Case Study: Globalisation and Development in Vietnam
The Topic 1 case study, run on Vietnam: what globalisation did to an economy that opened from a very low base, which government strategies produced the result, and how to evaluate them rather than list them.
90 min · HSC Topic One - The Global Economy
Assumes you have read The Effects of Globalisation, Globalisation Through Trade, Investment and Transnational Corporations and The International Business Cycle and Development.
The full teaching. Start here.
- Case study
A sustained example used as evidence. In this syllabus it means one economy, studied closely enough that you can quote its policies, its indicators and its turning points from memory, and use them to answer a question that was not written about it.
- Doi Moi
"Renovation": the set of reforms adopted by Vietnam from 1986 that replaced central planning with a "socialist oriented market economy", legalised private enterprise, opened the economy to foreign investment and trade, and left the state in control of the major industries and the political system.
- Export processing zone
An industrial area where firms producing for export face lower tariffs, simpler customs and, usually, lower tax. It is a way of giving exporters the conditions of an open economy without opening the whole economy at once.
- Domestic value added
The share of the value of an export that is created inside the exporting economy, rather than imported as components. It is the number that converts an export total into an income gain.
Evaluatetypically 6 to 8 marks
- Demands
- Judge worth against criteria, weighing strengths against weaknesses, and conclude.
- Shape
- A position stated early, defended with evidence, with the counter-case acknowledged and answered.
- Loses marks
- Listing advantages and disadvantages with no weighting, so nothing is actually evaluated.
Where Vietnam started, and what the record looks like
In the mid 1980s Vietnam was one of the poorest economies in the world. It was recovering from four decades of war, running a centrally planned system with collectivised agriculture, experiencing inflation above 300 per cent, and importing rice it could not grow enough of. It was also largely closed: trade was conducted mainly with the Soviet bloc through state agencies, and that arrangement was about to disappear.
The reform programme adopted in 1986 and implemented from 1988, Doi Moi, is the starting point of the case study. What follows is one of the fastest sustained improvements in living standards ever recorded.
- Income per person, as published
- Income per person growing at 2.5 per cent a year
- The difference the growth rate makes
- In 2024
- Income per person is about US$4700, against about US$232 on the comparison path, and trade is worth about 180 per cent of GDP.
- What the record is
- From about one hundred United States dollars a person in 1990 to several thousand today, with growth averaging between six and seven per cent a year for three decades, and the share of the population in extreme poverty falling from more than half to a small fraction. Vietnam was reclassified as a lower middle income economy in 2009 and has been in the high human development group since 2019.
- Why the comparison path is drawn
- Because the marks are not in the growth rate, they are in the explanation of it. An economy growing at two and a half per cent a year, which is a respectable rate, would not be anywhere near the published line. The gap is what has to be accounted for, and the account is integration: export manufacturing, foreign direct investment and the agreements that gave both access to markets.
- What the openness figure means
- Exports plus imports are worth close to twice GDP. That is not a rounding error: exports and imports are gross flows while GDP is value added, so an economy that imports components and re-exports assembled goods counts the same parts twice. The ratio is still the right measure of exposure, because it is the gross flow that stops when a foreign market stops buying.
- Where the argument goes next
- A response that stops here has described growth. The evaluation is in what the growth was made of: whether the income stays in Vietnam, whether the development indicators moved with the income, and what the same openness does when world demand falls. The other two figures in this lesson are those two questions.
- Read it as
- One published series and one arithmetic comparison. Income at market exchange rates understates living standards against a purchasing power parity measure, and the values are rounded, so quote the order of magnitude and the growth rate rather than the last digit.
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
Three facts are worth committing to memory, because they anchor every paragraph you will write about this economy:
| Fact | Figure |
|---|---|
| Income per person | From about one hundred United States dollars in 1990 to the order of several thousand today |
| Growth | Averaging between six and seven per cent a year for three decades, interrupted only by the Asian crisis and the pandemic |
| Poverty | From more than half the population in extreme poverty in the early 1990s to a small fraction of it |
| Openness | Exports plus imports worth close to twice GDP, among the highest ratios of any economy of its size |
| Development status | Lower middle income since 2009, and in the high human development group since 2019 |
Common mistake
Beginning the case study at the growth rate
Why it happens:
Six per cent growth in a high income economy would be extraordinary; six per cent from one hundred dollars a person is a different claim, and the compounding is the whole story. A response that opens with the starting conditions, the war, the planned system, the inflation, the rice imports, has already explained why the strategies that followed were possible and why they are not directly transferable.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Vietnam's trade, measured as exports plus imports, is worth close to twice its GDP. What does a ratio above 100 per cent tell you?
Hint 1Exports and imports are measured at their full sale value; GDP is measured as value added.
Hint 2What happens to the figures when a factory imports US$8 of parts and exports a US$10 finished good?
Hint 3The ratio is added together, not netted off, so it is not about the balance of trade.
The strategies, grouped so that they can be evaluated
Learning a list of policies is not the same as being able to use them. Group them by what they were trying to do, because a question will ask about growth, or about development, or about a particular channel, and the group is what you retrieve.
| Group | The strategies | What each was meant to achieve |
|---|---|---|
| Domestic market reform | Doi Moi from 1986; household land use rights and the end of agricultural collectives from 1988; price liberalisation; legal recognition of private firms; partial equitisation of state owned enterprises | Restore the incentive to produce, and free labour and land to move to more productive uses |
| Opening to foreign investment | Foreign investment law of 1987 and its successors; export processing zones and industrial parks; corporate tax holidays and reductions for exporters; permission for wholly foreign owned firms | Import the capital, the technology and the management that domestic saving could not supply |
| Trade integration | Normalised trade with the United States in 2001; WTO accession in 2007; the CPTPP in force from 2019; the European Union agreement from 2020; RCEP from 2022 | Buy secure access to the markets that the export strategy depends on, and lock in domestic reform through external commitments |
| Building the inputs | Near universal electrification; heavy public investment in roads, ports and power; universal primary and lower secondary schooling; targeted poverty and health programmes | Supply what foreign investment needs and convert growth into development |
| Managing the exposure | Accumulating foreign exchange reserves; a managed exchange rate; fiscal support and monetary easing in downturns; diversifying markets through new agreements | Keep the cycle from destroying the gains between booms |
Two features of this list are what an examiner is looking for.
The first is sequence. Agriculture was reformed before industry, which mattered because most of the population farmed; the export sector was opened through zones before the whole economy was opened; and the trade agreements came after there was something to export. The order was not accidental and it is the part that generalises to other economies.
The second is that the strategies are complementary rather than separate. Foreign investment only produced an export boom because the ports, the roads and the electricity existed, because schooling had produced a literate workforce, and because the trade agreements guaranteed that the output could be sold. Take any one away and the others deliver much less. That is the argument to make when a question asks which strategy mattered most.
Chain of reasoning
How the strategies connect to the growth rate
Land reform gives farming households the right to use their land and keep what they produce, so agricultural output rises and Vietnam moves from importing rice to being one of the largest exporters of it.
Rising farm productivity releases labour from agriculture, and the population is young, literate and prepared to move to where the work is.
Investment rules, tax incentives, industrial parks and low wages attract foreign manufacturers looking for an alternative to producing in China, which accelerates sharply after 2018 as firms diversify their supply chains.
Those firms employ the released labour at wages far above farm incomes, which raises household income, saving and the domestic market.
Their output is sold into markets opened by the trade agreements, so export income rises, which funds the imports of capital equipment that raise productivity further.
Tax revenue and remitted income fund electrification, schooling and health spending, which convert the growth into development and prepare the next cohort of workers.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Explain how TWO government strategies contributed to economic growth in an economy other than Australia that you have studied. Refer to the sequence in which the strategies were adopted.
Hint 1Choose strategies from different groups, so that the two explanations do not repeat each other.
Hint 2Each explanation needs a chain: what the policy changed, what that made possible, and how it reached output.
Hint 3The sequence mark is for saying why one strategy had to come before the other.
Whether the growth became development
This is where most responses stop too early, and it is half the dot point. Growth is an increase in real output; development is an improvement in the standard of living, measured across income, health and education together.
Vietnam is one of the clearer cases where the two moved together rather than apart:
- Poverty fell from more than half the population in the early 1990s to a small fraction on the extreme poverty line, with the national multidimensional measure in the low single digits.
- Health and education improved with it: life expectancy in the mid seventies, near universal primary and lower secondary enrolment, and performance in international assessments well above what an economy of Vietnam's income would predict.
- The Human Development Index placed Vietnam in the high human development group from 2019, a category most economies do not reach at that income level.
- Electrification reached effectively the whole population, which is the input that makes both the factories and the schooling usable.
The reason the two moved together is worth stating, because it is an argument rather than a fact: the growth was labour intensive. An export manufacturing strategy employs large numbers of low skilled workers, so the income from growth reached households directly through wages rather than only through the budget. An economy that grows by exporting minerals can raise GDP without employing many people, which is why the same growth rate produces much less development there.
Common mistake
Using rising GDP per capita as evidence of development
Why it happens:
The case study is the place where this distinction earns marks rather than costs them. Say that income per person rose, then say that life expectancy, schooling and poverty moved with it, then explain why: the growth was in labour intensive manufacturing and it was accompanied by public spending on the inputs of development. That is a causal account, not a list of indicators.
What lifts this to a Band 6
Name the gaps as well. Development gains are uneven between the industrial south and east and the northern uplands, and ethnic minority communities remain far poorer than the national average on every measure. A response that reports uniform improvement is easier to disbelieve than one that reports improvement with a distributional qualification.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A student writes: 'Vietnam's rapid growth automatically produced development, because when GDP per capita rises, living standards rise with it.' What is wrong with the reasoning?
Hint 1The claim contains the word 'automatically'. Ask what would have to be true for it to hold.
Hint 2Think of an economy that grew at the same rate by exporting minerals.
Hint 3What reached Vietnamese households, and what did the government spend on?
What the strategy cost, and what it did not buy
An evaluation needs the other side, and in this case study the other side is unusually concrete. The strategy attracted foreign firms to assemble imported components for export. That is the strategy working as designed, and it has four consequences.
Most of the exporting is not done by Vietnamese firms. The foreign invested sector accounts for roughly seven in ten dollars of merchandise export income. Export success and domestic industrial capability are therefore not the same thing, and the first can be large while the second stays small.
Much of the value in an export was imported. Around half of the value in Vietnam's gross exports is created inside Vietnam, and in electronics, its largest export category, the share is lower again. The rest is components bought in from Korea, China, Japan and Taiwan. A headline export figure therefore overstates the income gain, which is exactly the calculation the transnational corporations lesson set up.
- Local suppliers
- Wages in the host economy
- Tax to the host government
- Profit reinvested locally
- Imported inputs, leaves the economy
- Overheads paid to the parent, leaves the economy
- Profit sent to the parent, leaves the economy
The numbers behind this graph
| Where it goes | These settings, US$ | Enclave plant, US$ |
|---|---|---|
| Local suppliers | 24.8 | 8.3 |
| Wages in the host economy | 20.0 | 20.0 |
| Tax to the host government | 3.0 | 1.0 |
| Profit reinvested locally | 5.1 | 0.9 |
| Imported inputs | 30.3 | 46.8 |
| Overheads paid to the parent | 5.0 | 5.0 |
| Profit sent to the parent | 11.9 | 18.1 |
- What stays in the host economy
- US$53 of every US$100 of revenue, against US$30 for the enclave plant, a difference of US$23 on the same investment
- Local linkages
- Buying from local suppliers is the largest single lever here, because it turns one foreign plant into demand for domestic firms and transfers standards and technology to them. Host governments pursue it through local content requirements and supplier development programmes, and it is what separates an investment that develops an economy from one that merely occupies land in it.
- Tax actually paid
- A transnational corporation can set the prices at which its own subsidiaries trade with each other, so profit can be reported wherever tax is lowest. Estimates of revenue lost to profit shifting run to hundreds of billions of dollars a year, and developing economies lose the most as a share of their revenue. The agreed 15 per cent global minimum tax, in force in the European Union, the United Kingdom, Japan, Australia and others from 2024, is the policy response.
- Profit sent to the parent
- Remitted profit is recorded in the primary income account, so a large stock of foreign owned capital produces a permanent income outflow. This is why foreign investment improves the capital account and worsens the current account for as long as it earns.
- What the model leaves out
- The jobs themselves, the skills workers take with them when they leave, the export access the parent provides, and the tax revenue from wages rather than profit. All of them favour the investment, and all belong in a balanced judgement.
- Read it as
- A model of where the money goes, not data on any particular firm. The levers are the examinable point.
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
The tax base was deliberately narrowed to attract the investment. Tax holidays and reduced rates for exporters are what made the location competitive, and they mean the government collects less from the most profitable part of its economy than the export figures suggest. The global minimum corporate tax rate of 15 per cent, applying from 2024, removes part of that competition for everyone, which changes the terms of this strategy for the first time in thirty years.
Linkages to domestic firms have been slow to build. The standard example is the largest electronics investor, whose Vietnamese operations ship a substantial share of the country's exports while the number of Vietnamese firms supplying it directly, though it has grown from a handful to a few hundred, remains small relative to the output. Without those linkages, the technology transfer that justifies the tax incentives does not fully arrive.
There are two further costs that any complete evaluation names:
- The environment. Rapid industrialisation on a substantially coal fired grid has produced serious urban air pollution and a fast rising emissions path, alongside the Mekong Delta's exposure to sea level rise and salinity, which is one of the most climate vulnerable regions on earth. The commitments to a net zero target and the transition partnership agreed with a group of donor economies are the counterweight, and, like the climate finance material in the environment lesson, most of the money is offered as loans rather than grants.
- Institutional capacity. State owned enterprises remain a large and, on average, less productive part of the economy, and an intensive anti corruption campaign has slowed the approval of public projects during the years it has run. Both are constraints on the next stage rather than on the stage already completed.
Worked example4 marks
Turning an export figure into an income figure
A foreign owned factory operating in Vietnam exports US$500 million of electronics in a year. Imported components account for 60 per cent of the export value. Of the remaining value, wages paid to Vietnamese workers are US$90 million, purchases from Vietnamese suppliers are US$30 million, and company tax paid in Vietnam is US$10 million. The rest is profit remitted to the parent company.
Calculate the share of the export value retained in Vietnam, and explain what the figure means for an evaluation of the investment strategy.
Separate the imported value from the value added
Imported components are 60 per cent of US$500 million, which is US$300 million. That money leaves immediately and was never Vietnamese income.
Value added in Vietnam is therefore US$500 million minus US$300 million, or US$200 million.
Split the value added between residents and the parent
Of that US$200 million, the amounts staying with Vietnamese residents and the Vietnamese government are the wages, the supplier purchases and the tax:
US$90 million plus US$30 million plus US$10 million is US$130 million.
The remainder, US$70 million, is profit remitted to the parent company.
Express the retained amount as a share of exports
US$130 million divided by US$500 million is 0.26, or 26 per cent.
Answer
26 per cent of the export value is retained in Vietnam.
Is that answer sensible?
The number is the evaluation. The export figure that appears in the trade statistics is US$500 million; the contribution to Vietnamese income is US$130 million. Both are true, and quoting only the first overstates the benefit of the strategy by a factor of nearly four.
It does not follow that the investment was a bad deal. US$130 million of wages, supplier income and tax that would not otherwise exist is a real gain, and the wages are paid at rates well above the farm incomes the workers left. What follows is that the objective for the next stage is the retained share, not the export total: more local sourcing, more skilled work, and a tax base that is not competed away.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
A foreign owned factory exports US$800 million of goods from the host economy in a year. Imported components are 55 per cent of the export value. Of the value added in the host economy, wages paid locally are US$170 million, purchases from local suppliers are US$50 million, and company tax paid locally is US$20 million; the remainder is profit remitted to the parent. Calculate the percentage of the export value retained in the host economy. Give your answer to one decimal place.
Hint 1Take the imported components out first: they were never host economy income.
Hint 2Retained value is what stays with residents and the government, so add wages, local purchases and tax.
Hint 3Express the retained amount as a share of the original export value, not of the value added.
The same openness, seen in a downturn
An economy with trade worth close to twice its GDP has imported the world cycle along with the growth. This is the international business cycle material applied to a single economy, and it is the section that separates a case study from a country profile.
- Fall in export earnings, per cent of GDP
- Fall in GDP, per cent
- Fall in income owned by residents, per cent
- On these settings
- A 10 per cent fall in export market demand takes about 9.0 per cent of GDP off export earnings at Vietnam's level of openness, which works through to about 6.9 per cent of GDP and about 5.4 per cent of the income owned by residents.
- Why the three curves separate
- Export earnings are a gross flow, so the whole fall arrives there. Only the part created inside the economy is GDP, which is why the middle curve is lower: on these settings 55 per cent of the value in exports is made at home, and the imported components simply stop being imported. Some of what is left is profit belonging to foreign owners, which was never income to residents, so the lowest curve is lower again.
- The uncomfortable implication
- The feature that cushions the downturn is the same feature that limits the boom. An economy assembling imported components loses less when orders stop, because less of the value was ever its own. Raising the domestic share of value is the development objective and it raises the exposure at the same time, which is a genuine trade off rather than a problem to be solved.
- What it does not show
- Employment. The jobs are in the assembly, not in the value added, so a fall in orders reaches workers in full even where it reaches national income only partly. Any response using this figure should say so, because the human cost of an export downturn is not proportional to the national accounts effect.
- The recent case
- In 2023 weak demand for electronics, furniture and clothing in the United States and Europe cut Vietnamese export orders sharply and growth fell to about five per cent, well below the rate either side of it. In April 2025 the United States announced a tariff of 46 per cent on Vietnamese goods, suspended and then settled in July 2025 at 20 per cent with a higher rate on goods judged to have been transshipped. Both are demand shocks arriving through a single market, which is the concentration risk that openness carries.
- Read it as
- A model of proportions, not a forecast. The value added share, the foreign invested sector share and the export share of GDP are data; the multiplier and the profit share are assumptions, chosen to be conservative and stated so they can be argued with.
Every slider is a normal range input, so the arrow keys move it one step and Home and End jump to the extremes.
The recent record shows the exposure operating in three different ways:
| Episode | What happened | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| 2020 | Growth of about 2.9 per cent, one of very few economies to grow at all, on early border closure and continued manufacturing | Exposure is not destiny: a supply side that stays open can capture demand that has moved away from economies in lockdown |
| 2021 | Growth of about 2.6 per cent while world output rebounded above six per cent, as the Delta wave closed factories in the southern industrial provinces | The shock ran the other way. A country integrated into supply chains is exposed to its own disruptions being transmitted outward, and to losing orders permanently when it cannot fill them |
| 2023 | Growth of about 5.0 per cent, below the rate either side of it, on weak demand for electronics, furniture and clothing in the United States and Europe | The ordinary case. A demand downturn in two markets reaches an export led economy quickly and directly |
The policy responses are the evaluable part: fiscal support and value added tax reductions through the pandemic; interest rate cuts through 2023 when most central banks were still tightening, which Vietnam could do because its inflation was contained; acceleration of public investment to substitute domestic demand for foreign demand; and the continued signing of trade agreements to spread the market risk.
Common mistake
Treating 2020 as proof that Vietnam had decoupled from the world cycle
Why it happens:
Single year decoupling is usually a timing difference. Vietnam grew in 2020 because its supply side kept operating while competitors were closed, and then grew slowly in 2021 when the position reversed, while the world rebounded. Across the two years the economy is close to where the world cycle would have placed it. This pair of years is the best available illustration of why decoupling has to be argued channel by channel.
What lifts this to a Band 6
The current exposure is concentration in one market. The United States takes close to a third of Vietnam's exports, and in April 2025 it announced a tariff of 46 per cent on Vietnamese goods, suspended and then settled in July 2025 at 20 per cent with a higher rate on goods judged to have been transshipped. A strategy built on access to a single large market is a strategy exposed to that market's politics, which is a point about protection, globalisation and this case study at the same time.
CheckpointAnswer before reading on.
Explain how exposure to the international business cycle has affected an economy other than Australia that you have studied, and assess the effectiveness of that government's response.
Hint 1Openness is exposure; say what the ratio is and why that follows.
Hint 2Use more than one episode, because a single year can be explained away as a coincidence.
Hint 3The assessment needs a criterion: effective at what, and compared with what alternative?
The middle income question
The strategy that took Vietnam from one hundred dollars a person to several thousand is not obviously the strategy that takes it further. Its competitive advantage in assembly is low labour cost, and the wages have been rising, which is the point of the exercise. An economy that has used up that advantage without acquiring another one is in what the development literature calls the middle income trap: too expensive to compete on cost, not yet productive enough to compete on capability.
Nothing about the trap is inevitable. Korea and Taiwan passed through the same position and out of it, and the things they did are known: raise the domestic share of the value in exports, build supplier firms capable of meeting a multinational's standards, move education from universal basic schooling to technical and tertiary capability, and raise productivity in the state owned sector rather than protecting it. Vietnam's published plans name all four, and the constraints on delivering them are the electricity supply, the skills base and the institutional capacity to approve and build infrastructure.
For an examination response this is where the evaluation lands. The strategies were highly effective against the objective they were set, which was to escape very low income through integration, and they are only partly suited to the objective that follows, which is to capture more of the value of what the economy already produces.
How to run any case study under exam conditions
The economy is a choice; the structure is not. Whatever economy you study, a response to this dot point needs the same five moves:
- The starting point, in one or two sentences, so the growth rate means something.
- The strategies, grouped, with dates. Groups are retrievable under pressure; a list of nine policies is not.
- The results, split into growth and development, with the development indicators named separately.
- The costs and limits, quantified where possible. This is where most responses are thin and where the marks separate.
- The judgement, tied to a criterion. Effective against what objective, and compared to what alternative?
Where this sits
This lesson closes the content of Topic 1. It draws on the trade, investment and transnational corporations lesson for retained value, on the international business cycle lesson for the exposure, on the environmental sustainability lesson for the emissions path and the transition finance, and on the international organisations lesson for the WTO accession and the minimum tax rate. The essay plan below is priority 8, and the material here is also the evidence base for priority 12 on globalisation and priority 10 on differences in development.
Putting it together
Essay planpriority 8 of 16 · 20 marks
For an economy other than Australia, analyse the impact of globalisation and of government strategies on economic growth and development.
- Analyse
- Break the situation into its parts and show how they relate and affect each other.
- Thesis
- Globalisation raised Vietnam's growth and development further and faster than any plausible alternative, but it did so through a specific mechanism, foreign owned assembly of imported components for export, and that mechanism determines both the size of the gain and the limits now binding. Government strategy is not separable from globalisation in this case: the integration was a policy choice, sequenced deliberately, and its results are the results of the sequencing.
Globalisation raised growth by supplying the three things a very poor economy cannot supply itself: capital, technology and a market.
The counterargument is conceded and then used: the volatility is the price of the mechanism that produced the level, and the level is very large. The comparison that matters is not Vietnam against a stable Vietnam, it is Vietnam against the closed, planned economy of 1986 with inflation above 300 per cent and rice imports.
- Theory
- Output per person rises when capital per worker and productivity rise. Domestic saving in a low income economy is too small to fund the investment, so importing capital raises the investment rate above the saving rate, and foreign direct investment brings the technology and the management with it. Access to world markets removes the constraint of a small domestic market, allowing scale that domestic demand could not support.
- Diagram
- The Vietnam record figure, with the published income path against a comparison path at an ordinary growth rate, so that the part requiring explanation is visible.
- Evidence
- Income per person from about one hundred United States dollars in 1990 to the order of several thousand today; growth averaging six to seven per cent a year for three decades; trade worth close to twice GDP; disbursed foreign direct investment of the order of twenty five billion United States dollars in 2024 against registered commitments of the order of thirty eight billion; foreign invested firms accounting for roughly seven in ten dollars of merchandise export income; supply chain diversification away from China accelerating inflows after 2018.
- Against
- The same openness imported the world cycle. Growth fell to about 2.6 per cent in 2021 while world output rebounded above six per cent, and to about 5.0 per cent in 2023 on weak demand in the United States and Europe.
Government strategy decided what globalisation did, because the sequence of reform determined who could take advantage of the opening.
The concession is the more sophisticated position. Policy was necessary and not sufficient, which is precisely why the case study is used as evidence in the differences in development essay rather than as a recipe.
- Theory
- Openness is an opportunity, not an outcome. Whether an economy converts it into growth depends on whether it has the labour, the infrastructure and the institutions that mobile capital requires, and those are supplied by domestic policy. Reform sequencing matters because the factor released by one reform is the input to the next.
- Diagram
- No figure; this paragraph is the mechanism, and it is best set out as the chain from land reform through released labour to export manufacturing.
- Evidence
- Doi Moi from 1986 and household land use rights from 1988, moving Vietnam from rice importer to one of the world's largest rice exporters; the foreign investment law of 1987 and the export processing zones that followed; normalised trade with the United States in 2001, WTO accession in 2007, the CPTPP from 2019, the European Union agreement from 2020 and RCEP from 2022; near universal electrification and universal primary and lower secondary schooling; results in international assessments above what the income level predicts.
- Against
- Other economies adopted similar policies without similar results, so the policies cannot be a sufficient explanation. Political stability, a young and literate population, and proximity to the East Asian manufacturing network were conditions Vietnam did not create.
The growth became development because of what it was made of and what the government spent it on.
This is the paragraph where the distinction between growth and development is demonstrated rather than asserted. State the mechanism, that labour intensive export manufacturing pays income into households directly, then qualify it distributionally.
- Theory
- Growth raises living standards only if the income reaches households and if it is converted into the health and education that development is measured by. Labour intensive growth distributes income through wages directly; capital intensive or resource based growth does not, and relies on the budget to redistribute it.
- Diagram
- The growth against development figure from the indicators lesson, which separates a movement along the frontier from a movement of the frontier.
- Evidence
- Extreme poverty from more than half the population in the early 1990s to a small fraction, with national multidimensional poverty in the low single digits; life expectancy in the mid seventies; the high human development group from 2019; effectively universal electrification; manufacturing wages well above the farm incomes the workers left.
- Against
- The gains are uneven. Ethnic minority communities and the northern uplands remain far behind the industrial south and east on every indicator, and the informal sector is large, so a substantial share of workers has no social insurance.
The cost of the strategy is that the economy exports far more than it earns, and the tax base was narrowed to make that happen.
The evaluative move is to accept the counterargument and change the objective. The strategy was right for the starting point and the question now is the retained share, which is why local sourcing requirements, skills policy and the minimum tax rate are the current agenda rather than more incentives.
- Theory
- Gross exports are not income. Only the value added inside the economy is GDP, and only the part of that value accruing to residents is national income, so an assembly economy's export figure overstates its gain. Tax competition for mobile investment transfers part of the remaining benefit from the host government to the investor.
- Diagram
- The retained value figure, splitting a subsidiary's revenue into imported inputs, wages, local purchases, tax and profit remitted to the parent.
- Evidence
- Around half of the value in gross exports created inside Vietnam, and lower in electronics, the largest export category; foreign invested firms responsible for roughly seven in ten dollars of merchandise exports; corporate tax holidays and reduced rates for exporters; the number of Vietnamese firms supplying the largest electronics investor directly growing from a handful to a few hundred but still small relative to its output; the global minimum corporate tax rate of 15 per cent applying from 2024, which removes part of the tax competition.
- Against
- A low retained share of a very large number is still a transformative amount of wage income, supplier income and tax that would not otherwise exist, and the alternative was not a higher retained share but no investment at all.
What comes next is the real test, because the advantage that produced the growth is being used up.
The judgement belongs here, stated rather than implied. The strategies were highly effective against the objective of escaping very low income, and are only partly suited to the objective of capturing more of the value of what the economy already produces, which is a conclusion about fit rather than a verdict of success or failure.
- Theory
- A cost based comparative advantage erodes as the success raises wages. Sustaining growth then requires a productivity based advantage, which needs domestic firms capable of supplying multinationals, a workforce educated beyond the basic level, and infrastructure ahead of demand. Where those do not arrive, growth slows at middle income.
- Diagram
- The export led exposure figure, which shows both sides at once: the same openness that delivered the growth is the channel through which a foreign demand shock arrives.
- Evidence
- Rising manufacturing wages eroding the cost advantage; electricity supply constraints during industrial expansion; the coal heavy grid against a net zero commitment and a transition partnership funded largely by loans; state owned enterprises remaining a large and less productive share of output; the United States taking close to a third of exports, with the tariff of 46 per cent announced in April 2025 suspended and settled in July 2025 at 20 per cent, and a higher rate on transshipped goods.
- Against
- Vietnam is moving up the range of what it makes, from clothing and footwear to electronics and, increasingly, more complex components, and Korea and Taiwan show the transition is possible from a similar position.
Judgement
On the objective that was set, escaping very low income through integration, the strategies were highly effective, and the evidence is the combination of three decades of six to seven per cent growth with poverty falling from more than half the population to a small fraction and entry into the high human development group. On the objective that follows, capturing more of the value of what the economy already exports, the same strategies are only partly suited, because tax incentives, an assembly specialisation and a low domestic value added share are the cost of the first objective and the obstacle to the second.
The full response also needs: Define growth and development separately before the first paragraph, since the question names both. If the question is set on globalisation generally rather than on one economy, priority 12 is the plan and this case study becomes its evidence. If it is set on why economies develop differently, priority 10 is the plan and Vietnam is the positive case against which the constrained economies are compared.
Exam question
Hardest asked · about 12 min
6 marks
Analyse the impact of globalisation on economic growth and development in an economy other than Australia.
Hint 1Analyse means show the components and their relationships, so the mechanism has to be visible in every paragraph.
Hint 2The question names growth and development separately; answer both, and explain why they moved together or apart.
Hint 3Six marks will not be earned by a one sided account. Include the limits of the same mechanism.
Where students lose marks on this one
Narrating the economy's history in chronological order
Why it happens: The case study is learnt as a story, and the story has an obvious order.
Organise by mechanism: the growth channel, the conversion into development, the limits. Dates then appear as evidence inside an argument rather than as a timeline.
Concluding that globalisation was simply positive
Why it happens: The growth and poverty figures are dramatic and point one way.
An analyse question wants the relationship. The same mechanism that produced the gain produced the low retained share and the exposure, and saying that is the sixth mark.
Written for this site.
Through a marker’s eyes
6 marks
Analyse the impact of globalisation on economic growth and development in an economy other than Australia.
The attempt
2 out of 6
Globalisation has had a big impact on Vietnam. Since Doi Moi in 1986 Vietnam has opened up its economy to trade and foreign investment. It joined the WTO in 2007 and has signed many free trade agreements such as the CPTPP and the EVFTA. As a result Vietnam has grown very fast, with growth of around 6 to 7 per cent per year, and poverty has fallen dramatically. Many TNCs such as Samsung have invested in Vietnam and built factories there, creating lots of jobs. Vietnam is now a middle income country and its HDI has improved a lot. Overall globalisation has been very positive for Vietnam and has improved both economic growth and economic development.
What the marker sees
Two marks. The economy is chosen, the reforms are dated and the main integration events are named correctly, which is the identification requirement. Nothing is analysed. Growth and development are both asserted to have improved, with no mechanism connecting the foreign investment to the growth or the growth to the development, and with no figure attached to either beyond the growth rate. The development claim rests on the letters "HDI" without a value or a category. The response also reaches an entirely one sided conclusion, which a six mark analyse question will not reward: there is no retained value, no exposure, no distributional qualification. It reads as a summary of what Vietnam did rather than an account of how globalisation produced a result.
The same answer, fixed
6 out of 6
Globalisation transformed Vietnam's growth and development by supplying the capital, technology and market access that a very poor economy cannot supply itself, and the mechanism by which it did so explains both the size of the gain and its limits.
The growth channel is foreign direct investment into export manufacturing. Domestic saving in 1986 was far too small to fund the necessary investment, so the foreign investment law of 1987, the export processing zones, and tax incentives for exporters brought in the capital and the technology together. Trade agreements then guaranteed the market: normalised trade with the United States in 2001, WTO accession in 2007, the CPTPP from 2019 and the European Union agreement from 2020. The result was growth averaging six to seven per cent a year for three decades, income per person rising from about one hundred United States dollars in 1990 to the order of several thousand today, and trade worth close to twice GDP.
That growth became development because of what it was made of. Export manufacturing is labour intensive, so the income reached households directly as wages well above the farm incomes those workers left, rather than only through the budget. Extreme poverty fell from more than half the population in the early 1990s to a small fraction, life expectancy reached the mid seventies, and Vietnam entered the high human development group in 2019. Public investment in electrification and universal basic schooling supplied the inputs that both the factories and the development gains required, which is why the two moved together here and not in resource exporting economies with similar growth rates.
The same integration imposes two limits. The first is the retained share: foreign invested firms earn roughly seven in ten dollars of merchandise export income, and only around half of the value in gross exports is created inside Vietnam, less in electronics, so the export total substantially overstates the income gain. The second is exposure: growth fell to about 2.6 per cent in 2021 when the Delta wave closed southern factories as the world rebounded, and to about 5.0 per cent in 2023 on weak demand in the United States and Europe, with close to a third of exports going to a single market that announced a 46 per cent tariff in April 2025, settled in July at 20 per cent.
The impact is therefore large, real and specific in kind. Globalisation delivered the fastest escape from low income available to Vietnam, through labour intensive foreign owned assembly, and that same mechanism determines what is now binding: a low share of the value retained, and a cycle imported along with the market.
Exam question
Hardest asked · about 25 min
10 marks
Evaluate the effectiveness of the strategies used to promote economic growth and economic development in an economy other than Australia.
Hint 1Evaluate needs a criterion stated early: effective against which objective?
Hint 2Group the strategies, then judge each group, rather than listing them and judging at the end.
Hint 3The strongest evaluations separate the objective that was met from the objective that follows.
Where students lose marks on this one
Describing the strategies thoroughly and evaluating only in the final paragraph
Why it happens: Evaluation is taught as a conclusion, and the descriptive material is the part that was revised.
Judge each group as you finish it. A response that evaluates only at the end has spent most of its marks on description.
Treating the middle income trap as a prediction that growth will stall
Why it happens: The phrase sounds like a diagnosis rather than a risk.
It is a description of a position, not a forecast. Korea and Taiwan passed through the same position, so the useful point is what the transition requires, not whether the trap is inevitable.
Omitting the development strategies and evaluating only the growth strategies
Why it happens: Growth policies are more memorable and the evidence is more dramatic.
The dot point and the question both name development. Electrification, schooling and the poverty programmes are strategies, and they carry the marks for the second half.
Written for this site.