Structure of the Atom
How cathode ray experiments revealed the electron, how Thomson measured its charge to mass ratio and Millikan its charge, how alpha scattering revealed the nucleus, and how Chadwick found the neutron.
70 min · Module 8: From the Universe to the Atom
Assumes you have read Charged Particles in Electric and Magnetic Fields and Radioactive Decay and Fission.
The full teaching. Start here.
The short version
Cathode rays. A high voltage across a gas at very low pressure sends a beam from the negative electrode, the cathode. The beam is bent by magnetic and electric fields in the way negative charges would be, so it is a stream of negatively charged particles, not light.
Thomson, 1897. Crossed electric and magnetic fields were set so the beam went straight: the forces balance, so . The magnetic field alone then bent the beam into a circle, giving C kg⁻¹. The value was the same for every material, and about times the hydrogen ion's. Atoms contain a tiny negative particle: the electron. Thomson proposed the plum pudding model.
Millikan, 1909. Charged oil drops were held still between plates, so and . Every charge was a whole number multiple of C. Charge is quantised, and with Thomson's ratio the electron's mass is kg.
Geiger and Marsden, 1909. Alpha particles fired at thin gold foil mostly passed straight through, but about in bounced back. Rutherford, 1911: the atom is mostly empty space, with its positive charge and almost all its mass in a tiny nucleus. The model could not explain why orbiting electrons do not radiate and spiral in, or why nuclei are heavier than their charge suggests.
Chadwick, 1932. Alpha particles on beryllium gave a neutral radiation that knocked protons out of paraffin wax. Gamma rays could not supply enough energy; a neutral particle with about the proton's mass could. This was the neutron.
Cathode rays
Making them
Seal two electrodes into a glass tube, pump out most of the air, and connect a high voltage across them. At very low pressure the glass opposite the cathode glows green. Something is travelling from the cathode, and in the 1870s nobody knew what. These were called cathode rays.
Two conditions matter. The pressure must be very low, so the rays can travel the length of the tube without hitting gas molecules. And the voltage must be high, several thousand volts, and always of the same polarity so that one electrode stays the cathode. It was usually supplied by an induction coil, which makes a high voltage from a low voltage DC supply by repeatedly switching the current in its primary coil.
Waves or particles?
German physicists, including Hertz, thought cathode rays were a kind of electromagnetic wave. British physicists, including Crookes, thought they were charged particles. Each side had evidence.
| Observation | What it suggests |
|---|---|
| A metal object in the beam, such as a Maltese cross, casts a sharp shadow opposite the cathode | The rays come from the cathode and travel in straight lines. Light does this too, so it does not decide the question |
| The rays make glass and some minerals glow | They carry energy. Ultraviolet light does this too |
| A magnet bends the beam, in the sense expected for negative charges moving from the cathode | Charged particles. Light is not bent by a magnet |
| Between charged plates, the beam bends towards the positive plate | Negative charge |
| The beam turns a light paddle wheel placed in its path | The rays seemed to carry momentum. The wheel is now known to be turned mostly by heating, so this was weaker evidence than it looked |
| The rays are the same whatever metal the cathode is made of | Something common to all matter |
| The rays pass through thin metal foil | Hertz took this as evidence for waves: surely particles could not pass through solid metal |
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A metal Maltese cross inside a cathode ray tube casts a sharp shadow on the glass at the end opposite the cathode. What does this show?
Hint 1Where is the shadow, compared with the cathode and the cross?
Hint 2A sharp shadow needs something that does not bend round the obstacle.
Hint 3Could light make the same shadow?
The electric deflection was the difficult one. In 1883 Hertz passed the rays between charged plates and saw no deflection, and concluded they were uncharged. The problem was his vacuum. The beam ionised the gas left in the tube, and the ions collected around the plates, the positive ions near the negative plate and the negative ones near the positive plate. They screened the plates, so the field inside was almost zero. In 1897 Thomson used a much better vacuum and the beam bent clearly towards the positive plate.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
In 1883 Hertz passed cathode rays between charged plates and saw no deflection, so he concluded they were uncharged waves. Which statement best explains his result?
Hint 1What was left in Hertz's tube besides the cathode rays?
Hint 2What would a beam of fast charged particles do to that gas?
Hint 3What would charged gas ions do to the field between the plates?
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Outline three observations of cathode rays that suggested they were negatively charged particles rather than a form of electromagnetic radiation.
Hint 1Light is not affected by electric or magnetic fields. What happens to a cathode ray near a magnet?
Hint 2Which way does the beam bend between charged plates, and what does that say about its charge?
Hint 3Does the kind of metal used for the cathode change the rays?
Thomson's charge to mass ratio
Knowing the rays were negative particles, Thomson wanted to know what they were. He could not measure the charge or the mass of one particle, but he could measure their ratio.
3D model
An electron gun fires a beam through a region where an electric field between two plates and a magnetic field from a pair of coils act at right angles to each other and to the beam. The beam strikes a fluorescent screen. When the electric and magnetic forces balance, the beam passes straight through, and the fields give the electron speed.
A cathode ray tube with deflecting plates and a magnetic field at right angles to both the plates' electric field and the beam. The beam is drawn from the gun to the screen, with the electric and magnetic force arrows on the electrons between the plates.
Start with the magnetic field at zero: the beam bends towards the positive plate. Now raise the field. The magnetic force pushes the other way, and at about mT the beam goes straight through. Change the accelerating voltage and the balance is lost, because the electrons now have a different speed.
Stage one: the speed
The plates give an electric force on each electron. The magnetic field, at right angles, gives a magnetic force in the opposite direction. When the beam is undeflected, these two forces are equal:
Electric field between parallel plateson the NESA formulae sheet
- Symbols
- electric field strengthV m⁻¹
- potential difference between the platesV
- separation of the platesm
- Valid when
- The plates are flat, parallel and close together compared with their size, so the field between them is uniform.
- Not valid when
- Near the edges of the plates, where the field lines bulge outwards, or for the field of a point charge, which is not uniform.
- Rearranged
- for V: for d:
- Where it turns up
- Finding the field strength from the supply voltage and plate spacing
- Finding the force on a charge between plates, together with F = qE
- Where marks go missing
- Leaving the separation in millimetres or centimetres
- Multiplying by d instead of dividing
Force on a moving charge in a magnetic fieldon the NESA formulae sheet
- Symbols
- magnetic force on the chargeN
- chargeC
- speed of the chargem s⁻¹
- magnetic field strengthT
- angle between the velocity and the field°
- Valid when
- A charge moving through a magnetic field. The force is perpendicular to both the velocity and the field, given by the right hand palm rule for a positive charge and reversed for a negative one.
- Not valid when
- The charge is at rest or moves along the field, where the force is zero, or θ is measured from a line perpendicular to the field.
- Rearranged
- for v: for B:
- Where it turns up
- Finding the force on an electron or proton crossing a magnetic field
- Balancing electric and magnetic forces in a velocity selector, v = E/B
- Where marks go missing
- Expecting a force on a stationary charge
- Using cos θ with θ measured from the field
This only holds when the beam goes straight. For any other speed the forces are unequal and the beam bends. The arrangement picks out one speed, so it is called a velocity selector.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student says: "When Thomson's beam goes straight through the crossed fields, the fields cancel, so the electrons feel no force at all." What is the best correction?
Hint 1Are the two fields still there?
Hint 2Each field exerts its own force. What is true of their sum?
Hint 3Would a slower electron still go straight?
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
In a Thomson tube the deflecting plates are mm apart with V across them. A magnetic field of mT at right angles to the electric field brings the beam back to the centre of the screen.
Calculate the speed of the electrons.
Give it to 2 significant figures.
Hint 1First find the electric field between the plates.
Hint 2Undeflected means the electric and magnetic forces are equal and opposite: .
Hint 3, with in tesla.
Stage two: the ratio
Switch the electric field off. The magnetic force is now the only force, always at right angles to the velocity, so the electrons move in a circular arc. The magnetic force provides the centripetal force:
Radius of a charged particle's path in a magnetic fieldnot on the formulae sheet, learn it
- Symbols
- radius of the circular pathm
- mass of the particlekg
- speed of the particle, perpendicular to the fieldm s⁻¹
- chargeC
- magnetic field strengthT
- Valid when
- The field is uniform and the velocity is perpendicular to it, so the magnetic force supplies the whole centripetal force. The period is T = 2πm/qB, independent of speed.
- Not valid when
- The velocity has a component along the field, where only the perpendicular component goes in, or the speed is close to the speed of light.
- Rearranged
- for v: for T:
- Where it turns up
- Finding the radius of an electron or proton's path
- Separating isotopes by mass in a mass spectrometer
- Where marks go missing
- Inverting the formula as qB/mv
- Forgetting to convert mT to T
Thomson actually measured how far the spot moved on the screen and worked out the bending from that. HSC questions give the radius directly.
Worked example4 marks
Thomson's charge to mass ratio
In a Thomson tube the plates are cm apart with V across them. The beam is undeflected when a magnetic field of mT is also applied. With the electric field switched off, the beam follows an arc of radius m. Find the speed of the particles and their charge to mass ratio.
Electric field
Uniform field between parallel plates.
Speed
Undeflected, so the electric and magnetic forces are equal and opposite.
Charge to mass ratio
In the magnetic field alone, the magnetic force is the centripetal force.
Answer
The particles travel at m s⁻¹, about a tenth of the speed of light, and have C kg⁻¹.
Is that answer sensible?
The accepted value for the electron is C kg⁻¹. The ratio for a hydrogen ion is C kg⁻¹, about times smaller.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
In a repeat of Thomson's experiment, a beam passes undeflected through crossed fields with V m⁻¹ and mT. The electric field is then switched off, and the beam follows a circular arc of radius m in the magnetic field alone.
Calculate the charge to mass ratio of the particles in C kg⁻¹.
Give it to 3 significant figures.
Hint 1The first stage gives the speed: .
Hint 2In the magnetic field alone, the magnetic force provides the centripetal force: .
Hint 3Rearrange to , or substitute to get .
What it showed
Thomson found the same ratio whatever the cathode metal and whatever gas was in the tube. The particles must be part of every kind of atom. The ratio was about times the hydrogen ion's, the largest known. That meant either an enormous charge or a tiny mass, and Thomson argued for a tiny mass: a particle far lighter than the lightest atom. He called them corpuscles; we call them electrons.
So atoms are not indivisible. They contain electrons, and since atoms are neutral, they must also contain positive charge. Thomson's plum pudding model (1904) put the electrons in a sphere of spread out positive charge.
The model this overturned had stood for nearly a century.
3D model
Dalton pictured matter as made of atoms that are solid, indivisible and identical within an element. Switch between one element, two elements and a compound to see the three claims the model was built on: every atom of an element is alike, atoms of different elements differ, and a compound has the same whole number ratio of atoms in every unit.
Dalton's atoms are solid spheres with nothing inside them. Every atom of an element is identical, atoms of different elements differ in mass, and a compound holds the same whole number ratio of atoms in every unit. That is enough to explain conservation of mass and the fixed composition of compounds, and it has no way at all to explain a particle coming out of a cathode.
3D model
Once Thomson had shown that cathode rays are particles far lighter than any atom, the atom needed parts. He put the electrons inside a sphere of positive charge spread through the whole atom, which made it neutral and explained how ions form. Fire an alpha particle through it and watch how little such an atom can do to it.
Thomson's replacement keeps the atom neutral by spreading the positive charge through the whole sphere and embedding the electrons in it. Removing an electron leaves a positive ion, and adding one leaves a negative ion, which is exactly what electrolysis needs.
Turn the alpha particle on. With the positive charge spread over the whole atom, the closest an alpha particle can come to all of it is the radius of the atom, so the force on it is tiny and its path bends by a fraction of a degree. That prediction is the one Geiger and Marsden tested, and it is the one that failed.
What the experiment could not show: the charge and the mass separately. The tiny mass was an argument, not a measurement, until Millikan measured the charge.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Thomson found the same charge to mass ratio for cathode rays whatever the metal of the cathode and whatever gas was in the tube, and it was about times the ratio for hydrogen ions. What did he conclude?
Hint 1What does it mean that the value never depends on the material?
Hint 2A charge to mass ratio 1800 times larger could mean a larger charge or a smaller mass. What did later work show?
Hint 3Where do these particles come from, if every material produces them?
Assesstypically 5 to 8 marks
- Demands
- Make a judgement of value, size or significance, and support it.
- Shape
- Criteria, evidence against them, then a stated judgement. The judgement must be visible.
- Loses marks
- Presenting balanced evidence and never committing to a verdict.
Exam question
Harder · about 8 min
5 marks
Assess the contribution of Thomson's charge to mass experiment to the understanding of cathode rays and of the atom. Include how the experiment worked.
Hint 1Describe the two stages: balancing the fields, then the magnetic field alone.
Hint 2What did the result settle about the nature of cathode rays, and what did the size of the ratio suggest?
Hint 3Assess means make a judgement: what did the experiment not tell us, and who filled the gap?
Where students lose marks on this one
Describing the method in detail with no judgement.
Why it happens: Assess questions look like describe questions with an extra word.
State clearly what the experiment established, what it could not show, and how significant it was overall.
Written for this site.
Millikan's oil drop experiment
The method
Millikan sprayed a fine mist of oil drops above two horizontal metal plates. Some drops fell through a small hole in the top plate into the gap between them, where he watched them through a microscope. The spray charged most drops by friction as they left the nozzle, and he could change a drop's charge while watching it by passing X-rays through the air around it.
With the plates switched off, a drop falls and quickly reaches a steady terminal velocity, where air resistance balances its weight. Measuring that speed gives the drop's size, and from the density of the oil, its mass .
With the plates switched on, he adjusted the voltage until a charged drop hung still. The electric force balanced the weight:
Force on a charge in an electric fieldon the NESA formulae sheet
- Symbols
- electric force on the chargeN
- chargeC
- electric field strengthN C⁻¹
- Valid when
- Any charge in an electric field, moving or at rest. The force is along the field for a positive charge and against it for a negative charge.
- Not valid when
- The charge's own field is included, or the magnetic force on a moving charge is also present and has been left out.
- Rearranged
- for E: for a:
- Where it turns up
- Finding the acceleration of an electron or ion between charged plates
- Comparing the electric force with a particle's weight
- Where marks go missing
- Giving the force on an electron the same direction as the field
- Using the charge of an alpha particle as e instead of 2e
Worked example3 marks
A drop held still between the plates
An oil drop of mass kg is held stationary between horizontal plates cm apart when the voltage across them is V. Find the charge on the drop, and how many electrons it has gained or lost.
Balance the forces
Stationary, so the upward electric force equals the weight.
Substitute
Convert the separation to metres.
Count the charges
Divide by the elementary charge.
Answer
The drop carries C, exactly three elementary charges.
Is that answer sensible?
For the electric force to point up, the field must point up for a positive drop or down for a negative one. The sign of the charge depends on which plate is positive, which the question does not give.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
An oil drop of mass kg is held stationary between horizontal plates cm apart when the voltage across them is V.
Calculate the charge on the drop, and state how many elementary charges it carries.
Give it to 3 significant figures.
Hint 1Stationary means the electric force balances the weight: .
Hint 2, so .
Hint 3Divide the charge by C.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A negatively charged oil drop is held stationary between two horizontal plates. Which statement is correct?
Hint 1Which way must the electric force act to balance the weight?
Hint 2A negative charge is pushed opposite to the direction of the field.
Hint 3The field points from the positive plate to the negative plate.
What it showed
Millikan measured hundreds of drops. The charges were never spread evenly. Every one was a whole number multiple of the same value, about C, and when X-rays changed a drop's charge, it changed by a whole multiple of that value too. Charge comes in fixed units: it is quantised, and the smallest unit is the charge of one electron, .
Try finding from a set of drops the way Millikan did.
- Measured drops
The numbers behind this graph
| Drop | Charge (10⁻¹⁹ C) | Charge ÷ trial |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1.59 | 0.84 |
| 2 | 1.60 | 0.84 |
| 3 | 1.60 | 0.84 |
| 4 | 1.60 | 0.84 |
| 5 | 3.17 | 1.67 |
| 6 | 3.18 | 1.68 |
| 7 | 3.23 | 1.70 |
| 8 | 4.77 | 2.51 |
| 9 | 4.81 | 2.53 |
| 10 | 4.82 | 2.54 |
| 11 | 4.83 | 2.54 |
| 12 | 4.85 | 2.55 |
| 13 | 6.41 | 3.37 |
| 14 | 6.41 | 3.37 |
| 15 | 6.43 | 3.38 |
| 16 | 6.45 | 3.39 |
| 17 | 8.09 | 4.26 |
| 18 | 9.68 | 5.09 |
| 19 | 11.10 | 5.84 |
| 20 | 11.15 | 5.87 |
| 21 | 11.27 | 5.93 |
| 22 | 11.28 | 5.94 |
| 23 | 11.28 | 5.94 |
| 24 | 11.30 | 5.95 |
| 25 | 11.32 | 5.96 |
| 26 | 12.71 | 6.69 |
| 27 | 12.72 | 6.69 |
| 28 | 12.74 | 6.70 |
| 29 | 12.78 | 6.73 |
| 30 | 12.94 | 6.81 |
- Trial charge
- 1.90 × 10⁻¹⁹ C
- Typical distance from a whole multiple
- 0.294 of the trial charge
- Largest charge that fits every drop
- 1.00 × 10⁻¹⁹ C
- Smallest drop measured
- 1.59 × 10⁻¹⁹ C
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
Half of also fits every drop, because anything that is a whole number of is also a whole number of . The answer is the largest value that fits every drop, and no drop was ever found carrying less. Notice too that the smallest drop in a sample need not carry one charge.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student measures the charges on five oil drops: , , , and , all C.
Estimate the elementary charge from these data, in coulombs.
Give it to 2 significant figures.
Hint 1Look at the differences between the charges, sorted in order.
Hint 2Every charge should be a whole number multiple of the same value. What is the largest value that divides them all?
Hint 3Sorted: , , , , . The steps are all .
Combined with Thomson's ratio, this gave the electron's mass for the first time:
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Thomson measured the electron's charge to mass ratio as C kg⁻¹, and Millikan measured its charge as C. Calculate the mass of the electron.
Give it to 3 significant figures.
Hint 1You have and .
Hint 2.
Hint 3Divide the charge by the ratio.
Common mistake
Millikan measured the mass of the electron.
Why it happens: The two experiments are taught together, and the mass is the headline result.
Millikan measured the charge. Thomson measured the ratio. Neither measured the mass; it comes from putting the two together.
Through a marker’s eyes
3 marks
Explain how Millikan's oil drop experiment showed that electric charge is quantised. (3 marks)
The attempt
1 out of 3
Millikan balanced oil drops between charged plates so that qE = mg. He found the charge on the electron was 1.6 × 10⁻¹⁹ C.
What the marker sees
The method is right and earns a mark. But the question asks how the experiment showed charge is quantised, and finding one value does not show that. The marks are for what the charges on many drops had in common.
The same answer, fixed
3 out of 3
Millikan held charged oil drops still between horizontal plates by adjusting the voltage until the electric force balanced the weight, , and found each drop's mass from its terminal velocity with the field off. This gave the charge on each drop.
Over many drops, every charge was a whole number multiple of the same value, C, and when a drop's charge changed it changed by a whole multiple of that value. No drop carried a fraction of it.
So charge only comes in whole units of C: it is quantised, and is the charge of one electron.
The nuclear atom
The Geiger–Marsden experiment
In 1909, working under Rutherford, Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden fired alpha particles at very thin metal foil in an evacuated chamber. A zinc sulfide screen, which gives a tiny flash when an alpha particle hits it, could be moved around the foil, and they counted flashes through a microscope at each angle.
If the plum pudding model was right, the positive charge in each atom was spread out over the whole atom and could only push weakly on an alpha particle. Alpha particles are about times heavier than electrons, so the electrons could not turn them much either. Every alpha particle should have gone through with at most a small deflection.
Most did pass straight through. But about in was turned through more than , and some came almost straight back. Rutherford later said it was as if a shell fired at tissue paper had bounced back.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student writes: "In the Geiger–Marsden experiment, most of the alpha particles bounced back off the gold atoms." What is the correction?
Hint 1What fraction was turned back?
Hint 2What does most particles passing through say about the atom?
Hint 3Why was it surprising that any came back?
3D model
Alpha particles from a source in a lead block are fired at a thin gold foil in an evacuated chamber, and a zinc sulfide screen on a movable arm is swung round to count the flashes at each angle. Each particle is given a random aim and deflected by the amount Coulomb law gives for that aim, so most carry on almost straight and the rare close aim comes back.
Swing the screen round from the forward direction to the back. Near the beam the flashes come too fast to count individually; by they are seconds apart, and behind the foil you wait. That pattern, not any single reading, is the evidence for a nucleus.
Why spread out charge cannot turn an alpha particle back
An alpha particle is fast and heavy. Turning it round needs a very large force. Coulomb's law says the force grows rapidly as the distance falls, but only if the alpha particle can get close to all of the positive charge.
Coulomb's lawon the NESA formulae sheet
- Symbols
- electrostatic force between the chargesN
- the two chargesC
- distance between the centres of the chargesm
- Coulomb constant, 8.99 × 10⁹N m² C⁻²
- Valid when
- Two point charges, or spherical charge distributions measured from their centres, at rest or moving slowly, in a vacuum or in air.
- Not valid when
- The charge is spread out and one charge sits inside it, as in the plum pudding atom, where only the charge closer to the centre than the particle pulls or pushes on it.
- Rearranged
- for r:
- Where it turns up
- Comparing the repulsion on an alpha particle from a concentrated nucleus with that from a spread out atom
- Finding the attraction between the electron and the nucleus in hydrogen
- Where marks go missing
- Dividing by r instead of r squared
- Using e for the charge of an alpha particle instead of 2e, or of a nucleus instead of Ze
Worked example4 marks
Spread out charge against a nucleus
A gold atom has a positive charge of and a radius of about m. Compare the largest force this charge can exert on an alpha particle () if it is spread through the whole atom, with the force when the alpha particle is m from a nucleus holding all of it. Take N m² C⁻².
Spread out charge
Outside a sphere of charge, the force is as if all the charge were at the centre. Inside it, only the charge nearer the centre pushes outwards, so the force is largest at the surface.
Concentrated charge
Now the alpha particle can get ten thousand times closer to all the charge.
Compare
The distance is 10⁴ times smaller, and the force depends on distance squared.
Answer
Concentrating the charge makes the largest possible force about times bigger: N instead of μN. Only a concentrated charge can turn an alpha particle back.
Is that answer sensible?
On an alpha particle of mass kg, N gives an acceleration of about m s⁻², enough to reverse a speed of m s⁻¹ over a few femtometres.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
An alpha particle (charge ) is m from the centre of a gold nucleus (charge ). Calculate the electrostatic force on it. Use N m² C⁻² and C.
Give it to 2 significant figures.
Hint 1Coulomb's law: .
Hint 2 C and C.
Hint 3Square the distance: m².
The paths below are calculated from Coulomb's law for an alpha particle passing a gold nucleus, drawn to scale. Move the aim closer to the nucleus and watch the angle grow.
- Closest approach
- Chosen alpha particle
- Gold nucleus, radius about 7 fm
- Scattering angle
- 97.4°, turned back
- Closest approach to the nucleus
- 53.0 fm = 5.30 × 10⁻¹⁴ m
- Head-on closest approach kqQ/K
- 45.5 fm
- Aim needed to be turned back, b < d/2
- 22.8 fm, about 1/6300 of the atom's radius
- Largest turn a plum pudding atom could give
- about 0.018°
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
To be turned back, an alpha particle has to be aimed within about m of a nucleus, a target a few thousand times smaller than the atom. That is why so few bounce back, and why the fraction that bounces back measures how small the nucleus is.
Common mistake
The alpha particles bounced off the nucleus when they hit it.
Why it happens: Collisions are usually pictured as objects touching.
The alpha particle never reaches the nucleus. Electrostatic repulsion slows it, stops it and pushes it back while it is still tens of femtometres away. The closest approach is set by its kinetic energy.
Rutherford's model
In 1911 Rutherford proposed that:
- almost all the atom's mass, and all its positive charge, is concentrated in a tiny central nucleus, about m across, with the atom about times larger
- electrons orbit the nucleus, held by electrostatic attraction, like planets around the Sun
- most of the atom is empty space
3D model
All the positive charge and nearly all the mass sits in a nucleus ten thousand times smaller than the atom, with electrons in orbit around it and empty space between. This is the model that explains the Geiger and Marsden results. Switch to what Maxwell theory predicts and the orbiting electrons, which are accelerating charges, radiate their energy away and spiral into the nucleus.
The nucleus here is drawn about a hundred times larger than it should be. To be honest about the scale, with the atom drawn this size, the nucleus would be smaller than the thinnest line the screen can draw.
He derived how many alpha particles should be scattered at each angle, and in 1913 Geiger and Marsden's detailed measurements matched it. That quantitative agreement is what made the model convincing.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
In the Geiger–Marsden experiment, alpha particles were fired at a very thin sheet of gold foil. Describe the results, and explain what each result showed about the structure of the atom.
Hint 1What happened to most of the alpha particles?
Hint 2What happened to a very small fraction of them?
Hint 3What would the plum pudding model predict, and what arrangement of charge and mass can turn an alpha particle back?
Its limitations
Stability. An electron moving in a circle is accelerating. Maxwell's theory says an accelerating charge radiates electromagnetic waves, so the electron should lose energy and spiral into the nucleus in about s. Atoms are stable.
Switching the model above to what Maxwell's theory predicts shows the collapse: the orbits shrink, the electrons spiral in, and the whole atom is gone in a hundred-billionth of a second.
Spectra. A spiralling electron would give off a continuous range of frequencies. Real atoms emit only particular frequencies: line spectra. The model cannot explain them.
Electrons. It says nothing about how the electrons are arranged, or their energies.
The nucleus. Helium's charge is twice hydrogen's but its mass is four times. The model had no explanation for the extra mass, and nothing to stop the protons in a nucleus repelling each other apart.
Bohr addressed the first two in 1913, which is the next lesson. The third needed the neutron.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
According to classical physics, why should an atom built on Rutherford's model be unstable?
Hint 1An electron moving in a circle is accelerating.
Hint 2What does an accelerating charge emit, according to Maxwell's theory?
Hint 3If the electron loses energy, what happens to its orbit?
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Put these models and discoveries in historical order, earliest first: the neutron, Rutherford's nuclear model, Dalton's indivisible atom, Bohr's quantised orbits, Thomson's plum pudding model.
- Rutherford's nuclear model
- Dalton's indivisible atom
- the neutron
- Thomson's plum pudding model
- Bohr's quantised orbits
Hint 1Dalton's atoms came long before anyone knew atoms had parts.
Hint 2The electron had to be found before anyone could put electrons in a model.
Hint 3Bohr built on Rutherford's model in 1913. The neutron was found in 1932.
Assesstypically 5 to 8 marks
- Demands
- Make a judgement of value, size or significance, and support it.
- Shape
- Criteria, evidence against them, then a stated judgement. The judgement must be visible.
- Loses marks
- Presenting balanced evidence and never committing to a verdict.
Exam question
Harder · about 8 min
5 marks
Assess Rutherford's model of the atom, using the evidence it was based on and its limitations.
Hint 1What were the two key observations of the Geiger–Marsden experiment, and how does the model explain each?
Hint 2What could the model not explain about the electrons, and about the nucleus?
Hint 3Finish with a judgement: an improvement on the plum pudding model, but incomplete.
Where students lose marks on this one
Listing features and limitations with no final judgement.
Why it happens: Treating assess as describe.
End by weighing the model: how much it explained, and what it left for Bohr and Chadwick.
Written for this site.
Chadwick and the neutron
In 1920 Rutherford suggested that the nucleus might contain a neutral particle with about a proton's mass. Without a charge it would be very hard to detect, and for twelve years nobody could find it. Until then the extra mass was explained by extra protons, with electrons inside the nucleus to cancel their charge.
The puzzle
In 1930 Bothe and Becker found that alpha particles from polonium striking beryllium produced a very penetrating radiation, not deflected by electric or magnetic fields. In 1932 Irène Joliot-Curie and Frédéric Joliot found it knocked fast protons out of paraffin wax, which is rich in hydrogen. They assumed it was gamma radiation.
Chadwick's apparatus
1Polonium: the alpha source
Polonium emits alpha particles and almost no gamma rays, so any penetrating radiation beyond the beryllium must come from the beryllium itself.
2Beryllium target
An alpha particle is absorbed by a beryllium-9 nucleus, which becomes carbon-12 and releases a neutron: . This reaction releases only a few MeV.
3The neutral radiation
Not deflected by electric or magnetic fields, so it is neutral. That rules out protons, electrons and alpha particles, but not gamma rays. It also passes through several centimetres of lead.
4Paraffin wax
Paraffin is mostly hydrogen and carbon. When the radiation hits a hydrogen nucleus, a proton, it can knock it out at high speed. Protons are charged, so they can be detected where the radiation itself could not.
5Ionisation chamber
The protons ionise the gas in the chamber and each gives a pulse of current, which is counted. Putting thin sheets of aluminium in front of the chamber and seeing how many stop the protons gave their range, and so their speed.
3D model
Alpha particles from polonium strike beryllium, and something neutral comes out. It is not bent by the magnet and it is not stopped by lead, yet when it reaches paraffin wax it knocks protons out hard enough to be counted in an ionisation chamber. Switch the target to nitrogen and the recoils are slower, and the two measurements together fix the mass of the new particle.
Switch the target between paraffin wax and nitrogen. The radiation is the same both times, yet the recoils differ, and it is that pair of measurements that gives the mass of the particle rather than either one alone.
Why not gamma rays?
Chadwick repeated the experiment and measured the speeds of the knocked out protons, and also of nitrogen nuclei knocked on by the same radiation. A photon gives little momentum to a heavy nucleus. For gamma rays to give the protons their observed speeds, they would need about MeV, and to give the nitrogen nuclei theirs, about MeV. The beryllium reaction released only a few MeV. Worse, the two estimates disagreed with each other.
A neutral particle with about the proton's mass fitted everything. In a head-on elastic collision, a particle hitting a stationary one of the same mass stops and hands on all its speed, which explains why protons came out so fast. And using conservation of momentum and kinetic energy for collisions with two different targets, Chadwick could find the particle's mass without knowing its speed.
Worked example4 marks
The mass of the neutral particle from recoils
In a head-on elastic collision, a particle of mass and speed gives a stationary nucleus of mass a speed , from conservation of momentum and kinetic energy.
The same neutral radiation gives hydrogen nuclei (mass u) a maximum speed of m s⁻¹ and helium nuclei (mass u) a maximum speed of m s⁻¹. Find the mass of the neutral particle.
Write both collisions
The incoming particle is the same in both, so m and u are the same.
Divide
The unknown speed u cancels.
Solve
Multiply out and collect the terms in m.
Answer
The neutral particle has a mass of u, the same as a proton.
Is that answer sensible?
Chadwick used hydrogen and nitrogen and got about u, within his measurement uncertainty of the modern value, u. A photon has no mass, so no value of fits a gamma ray.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
In a head-on elastic collision, a particle of mass moving at speed gives a stationary nucleus of mass a speed .
Chadwick found the fastest hydrogen nuclei (mass u) knocked on by the beryllium radiation had speed m s⁻¹, and the fastest nitrogen nuclei (mass u) had speed m s⁻¹. Calculate the mass of the neutral particle in u.
Give it to 2 significant figures.
Hint 1Write the formula for hydrogen and for nitrogen. The unknown speed is the same in both.
Hint 2Divide one by the other so that cancels: .
Hint 3. Solve .
Common mistake
Chadwick proved the radiation was neutrons because it was not deflected by fields.
Why it happens: No deflection is the first property listed, and it does rule out the charged particles.
No deflection only shows the radiation is neutral, and gamma rays are neutral too. What ruled out gamma rays was energy and momentum: gamma rays could not give the protons and nitrogen nuclei their measured speeds.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student writes: "Chadwick proved the radiation from beryllium was made of neutrons because it was not deflected by electric or magnetic fields." What is wrong with this?
Hint 1What other radiation is also undeflected by fields?
Hint 2What did other scientists think the radiation was?
Hint 3What did the energies of the protons and nitrogen nuclei it knocked out show?
What it showed
The nucleus contains protons and neutrons. A nucleus with atomic number and mass number has protons and neutrons, which explains why nuclei are heavier than their charge suggests, and why isotopes of an element have different masses but the same chemistry. The idea of electrons inside the nucleus was dropped. The neutron's lack of charge also made it an ideal probe: it can reach a nucleus without being repelled, which led within seven years to the discovery of nuclear fission.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Before 1932, a nitrogen-14 nucleus was thought to contain protons and electrons. What does the neutron model say it contains, and what did the older model get wrong?
Hint 1Nitrogen's atomic number is .
Hint 2Mass number is protons plus neutrons.
Hint 3Electrons are far too light to account for mass, and the older model needed them only to cancel charge.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Explain how Chadwick's experiment provided evidence for the neutron, and why the neutron was needed in the model of the atom.
Hint 1What was the source of the radiation, and what did it hit?
Hint 2Why could the radiation not be gamma rays?
Hint 3What problem with atomic masses did the neutron solve?
How close does an alpha particle get?
A head-on alpha particle slows as it approaches, stops, and is pushed back. At the turning point all its kinetic energy has become electrical potential energy:
For a MeV alpha particle and gold, J, so
The nucleus must be smaller than this, or the alpha particle would have reached it and the scattering would not follow Coulomb's law. Rutherford's first estimate of nuclear size came from exactly this argument. With faster alpha particles and lighter nuclei, scattering did stop following Coulomb's law, at around m: the alpha particles were touching the nucleus and feeling the strong force.
Buoyancy and drag in Millikan's experiment
A drop in air also feels an upward buoyancy force equal to the weight of the air it displaces. For oil in air it is only about a thousandth of the weight, so HSC questions ignore it, but Millikan corrected for it. He also found that for drops this small, the usual formula for air resistance needed a correction, because a drop only a few hundred times wider than the gaps between air molecules no longer moves through the air as if it were a smooth fluid. His published C was a little low because his value for the viscosity of air was slightly wrong.
Why Thomson's ratio was so surprising
Before 1897 the largest known charge to mass ratio was the hydrogen ion's, from electrolysis. Thomson's particles had a ratio times larger, and he could not be sure whether they had a larger charge or a smaller mass. He argued for a smaller mass partly from Lenard's result that cathode rays travel much further through air than any atom could, which only a very small particle would. Millikan's measurement settled it: the charge is the same size as the hydrogen ion's, so the whole difference is in the mass.