jupiter every 42.5 hours and passes into its shadow each time round, and each reappearance sends a signal towards the Earth. At opposition the signal crosses 4.2 astronomical units; six months later it crosses 6.2, and the extra 2 units are the width of the Earth's orbit.

Io keeps perfect time, so the drift belongs to the light. Each eclipse is seen late by the extra distance divided by c, and after half a year the lateness has grown to the time light takes to cross the Earth’s orbit: 16.6 minutes, which Rømer measured as 22. Io’s orbit is drawn far larger than life, and the signal is slowed so it can be watched, but always in proportion to the distance it crosses. Drag to turn the model; scroll or pinch to zoom.

Io itself keeps perfect time: it circles Jupiter once every 42.5 hours whatever the Earth is doing. What changes is how long the news takes to arrive. Start the simulation at opposition, when the Earth is closest, and watch the dashed line lengthen as the Earth swings round to the far side of its orbit. The strip below records how late each eclipse is seen. Over half a year the lateness builds up to the time light needs to cross the Earth's orbit, and then unwinds as the Earth comes back. Set the crossing time to Rømer's 22 minutes, and then to the modern 16.6, to see how the size of the effect depends on .

Foucault's rotating mirror

Foucault reflected light off a rapidly rotating mirror to a fixed mirror and back. During the round trip the rotating mirror turned through a small angle, so the returning beam was deflected by twice that angle. From the rate of rotation and the deflection he found about , over a path of only 20 m.

3D model

A pulse of light leaves the source, reflects from a mirror spinning about a vertical axis, travels to a fixed mirror and returns. While it is away the rotating mirror turns a little, so the returning beam leaves it at a different angle and the image lands beside the source. A tube of water can be placed in the path.

500 rev s⁻¹
20.0 m

A pulse of light leaving the source, reflecting from the spinning mirror to the fixed mirror, and returning. While it is away the mirror turns through , so the returning beam leaves at twice that angle from the outgoing line and the image lands beside the source. The turn is magnified in the drawing; the readout gives the true angle.

The turn of the mirror is magnified 400 times in the drawing, since the real angle is well under a milliradian; the readout gives the true angle and the true shift of the image. Filling the path with water slows the light, so the mirror turns further and the image moves more, which is how Foucault showed light travels more slowly in water than in air. Drag to turn the model; scroll or pinch to zoom.

The deflection is what makes the method work in a laboratory. The time to be measured is only s, far too short for any clock of the day, but the mirror converts it into a sideways shift of the image of about a millimetre, which a micrometer eyepiece can measure. Twelve years earlier, in 1850, Foucault had put a tube of water in the path. Light travels more slowly in water, so it spent longer away, the mirror turned further, and the image shifted more. Select water in the model: the particle model predicted the opposite, that light should speed up in the denser medium, so this result settled the argument in favour of the wave model.

Modern methods and the definition of the metre

Once and could be measured precisely, Rosa and Dorsey used Maxwell's formula to calculate directly. Essen found the frequencies at which microwaves resonated in a metal cavity of accurately known dimensions, and used . The laser measurements of the early 1970s counted a laser's frequency directly against atomic clocks and measured its wavelength with an interferometer, giving an uncertainty of about .

At that point was known better than the metre itself, which was defined by the wavelength of a krypton lamp. So in 1983 the definitions were turned around:

  • The second is defined by the frequency of a transition in the caesium 133 atom: oscillations.
  • The speed of light is fixed exactly at .
  • The metre is the distance light travels in a vacuum in of a second.

can no longer be "measured more accurately". A better experiment now measures lengths more accurately instead. Distance has become a measurement of time: laser ranging to reflectors on the Moon, and GPS positioning, find distances by timing light and radio signals.

You can measure at home. Take the turntable out of a microwave oven and heat a tray of marshmallows or chocolate. The standing wave inside melts it at the antinodes, half a wavelength apart. Double the spacing to get and multiply by the frequency on the label, usually MHz.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A class repeats Fizeau's experiment with a wheel of teeth and a mirror km away. The returning light is first blocked when the wheel turns at revolutions per second.

Calculate the speed of light from these results, in .

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1The light is first blocked when a gap has been replaced by the next tooth. What fraction of a turn is that?

Hint 2With 600 teeth and 600 gaps, moving from a gap to a tooth is of a turn.

Hint 3Time for that: s. The light covers km in that time.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student removes the turntable from a microwave oven and heats a flat tray of marshmallows. The melted spots, which are at the antinodes of a standing wave, are cm apart. The oven's label gives its frequency as MHz.

Calculate the speed of light from these results, in .

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1How far apart are neighbouring antinodes in a standing wave, in wavelengths?

Hint 2The wavelength is twice the spacing.

Hint 3

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Since 1983 the speed of light has been fixed at exactly . What does this mean for the measurement of distance?

Select one answer

Hint 1If c is exact, which of distance and time is defined from the other?

Hint 2What physical process defines the second?

Hint 3How would you find a distance using light and a clock?

Exam question

Harder · about 8 min

5 marks

Compare one historical and one contemporary method of determining the speed of light, and explain how the result is now used in measuring distance.

Hint 1Choose a historical method you can describe in steps, such as Fizeau's toothed wheel or Foucault's rotating mirror.

Hint 2For the contemporary method, think about a laser with precisely known frequency and wavelength.

Hint 3What is the current definition of the metre, and why can c no longer be measured more precisely?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Describing two methods without comparing them.

    Why it happens: Treating "compare" as "describe twice".

    Write at least one sentence that names both methods: what they share and how they differ.

  • Saying c is still measured more precisely every year.

    Why it happens: Not realising the metre is defined from it.

    Since 1983 c is exact by definition. Better experiments now improve length measurements instead.

Written for this site.

Three kinds of spectrum

Pass light through a prism or a diffraction grating, in a spectroscope, and it spreads into its wavelengths. What you see depends on the source.

Continuous, emission and absorption spectra

Hot filamentcontinuousHydrogen tubeemissionThrough cool gasabsorption400 nm500 nm600 nm700 nm656 nm486 nm
  1. 1Continuous spectrum

    A hot, dense source, such as the tungsten filament of an incandescent lamp, glows at every wavelength. Its atoms are packed so closely that their energy levels merge into continuous bands, and the light is the black body radiation of the hot solid. The spectrum is an unbroken band of colour, brightest at a wavelength set by the temperature. It tells you the temperature but not what the filament is made of.

  2. 2Emission lines

    A thin gas made to glow, by passing a current through it in a discharge tube, emits light only at particular wavelengths. Electrons excited to higher energy levels drop back down and emit photons whose energy equals the gap between the levels. The gaps are fixed for each element, so the spectrum is a set of bright lines on a dark background. These four are hydrogen's visible lines, the Balmer series.

  3. 3Absorption lines

    White light shone through a cooler gas loses particular wavelengths. Atoms in the gas absorb photons whose energy exactly matches a gap between their energy levels and re-emit the energy in all directions, so less of it continues forwards. The spectrum is continuous with dark lines. Sunlight, and light reflected from anything it falls on, shows absorption lines, because it passes through the cooler outer layers of the Sun.

  4. 4Same wavelengths

    The dark lines of an element sit at exactly the same wavelengths as its bright lines, because both come from the same energy gaps. Emission and absorption are the same fingerprint, printed in light and in shadow.

The same four hydrogen wavelengths appear bright in the discharge tube and dark in the absorption spectrum.

How each kind is produced

3D model

A hot, dense source: a tungsten filament, or the core of a star. The charges inside it are thrown about at random, at every frequency the jostling can produce, so light leaves at virtually every wavelength. The prism at the far end stands for the spectroscope on the Earth, and the screen is divided into 64 channels from 400 to 700 nm.

5800 K

A continuous spectrum comes from random motion rather than from energy levels. Inside a hot dense object, a tungsten lamp filament or the core of a star, the charged particles and harmonic oscillators are jostled about at random, and every accelerating charge radiates. Random motion contains every frequency, so virtually all frequencies and wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation are emitted and the band is unbroken. Raise the temperature and the whole band brightens while its peak moves towards the blue.

The channel brightnesses are Planck law at the temperature on the slider, so raising the temperature brightens everything and moves the peak towards the blue. The band is unbroken because the oscillations are random rather than set by energy levels, which is why a continuous spectrum gives the temperature of a source but never says which element it is. Drag to turn the model; scroll or pinch to zoom.

3D model

A hot, thin gas, as in a discharge tube or a nebula. Energy put into the gas lifts electrons to higher energy levels; each one falls back and releases a photon carrying exactly the energy of the gap it drops across. The ladder beside the cloud is drawn from the lines themselves, each rung at the photon energy of one line above the level the electron lands on.

60 %

An emission spectrum comes from a hot gas thin enough that its atoms act on their own. Energy supplied to the gas, by collisions or by ultraviolet light from a nearby star, is absorbed by electrons and excites them to higher energy levels. When an electron makes a downward transition it releases a photon whose energy equals the difference between the two levels it transitions across, so only the wavelengths those gaps allow ever leave the cloud. Pass that light through a dispersive element at the Earth and the spectrum is a set of bright lines on darkness. Nebulae shine this way.

Only the wavelengths the atom’s own levels allow ever leave the cloud, so the screen is dark except at those wavelengths. Switch from hydrogen to helium and the whole set of lines changes, because the energy levels do: this is what makes a spectrum a fingerprint of an element. Drag to turn the model; scroll or pinch to zoom.

3D model

The continuous spectrum made deep in a star on its way out through the cooler gas of the photosphere. A photon whose energy matches a gap between two levels of an atom there is absorbed, and the energy comes back out when the electron drops down again, but in a direction chosen at random. Watch those photons leave the line of sight.

70 %

An absorption spectrum starts as a continuous spectrum, made in the dense interior of the star, which then passes out through the photosphere. Specific wavelengths are absorbed by electrons there, the ones whose photon energy matches the difference between two energy levels of the atoms in the photosphere. That energy is re-emitted when the electron returns to the ground state, but in an arbitrary direction, so little of it carries on towards the observer. The intensity of those wavelengths in the line of sight is reduced, and when the light reaches a dispersive element at the Earth they show up as dark lines across the continuous band. Add gas to the line of sight with the slider and the lines deepen without ever going black.

The wavelengths taken out are the same ones the gas would emit on its own, so the dark lines sit exactly where the bright lines of that element would be. Adding gas to the line of sight deepens the lines without ever making them black, because some light at those wavelengths still reaches the observer. Drag to turn the model; scroll or pinch to zoom.

In the investigation, you look at each kind of source through a hand spectroscope or a diffraction grating: an incandescent filament lamp gives a continuous spectrum, discharge tubes of hydrogen, helium, neon and mercury each give their own set of lines, and sunlight reflected from white paper or a cloud shows a continuous spectrum with fine dark lines. Never look at the Sun directly, even through a spectroscope.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

A student views three sources through a spectroscope: a glowing filament lamp, a hydrogen discharge tube, and sunlight reflected off white paper. Which row matches each source to its spectrum?

Select one answer

Hint 1A hot, dense solid emits at every wavelength.

Hint 2A hot, thin gas emits only at particular wavelengths.

Hint 3Sunlight passes through the Sun's cooler outer gas before reaching us.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Sodium vapour glowing in a discharge tube gives two bright yellow lines. White light shone through cool sodium vapour gives dark lines. Where are the dark lines?

Select one answer

Hint 1What energy does a photon need for a sodium atom to absorb it?

Hint 2Is that the same energy gap that produced the bright line?

Hint 3So is the wavelength the same or different?

Identifying elements

Because every element has its own energy levels, every element has its own set of spectral lines. To identify an unknown gas, excite it in a discharge tube or a flame, measure the wavelengths of its lines with a spectroscope, and compare them with the known spectra of elements. Every element whose full set of lines appears is present. A mixture simply shows all its elements' lines together.

This works on light from anywhere. In 1868 astronomers observing a solar eclipse found a bright yellow line at nm that matched no known element. They named the element after the Greek word for the Sun, helium, 27 years before it was found on Earth.

Common mistake

Identifying an element from the overall colour of the light.

Why it happens: Flame tests are taught by colour: sodium is yellow, copper green.

Different mixtures can give the same colour to the eye. What identifies an element is the exact set of wavelengths of its lines, measured with a spectroscope. The colour is only a rough first guess.

Exam question

Standard · about 4 min

3 marks

Explain how spectroscopy can identify the elements present in an unknown gas.

Hint 1Why does an atom emit light at particular wavelengths only?

Hint 2Are these wavelengths the same for every element?

Hint 3What would you compare the unknown spectrum with?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Saying the colour of the glow identifies the element.

    Why it happens: Flame tests use colour.

    Different mixtures can look the same colour. The exact wavelengths of the lines are what identify an element.

Written for this site.

What starlight tells us

A star's spectrum has two parts. The hot, dense gas of its visible surface emits a continuous, nearly black body spectrum. The cooler, thinner gas above it absorbs particular wavelengths, crossing the continuum with dark absorption lines. Each part carries different information.

The spectrum of a starA 5800 K star has its black body peak at 500 nm, in the green, so it looks yellow and is class G. Its strongest absorption lines come from ionised calcium, metals.Ca⁺ KMgFeλmax40045050055060065070000.20.40.60.811.2Wavelength (nm)Relative intensity
  • Black body continuum
  • Observed spectrum
Hot stars peak in the blue and show helium lines; hydrogen lines are strongest near 10 000 K; cool stars peak in the red and show calcium, sodium, metals and, coolest of all, molecules. The line positions identify the elements, and the pattern of line strengths is how stars are sorted into the classes O B A F G K M.
5800 K
Peak wavelength, b / T
500 nm (green)
Spectral class
G
Colour
yellow
Strongest absorption lines
ionised calcium, metals

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

Surface temperature

The continuum peaks at a wavelength set only by temperature, through Wien's law, . Drag the temperature down and the peak moves to longer wavelengths and the star becomes redder.

The lines give a second, independent thermometer. Hydrogen's visible lines need atoms with an electron already in the second energy level. In a cool star few atoms are excited that far; in a very hot star most hydrogen is ionised and has no electron at all. So hydrogen lines are strongest near K. Helium needs even higher temperatures to be excited, and molecules such as titanium oxide survive only in the coolest stars. The pattern of line strengths is the basis of the Harvard spectral classes:

ClassTemperature, KColourStrongest lines
Oover 30 000blueionised helium
B10 000 to 30 000blue whiteneutral helium, hydrogen growing
A7 500 to 10 000whitehydrogen, at its strongest
F6 000 to 7 500yellow whitehydrogen weakening, ionised calcium growing
G5 200 to 6 000yellowionised calcium, metals (the Sun)
K3 700 to 5 200orangemetals, calcium and sodium
Munder 3 700redtitanium oxide molecules

Worked example3 marks

Reading a star's spectrum

A star's continuous spectrum peaks at nm. Its absorption lines include strong lines of sodium and iron and weak hydrogen lines. Find its surface temperature and spectral class, and state what the lines show about its composition.

Wien's law

The peak of the continuum gives the temperature.

Class

Compare with the table, then check against the lines.

K falls in class K, an orange star. Strong metal lines with weak hydrogen are what a K star shows, so the two thermometers agree.

Composition

Each set of lines identifies an element.

The absorption lines match the laboratory wavelengths of sodium and iron, so both are present in the star's atmosphere. Weak hydrogen lines do not mean little hydrogen: at K few hydrogen atoms are excited enough to absorb visible light.

Answer

About K, class K. Its atmosphere contains sodium and iron, identified by matching their lines, as well as hydrogen.

Is that answer sensible?

A peak in the red and near infrared means cooler than the Sun, whose peak is at nm, so a temperature below K is right.

Chemical composition

Each element's absorption lines are at its own laboratory wavelengths, so matching the lines in a star's spectrum identifies the elements in its atmosphere. How dark the lines are indicates how much of each element there is, once the temperature is allowed for, as the worked example showed for hydrogen. This is how we know that stars are mostly hydrogen and helium, with small amounts of everything else.

Motion: shifted lines and broadened lines

The hydrogen alpha line, close upThe hydrogen alpha line appears at 656.28 nm instead of 656.28 nm, no motion along the line of sight. Rotation at 5 kilometres per second spreads it by ±0.01 nm, and it is 0.28 nm wide at half depth.Laboratory 656.28 nm65465565665765865900.20.40.60.81Wavelength (nm)Relative intensity
  • Observed line
A star moving away shifts every line to longer wavelengths, a red shift; one approaching shifts them to shorter wavelengths. Rotation widens the line, because one edge of the star approaches while the other recedes. Collisions in a dense atmosphere also widen it, which is why giants have sharp lines and white dwarfs broad ones.
0 km s⁻¹
5 km s⁻¹
1.0
Observed line centre
656.28 nm
Shift Δλ
+0.00 nm
Radial velocity, v = cΔλ/λ
0 km s⁻¹, no motion along the line of sight
Rotational spread, ±λv/c
±0.01 nm
Line width at half depth
0.28 nm
Atmosphere
like a main sequence star

Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.

When a star moves away from us, the waves it emits are stretched and every line appears at a longer wavelength, a red shift. Moving towards us, every line moves to a shorter wavelength, a blue shift. The fractional change is the same for every line:

Doppler shift of a spectral linenot on the formulae sheet, learn it

Symbols
  • observed wavelength minus laboratory wavelength; positive is a red shiftm
  • wavelength of the line measured in a laboratorym
  • speed of the source along the line of sight; positive is moving awaym s⁻¹
  • speed of lightm s⁻¹
Valid when
The source's speed along the line of sight is much less than c, which is true for stars in our galaxy.
Not valid when
Speeds are a large fraction of c, or the shift of distant galaxies, which is mostly the expansion of space rather than motion through it.
Rearranged
for v: for \Delta\lambda:
Where it turns up
  • Finding how fast a star moves towards or away from us from the shift of its lines
  • Finding a star's rotation speed from how much its lines are widened
Where marks go missing
  • Dividing by the observed wavelength instead of the laboratory one (a small error at low speeds, but the wrong method)
  • Calling a shift to longer wavelengths a blue shift

Where this comes from

Only the component of the velocity along our line of sight shifts the lines. That is the translational or radial velocity.

A rotating star has one edge coming towards us and the other going away, while light from the centre is unshifted. The light from the whole disc is a blend of all these, so each line is broadened symmetrically, rather than shifted. The faster the rotation, the wider the line. Try it on the graph: radial velocity slides the line; rotation spreads it out without moving its centre.

Worked example4 marks

Shift and spread

The hydrogen beta line has a laboratory wavelength of nm. In a star's spectrum its centre is at nm, and the line is spread over nm about that centre by the star's rotation. Find the star's radial velocity, whether it is approaching or receding, and the rotation speed at its equator.

The shift

Observed minus laboratory wavelength.

A negative shift is to shorter wavelengths, a blue shift.

Radial velocity

The fractional shift equals v/c.

Rotation

The edges are shifted by ±0.050 nm, the same relation applied to each edge.

Answer

The star is approaching at about , and its equator rotates at about .

Is that answer sensible?

The ratio of wavelengths is dimensionless, so nanometres can be used throughout. The Sun's equator rotates at about , and hot stars commonly rotate at tens to hundreds of , so the answer is plausible.

Density

Lines are also broadened by collisions. In a dense atmosphere, atoms are jostled by their neighbours so often that their energy levels are slightly disturbed, and they absorb over a wider range of wavelengths. This is pressure broadening. Slide the density on the graph: a thin atmosphere gives a narrow, sharp line, a dense one a broad line with wide wings.

Stars of the same temperature can have very different sizes. A giant or supergiant has a huge, thin atmosphere and very narrow lines. A main sequence star like the Sun has broader lines, and a white dwarf, the collapsed core of a star with Earth's size and the Sun's mass, has very broad lines. So line width lets astronomers tell a giant from a dwarf of the same colour, and so estimate its true brightness and distance.

Shift or spread, and why

A full mark answer on stellar spectra separates two effects of motion clearly: motion of the whole star along the line of sight shifts every line, and rotation or density broadens them. Then give the reason for each: the Doppler effect for the shift; opposite edges moving opposite ways for rotation; collisions for density. Naming the effect without the reason usually loses a mark per property.

Common mistake

Saying a red shifted star is a red, cool star.

Why it happens: The words sound alike.

Red shift is about the positions of the lines, and means the star is moving away. The star's colour comes from the peak of its continuous spectrum, and means temperature. A hot blue star can be red shifted, and a cool red star can be blue shifted.

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

The continuous spectrum of a star peaks at nm. Calculate its surface temperature, in kelvin. ( m K)

Give it to 3 significant figures.

Hint 1Which law links the peak wavelength with temperature?

Hint 2Rearrange Wien's law for .

Hint 3

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

In the laboratory, the hydrogen alpha line has a wavelength of nm. In the spectrum of a star it is measured at nm.

Calculate the star's speed along the line of sight, in , and state whether it is approaching or receding.

Give it to 2 significant figures.

Hint 1Find the shift, observed minus laboratory.

Hint 2The fractional shift equals .

Hint 3. Which way is a shift to longer wavelengths?

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

An astronomer reports that every line in a star's spectrum is red shifted by the same fraction. What does this tell you?

Select one answer

Hint 1Is red shift about the colour of the star or the position of its lines?

Hint 2Why would every line move by the same fraction?

Hint 3What does a shift to longer wavelengths mean for the motion?

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

Two stars have the same surface temperature and neither is rotating fast. Star P has very narrow hydrogen lines; star Q has broad ones. Which conclusion is best supported?

Select one answer

Hint 1What else, apart from rotation, widens a spectral line?

Hint 2How do collisions between atoms affect the energies they can absorb?

Hint 3Which kind of star has a thin, spread out atmosphere?

CheckpointAnswer before reading on.

How do astronomers find the chemical composition of a star's outer layers?

Select one answer

Hint 1Which feature of a spectrum is unique to each element?

Hint 2Is that feature bright or dark in starlight?

Hint 3What are the positions compared with?

Explaintypically 3 to 5 marks

Demands
Give the cause, or say why the relationship holds. The word "because" should appear in substance.
Shape
A chain: this happens, which causes that, which is why the observed result follows.
Loses marks
Describing the result in more detail and never naming a mechanism.

Through a marker’s eyes

3 marks

Explain how the spectrum of a star can be used to determine its rotational velocity and its translational velocity. (3 marks)

The attempt

1 out of 3

The Doppler effect changes the wavelength of the lines. If the star is moving away it is red shifted and if it is rotating the lines are also shifted.

What the marker sees

The red shift for a receding star earns a mark. But rotation does not shift the lines, it broadens them, and the response never says why, or how either speed would actually be calculated.

The same answer, fixed

3 out of 3

If the whole star moves along our line of sight, the Doppler effect shifts every absorption line by the same fraction. Comparing with laboratory wavelengths, gives the translational velocity: a red shift means it is receding, a blue shift approaching.

If the star rotates, one edge approaches while the other recedes, so light from the two edges is blue and red shifted. The combined line is broadened symmetrically about its centre, and the amount of broadening, , gives the rotation speed from the same relation.

Exam question

Harder · about 10 min

6 marks

Explain how the spectrum of a star can provide information about its surface temperature, its rotational and translational velocity, the density of its atmosphere, and its chemical composition.

Hint 1Split the spectrum into its two parts: the continuum and the absorption lines. Which part gives temperature?

Hint 2For motion, is the line shifted or widened, and why?

Hint 3For density and composition, what do the width and the positions of lines each tell you?

Where students lose marks on this one
  • Saying rotation red shifts a star.

    Why it happens: Treating all Doppler effects as a shift.

    Rotation shifts the two edges opposite ways, so the combined line widens. Only motion of the whole star shifts it.

  • Using line width for both rotation and density without saying how to tell them apart.

    Why it happens: Both broaden lines.

    Rotational broadening gives a rounded, dish shaped profile of the same width in velocity for every line; pressure broadening gives broad wings and depends on the line. Say that astronomers separate them by the shape of the profile.

Written for this site.

Bradley and the tilt of starlight

Run through vertical rain and it seems to fall at a slant towards you; the faster you run, the steeper the tilt. James Bradley found that stars appear displaced in the same way, by up to about 20 seconds of arc, towards the direction the Earth is moving in its orbit. The angle is about in radians, where is the Earth's orbital speed, so measuring the angle gave . His result, about , was within one per cent of the modern value, 150 years before Fizeau.

Why electromagnetic waves need no medium

Nineteenth century physicists, Maxwell included, assumed light must be a vibration of something, a luminiferous aether filling space. But nothing in the wave equation needs matter: the fields themselves are what oscillate, and they can exist in a vacuum. Michelson and Morley's failure to detect the Earth's motion through the aether, and Einstein's special relativity, removed the aether altogether. The constancy of for every observer, a consequence of Maxwell's equations, is where the special relativity lesson begins.

Why helium lines need hot stars

The energy needed to lift an electron in helium from its lowest level to the level that absorbs visible light is about eV, compared with eV for hydrogen. Only in stars hotter than about K are there enough collisions and photons of that energy to keep a useful fraction of helium atoms excited. In the hottest O stars, helium is ionised once, and the lines of ionised helium appear instead. The spectral sequence is really a temperature sequence of which atoms are excited, ionised or bound into molecules.

Separating rotation from density

Both rotation and density broaden lines, but differently. Rotation broadens every line by the same fraction of its wavelength, with a rounded profile and steep sides. Pressure broadening gives a narrow core with broad wings, and affects some lines, such as hydrogen's, far more than others. Astronomers fit the shape of each line to separate the two effects.